Delhi High Court refuses to stay streaming of Netflix series 'Hasmukh'

Netflix lawyers argued that the web series is a work of fiction


MUMBAI: The Delhi high court on Monday dismissed a plea seeking an ad-interim injunction restraining the streaming of the episodes of the web series Hasmukh.

The application against the series was filed by lawyer Ashutosh Dubey, who charged that its fourth episode contained derogatory remarks against the lawyer community.

The series, starring Vir Das, Ranvir Shorey and others, has been produced and owned by Applause Entertainment.

The web series is a dark comedy thriller revolving around a fictional character named ‘Hasmukh’ (Vir Das), an aspiring comedian and the protagonist. The protagonist in the series possesses a unique compulsion to kill people just before his on-stage stand-up act, which enables him to give a great performance and specifically relates his stand-up comedy act to the person he killed.

Dubey took objection to the utterance of the protagonist during a stand-up comedy performance from the fourth episode of the web series. The lawyer alleged in his suit that the dialogues in the said scene are highly disparaging, defamatory and bring disrepute to the legal profession and lawyers in the eyes of the general public.

Netflix lawyers argued that the web series is a work of fiction and explained to the court its brief plot line.

The defense lawyers also submitted that a class of persons cannot be defamed as a class, nor can an individual be defamed by general reference to a class to which the individual belongs. So, they argued, the lawyers as a community cannot be defamed as a “class of persons”, nor can the plaintiff be defamed by a general reference to lawyers.

The defendants also submitted that Article 19 (1) (a) of the Indian Constitution guaranteed the freedom of speech and expression which includes the creative freedom to express one's views and opinions and although the said right is not absolute since the present case would not qualify as defamation, it cannot be restricted.

Dismissing the application for ad-interim injunction, the court observed that the impugned comment is satirical “with regard to the lawyers taken as a class and is not with regard to any determinate definite or identifiable group of lawyers."

“Further, if an ad interim injunction is granted, it would amount to interference in the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by our constitution to the defendants,” stated the court.

The very essence of democracy, observed the court, is that a creative artist is given the liberty to project the picture of the society in a manner he perceives. “One of the prime forms of exposing the ills of the society is by portraying a satirical picture of the same. Stand-up comedians perform that very purpose. In their portrayal they use satire and exaggerate the ills to an extent that it becomes a ridicule. In the humorous portrayal of the ills of the society the stand-up comedians use satire.”

Applause Entertainment, the IP owner of the web series, was represented by senior counsel Sandeep Sethi, briefed by a team from ANM Global Inc comprising Nidhish Mehrotra, Anushree Rauta, Piyush Joshi and Chirag Luthria. 

Latest Reads

ABP Studios' ‘Karkhanisanchi Waari’ to premiere on SonyLIV on 10 Dec

Mumbai: ABP Studios’ co-produced Marathi feature film "Karkhanisanchi Waari" (Ashes on a Road Trip) will stream exclusively on SonyLIV, 10 December onwards.

iWorld Over The Top Services
Games24x7 onboards Rajat Bansal as chief technology officer

Mumbai: Amazon Lockers' former head of engineering Rajat Bansal has joined online gaming company Games24x7 as chief technology officer (CTO). A key addition to the company’s leadership team, Bansal will be responsible for outlining and implementing the company’s technological vision and ensuring...

iWorld Over The Top Services
How short video apps took media brands to masses in 2021

“It came, it saw, it conquered...” the statement perfectly describes the meteoric rise of ByteDance-owned short video app TikTok in India. Such was the momentum created by it that by December 2020 – that just six months after TikTok was banned - the market was flooded by its Indian counterparts...

iWorld Over The Top Services
GUEST COLUMN: How to combat streaming piracy with OTT’s broken protocol?

With vast sums of money to be made, it’s not surprising that streaming pirates are continually upping their game to keep their highly profitable illegal businesses afloat.  A recent global study conducted by Ampere Analysis for Synamedia found that sports streaming piracy alone is worth over $28...

iWorld Over The Top Services
Disney+ Hotstar appoints Parita Razdan as head of growth strategy and Ops

Disney+ Hotstar has appointed Parita Razdan as head of growth strategy and Ops. She begins her new role in December. She was previously vice president, pricing and customer intelligence at Star TV Network for three years. Prior to joining Star India.

iWorld Over The Top Services
HBO Max India onboards Arjun Nohwar as country GM

Mumbai: WarnerMedia-owned streaming service platform HBO Max has brought Arjun Nohwar on board as country general manager (GM) for India.

iWorld Over The Top Services
Netflix announces six new mobile game titles launching in December

Mumbai: Netflix has announced six mobile game titles that will be launched on its platform in December. The streaming giant is yet to announce the official launch date of the games. The titles include "Ashphalt Xtreme," "Hextech Mayhem," "Knittens," "Wonderputt Forever," "Arcanium: Rise of Akhan,"...

iWorld Over The Top Services
Disney+ Hotstar bags 20 nominations at Filmfare OTT awards

Mumbai: Disney+ Hotstar has bagged 20 nominations across 12 categories at the Filmfare OTT awards this year. Four Hotstar Specials’ are in the race to win the award including "Grahan" which has received 10 nominations, followed by "Criminal Justice: Behind Closed Doors" with six, "OK Computer" with...

iWorld Over The Top Services
Chingari App announces strategic partnership with Snow Records

Short video app Chingari has entered into a partnership with Snow Records, an independent newly launched music label. As part of the collaboration, Chingari app will promote all new albums to be released by Snow Records.

iWorld Over The Top Services

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories

* indicates required