'Name and shame delinquent channels'

MUMBAI: Media buying and planning (advertising) agencies and brands reacted strongly or cautiously when it came to commenting on famous yet delinquent television channels suspected of wrongdoing by India's only TV ratings points (TRP)  body. Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC), the only television audience measurement body in India, temporarily suspended the review of viewership of three news channels. BARC had communicated to all the broadcasters that ratings for India News, TV9 Telegu and V6 News were suspended for four weeks owing to suspected mala fide practices.

This decision may have had a bearing on advertising on the channels in question. Some industry experts were direct and forthcoming in their reactions, others were cautious, while some chose not to comment on the issue.

Requesting anonymity, a senior media planner told that the decision could have a mixed impact on the advertising revenue of the channels. There would be companies who believe in a particular channel since a long time. They may not get swayed by this temporary phenomenon. Companies who might want to launch a national campaign may take a channel's current ratings into account before making their decision. Then, there are regional advertisers who want to see the effect of advertising on the ground -- they may not take the BARC review into account at all. There would be some advertisers who would want to wait and watch for a while -- 2-3 weeks before taking any decision.

Dentsu Aegis chairman Ashish Bhasin lauded the BARC decision not to review certain errant channels for a period of time. "It is a bold step taken by BARC to name and shame the mischievous entities." It sends out a warning message to the channels to behave, and will act as a deterrent for other possible mischief-mongers that could spoil the purity of the currency for a Rs 20000 crore annual TV advertising business in India, Bhasin said.

About the impact on advertising, Bhasin said that the reputation of the errant channels would be affected owing to the suspension of review. "Although I am unaware of which channels were involved in what kind of wrongdoing, the channels would be disadvantaged due to the BARC action. In the medium to long term, the action would prove to be detrimental to the channels vis-a-vis advertising because the client decides to put his money on the basis of clear feedback and seeks value for every pie invested," Bhasin added.

Some experts were rather vocal about change in their approach. "I will certainly not recommend these channels for my clients," an Initiative Media (formerly Lintas Media) business director told

The business director said she would rather advise other substitute (surrogate) channels so that her clients do not suffer. She agreed that the BARC India decision may not directly impact regional and local brands, but, she said, media planners who would draw up annual national strategies for their respective clients would certainly keep the BARC India's suspension decision in mind.

However, some  client-companies were rather cautious. HDFC Life senior executive vice-president, marketing, analytics, digital & e-commerce Sanjay Tripathy said: "The channels concerned are denying any wrong-doing at this point. However, if the channels are found guilty of any wrongdoing as suggested in media reports, it is only fair then that they face the consequences. Prima facie, we believe before taking such a stance, due process would have been followed by the authorities by BARC (India) and should wait to this matter to be clarified before taking any hasty decisions."  

For the sake of an independent and unbiased article, IPG Mediabrands CEO Shashi Sinha chose not to comment since he chaired the technical committee of BARC India.

"Advertisers who do not utilise the services of media buying agencies may continue to advertise on the errant channels," said Madison World chairman Sam Balsara. "But, advertisers who take the help of agencies that use scientific methods of calculating GRPs (gross rating point) would over a period of time keep away from such channels," he added. To a question whether advertisers would mind the temporary suspension, Sam said, "They would and they should."

Also Read :

BARC India suspends three errant channels' review

Latest Reads
Colgate remains India’s #1 Most Trusted Oral Care brand, for the 8th consecutive year, in Nielsen’s consumer survey

Colgate-Palmolive (India) Limited, the market leader in Oral Care, has been ranked as the Most Trusted Brand in the Oral Care category for the 8th year in a row, as per the India’s Most Trusted Brands Survey 2018, conducted by Nielsen and commissioned by Economic Times - Brand Equity.

MAM Marketing MAM
Gautam Gambhir & give warm send-off to 15 cricketers for Perth, Australia

Padma Shri Gautam Gambhir and gave a warm send-off to 15 of the 33 talented aspiring cricketers who have qualified for the 5-year cricket scholarship and are selected to go to Guildford Grammar School, Perth, Australia for 21 days of overseas training.

MAM Marketing MAM
Finally, style and comfort rolled into one: take your pick from Bata's new 9 to 9 collection

Bata has come a long way since its inception. From being the ‘most comfortable’ footwear brand, it's now giving people the best of both worlds in terms of style and comfort.

MAM Marketing MAM
Hotstar releases new TVC for VIVO IPL 2019 campaign ‘#KoiYaarNahiFar’

Hotstar has released an entertaining new TVC for its VIVO IPL 2019 campaign, ‘#KoiYaarNahiFar’, conceptualised and created by the DDB Mudra Group.

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
Digital storytellers and content creators Amritpal Bindra, Anand Tiwari and Nikhil Taneja lauch ‘Yuvaa’

Amritpal Bindra, Anand Tiwari and Nikhil Taneja, the producers and content creators behind shows on the digital space – Bang Baaja Baaraat (40 million+ views), Sex Chat with Pappu and Papa (55 million+ views), Girl in the City (50 million+ views), Chukiyagiri (30 million+ views) and the first...

MAM Media and Advertising Digital Agencies
Unilever elevates Nitin Paranjpe as COO and Sanjiv Mehta as president, South Asia

Unilever recently promoted its president for foods and refreshment Nitin Paranjpe to the post of chief operating officer.

MAM Media and Advertising People
Mondelez India brings Minions cheer to Cadbury Dairy Milk Lickables and Gems Surprise

Mondelez India has rolled out Cadbury Dairy Milk in Lickables and Cadbury Gems Surprise in association with the Despicable Me Franchise.

MAM Marketing Brands
RSH Global assigns media mandate to Initiative

RSH Global, which owns Joy Personal Care and X-Men, has announced the appointment of Initiative—from the house of IPG Mediabrands, as its media agency of record.

MAM Media and Advertising Account
Times Network hosts the 5th edition of Digital India Summit 2019

TIMES NETWORK, India’s leading broadcast network, hosted the 5th edition of its landmark event, ‘Digital India Summit 2019’ today.

MAM Marketing MAM

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories