Cheetah Mobile Responds to Kochava’s Misleading Statements on Advertising

MUMBAI: Cheetah Mobile Inc. (NYSE: CMCM) ("Cheetah Mobile" or the "Company"), a leading mobile internet company with global market coverage, today announced plans to take legal action against mobile app attribution and analytics company Kochava. As per the company, Kochava has provided false information and opinions about Cheetah Mobile’s advertising system to the media, leading to a sharp decline in the company’s stock price. The company believes that Kochava’s actions are misleading and completely without merit.

Kochava has accused Cheetah Mobile’s apps of engaging in a fraudulent advertising practice known as “click injection.” Kochava has based this assertion on a series of tests carried out in a simulated smartphone environment, the results of which were shared with Cheetah Mobile and the media in a series of videos. However, upon analyzing the videos and other evidence, the company discovered that Kochava’s testing methods contained fundamental mistakes, leading to a number of false or misleading conclusions, including:

1. In the evidence provided to Cheetah Mobile, click injection occurs whether Cheetah Mobile apps are installed or not. It is unrelated to Cheetah Mobile’s apps.

On November 27, BuzzFeed News published the following statement, attributed to Grant Simmons, the head of client analytics for Kochava:

“The explanation provided by Cheetah refers to SDKs meant for ad delivery in-app. The fraud detailed in our research and the related article does not look at in-app ad delivery from the apps in question, but instead the syndication of fraudulent signals taking place on the device when the apps are present," he said in an email.

In the videos, Kochava first opens a Cheetah Mobile utility app while a large number of apps and SDKs unrelated to Cheetah Mobile’s apps are open, such as Appcoach and Webeye. These ad SDKs have no relationship with Cheetah Mobile’s utility apps. Kochava then uses the smartphone simulator to install a new app, which causes Appcoach or Webeye to report the installation to Kochava. But since Appcoach and Webeye are not installed inside Cheetah Mobile’s apps, this action has nothing to do with Cheetah Mobile.

In fact, in the above simulation environment, even if you uninstall all of Cheetah Mobile’s apps, an attribution report is generated. But by deliberately opening Cheetah Mobile’s utility apps within the simulation environment, Kochava is giving the erroneous impression that the reports generated by the third-party SDKs are related to Cheetah Mobile’s apps. Therefore, the evidence presented in Kochava’s videos is inaccurate and misleading.

2. Kochava has alleged that all of relevant advertising SDKs embedded in Cheetah Mobile’s products are owned and developed by Cheetah Mobile, but in fact, nearly 97% of Cheetah Mobile’s overseas utility revenue comes from third-party advertising SDKs. These third-party SDKs can be found on all of the world’s major advertising platforms and are being used on numerous mainstream global apps. The SDKs are unrelated to Cheetah Mobile.

The following statement appears in the same BuzzFeed article mentioned above:

The SDK involved in the suspect activity is actually owned and developed by Cheetah, not by third parties, according to Kochava.

Kochava’s videos show that once a new app is installed, advertising SDKs on Cheetah Mobile apps, such as Batmobi, Duapps and Altmob, report the download data to Kochava, which then determines attribution based on this data.

Cheetah Mobile cooperates with all of the major global advertising platforms. Every platform provides ads on Cheetah Mobile’s apps through their own SDKs embedded on Cheetah Mobile apps. The SDKs and third-party attribution platforms work together to determine attribution of app installations. Cheetah Mobile is not part of this process.

Kochava is an app attribution company, whose business model is based on determining installation attribution from third-party SDKs. Therefore, they fully understand that attribution is unrelated to the app itself. In their videos, they are misleading the media to believe that Cheetah Mobile is engaged in fraudulent practices.

3. The media and Kochava intentionally exaggerated the relationship between Cheetah Mobile and Kika Tech to intentionally overstate Cheetah Mobile’s influence over Kika Tech.

The article states that:

The other app is owned by Kika Tech, a Chinese company now headquartered in Silicon Valley that received a significant investment from Cheetah in 2016.

This statement is misleading. Kika Tech is just one of more than 80 companies that the Company has invested in. Cheetah Mobile owns less than a five percent stake in Kika Tech and has no seats on the board. Furthermore, the Company has zero operational control over Kika Tech.

4. Kochava has severely damaged the reputation of a public company with its unfounded claims. The Company reserves the right to take legal action against Kochava.

In the same article, Grant Simmons, head of client analytics for Kochava, is quoted as saying:

“This is theft — no other way to say it.”

The company finds this comment extremely hostile and outrageous.

Cheetah Mobile is a leading global app developer with numerous global partnerships. In the third quarter 2018, 70.31% of the company’s overseas utility revenue came from Google and Facebook’s ad SDKs, while 26.06% came from other mainstream global ad platform SDKs. These SDKs are used on mainstream apps throughout the world.

Cheetah Mobile’s success is based on long-term steady development and providing users with a better user experience. The company is dedicated to building a healthy development model. The company is also committed to complying with all relevant Google policies, GDPR, laws and regulations.

Gaia Guan, CEO of Moca Technology, a global mobile advertising platform focused on India and developing markets, said, “Cheetah Mobile is a pioneering Chinese mobile app company overseas. They are constantly focused on improving the product experience and ad experience for users, while strictly adhering to industry regulations and standards. In our many years working with Cheetah Mobile, they have always put the user and advertisers first, while treating their partnerships fairly and transparently.”

5. After investigating our third-party SDKs, the company has removed Batmobi and Duapps from its apps

Cheetah Mobile has cooperated with the third-party security firm Threat Hunter to investigate the situation, particularly regarding the advertising SDKs featured in the videos that could potentially possess attribution risks, namely Batmobi and Duapps. To be cautious, the company has proactively removed them from its updated apps. Cheetah Mobile continues to investigate, and will suspend cooperation with any SDK providers that are found to be engaging in fraudulent activities.

Kochava has a relatively small market share. In 2016, Kochava publicized its cooperation with Cheetah Mobile multiple times to raise its prestige, while seeking to expand its cooperation with the company. Cheetah Mobile ceased its collaboration with Kochava in September 2016.

Cheetah Mobile rejects Kochava’s accusations as baseless. The company will continue to place even more value on advertisers’ rights and making sure the industry develops in a healthy way. As one of the top publishers in the world, Cheetah Mobile pledges to redouble its efforts towards monitoring and detecting potential issues within third-party ad SDKs and its own products in order to ensure maximum benefits for advertisers and users alike.

Latest Reads
Vodafone Idea partners with cii techsaksham project for msmes to adapt in the digital age

MUMBAI: Vodafone Idea, in partnership with Confederation of Indian Industry (CII), Ministry of MSMEs and other tech giants like Intel, Dell, HP, WhatsApp, and Banking Partner YES BANK have already initiated an exclusive digital project TECHSAKSHAM- focused on supporting MSMEs in India to become...

MAM Marketing MAM
Mahindra Susten promotes greater sustainability with #CutTheCrap campaign

MUMBAI: India’s leading solar energy company, Mahindra Susten Private Limited, initiated a unique campaign #CutTheCrap to reinforce the importance of reusing and recycling for a sustainable future. The concept behind #CutTheCrap was to talk about waste segregation and its benefits to the...

MAM Marketing MAM
Grasim Industries appoint Srishti Sawhney as President and Global Brand Head, Pulp & Fibre

MUMBAI: Grasim Industries has appointed Srishti Sawhney as the President and Global Brand Head for Pulp & Fibre Business. In her new role, Sawhney’s mandate will be to strengthen and enhance the communication and branding of the ingredient brand Liva. She will also chart out the strategy to...

MAM Marketing MAM
Pantene launches its new #freedomhair campaign, inspiring girls to write their own story

MUMBAI: These are undoubtedly transformative times for young girls around the world, and Indian girls are also fuelling the winds of change. Caught between the ways of a traditional culture - that can get prescriptive on aspects like what they ought to wear, study, whom to marry and even how to...

MAM Marketing MAM
EaseMyTrip Joining Hands with Malaysia Tourism to promote the Destination

MUMBAI:, (EMT) one of the leading players in the Online Travel Aggregators segment, has joined hands with Malaysia Tourism Board to promote the destination amongst Indian tourists and offer customized tour packages for Malaysia at attractive rates. For promoting tourism in Malaysia,...

MAM Marketing MAM
Flying Machine, Dentsu India stretch the limit with new campaign for F-LITE denim

MUMBAI: Dentsu India, the brand solutions agency from Dentsu Aegis Network, has launched a new campaign to introduce Flying Machine’s new product, the F-Lite denim.

MAM Marketing MAM
Manyavar appoints Ranveer Singh as new face of brand

MUMBAI: Indian-wear brand Manyavar has announced the name of Bollywood actor Ranveer Singh as its new brand ambassador. As a part of the association, Ranveer Singh will be seen endorsing the brand’s latest festive collection through a slew of commercials spread across television, digital, and...

MAM Media and Advertising People
Why digital marketing needs a holistic approach

Digital marketing has taken over the traditional methods of interacting with consumers for brands and businesses in an overwhelming manner. This has led to a major shift in the marketing and advertising industry. The concept of digital marketing is not only new and intimidating but also rapidly...

MAM Media and Advertising Digital Agencies
Video hosting, ad distribution, monetisation solutions on one platform: VDO.AI

The world of video is constantly changing and evolving. Brands and platforms are looking for interactive solutions to monetise and distribute their content. The new platform of VDO.AI helps clients to target exactly these aspects from one point.

MAM Digital

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories