Statutory licensing: Mumbai High Court rules in favour of labels, against music streamers

Internet music streaming and digital downloads are not covered under the statutory licensing provi


MUMBAI: Music labels are rubbing their hands in glee. Reason: recently record label Tips Industries won a landmark judgement against Airtel’s music streaming service Wynk in the Mumbai High Court.

The court ruled that internet music streaming and digital downloads are not covered under the statutory licensing provision which is meant for TV and radio broadcasters of the Copyright Act, 1957.  This means that all streaming services will have to perforce conclude licensing agreements with record labels.

Says Indian Music Industry (IMI) president Blaise Fernandes: “This decision confirms IMI’s consistent stand that internet streaming services are not covered under Section 31D of the Copyright Act,1957. As an industry, we noted the intention of our parliament to provide involuntary licensing benefits under the Copyright Act, 1957 and are very encouraged that the honourable court has now clarified the intention of our lawmakers did not include streaming services under the statutory licensing scheme.“

Adds Tips Industries managing director Kumar Taurani: "This is true justice and I humbly bow in respect to the Indian judiciary. It’s been a long and trying process but we prevailed and justice was served. I'm very happy that the Indian judiciary believed in not only Tips but the whole music industry and vindicated what was right. We are not in business to arm twist or provoke unnecessary actions onto our partners in the OTT business; but in our case, in particular, Wynk was very unfair. Wynk as an internet music streaming service has valuations in millions, despite that they still refuse to pay to music labels a few crore rupees for the labels’ music content, which is at the heart of Wynk’s OTT streaming service. And without a heart, what good is a body? OTT players, until this judgement, continued to corner us.”

It was way back in 2017 that both Wynk – which has about 100 million subs - and Tips failed to agree on licensing terms for the latter’s music. Taurani had then asked the streamer to pull down its music catalogue from the service. Wynk sought the cover of section 31D claiming that it was a broadcasting organisation and hence was eligible for a statutory licence allowing it to broadcast Tips music. Taurani then filed suits against the streamer in January 2018.

The Mumbai High Court, which was hearing the case, finally ruled in favour of Tips saying that Wynk was not eligible to claim the statutory broadcasting licence provision. It issued an injunction forbidding it from streaming Tips music without getting a licence from it.

The court stated” “Such use of the copyrighted works... without obtaining a license from the owners of the copyright amounts to usurpation of the exclusive rights of the owners to commercially rent, sell or communicate to the public their sound recordings. This interpretation does not meet the legislative purpose behind enacting Section 31-D.”

Attempts to reach Wynk were not successful, but industry observers expect it to appeal against the order at higher courts.  Another case which is slated to come up for hearing in June  is the Warner Music group vs Spotify, which has also taken cover under section 31D provision for its India launch.

Latest Reads

Eros Now partners with ROKKI to offer AirAsia WiFi users best of Indian entertainment and discounted subscription plan vouchers

MUMBAI: Eros Now, a premier Indian OTT entertainment platform with more than 154 million registered users, today announced its partnership with ROKKI, AirAsia’s in-flight WiFi service provider. The partnership will provide access to the on-demand platform’s programming using guests’ own devices...

iWorld Over The Top Services
The Format that changed TV forever In India and across The Globe Turns 20!

MUMBAI: Big Brother, (aka Bigg Boss in India) - the original reality format - celebrates its landmark 20th birthday today.  On the 16th September 1999, nine Housemates moved in a purpose-built house in the Netherlands, equipped with 24 cameras and no contact with the outside world to be watched 24...

iWorld Over The Top Services
ZEE5 partners with quaero to Orchestrate its complex customer data

MUMBAI: ZEE5, India’s fastest growing ConTech brand today announced its partnership with Quaero, an Enterprise Customer Data Platform provider, to power its big data capabilities and mine customer insights.

iWorld Over The Top Services
Through its latest marketing innovation, ALTBalaji launches off by taking the interactive ooh route for mom: mission on mars

MUMBAI: ALTBalaji, India's leading home-grown OTT platform, in their latest bid to capture the imagination and attention of the viewers has launched a campaign unlike any other by adopting an innovative OOH (out-of-home advertising) hoarding to promote its recent original M-O-M: Mission on Mars....

iWorld Over The Top Services
WhatsApp offers to track 'dubious' individuals for Indian govt

MUMBAI: Facebook vice president of global affairs and communications Nick Clegg met home minister Amit Shah, national security adviser Ajit Doval, IT and communications minister Ravi Shankar Prasad and commerce minister Piyush Goyal regarding the dispute over traceability of messages in WhatApp....

iWorld Social Media
Disney CEO Bob Iger resigns from Apple's board

MUMBAI: Disney CEO Bob Iger has stepped down from Apple’s board of directors the day Apple announced the price and release date for its streaming service. The resignation comes at a time when both the companies are upping the game in the streaming business.

iWorld Over The Top Services
Zomato forays into online video space, to launch 18 original shows

The streaming war is not limited to media houses anymore. From e-commerce apps to online cab-ride services are also jumping on the band-wagon to keep consumers engaged. Now, food delivery app Zomato has announced its foray into web streaming with 18 original shows over the next three months.

iWorld Over The Top Services
BookMyShow's campaign around the movie Dream Girl Creates a Stir on Social Media

MUMBAI: BookMyShow, India’s leading entertainment destination, has launched a fun, quirky and innovative marketing campaign for Ayushmann Khurrana’s upcoming film ‘Dream Girl’. The campaign through its smart approach has managed to perform exceedingly well and capture people’s attention. This...

iWorld Social Media
Omidyar Network India, Monitor Deloitte launch report on Indian data privacy landscape

Omidyar Network India, an investment firm focused on social impact, today launched a new report titled “Unlocking the potential of India’s Data Economy: Practices, Privacy and Governance”, in partnership with Monitor Deloitte. The first of its kind study analyses data practices and governance by...

iWorld Social Media

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories