Guest column: Net neutrality - ensuring an open internet

At a time when the US Federal Communications Commission is to vote on a rollback on the Net Neutrality Rules notified during the Obama administration, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has published its recommendations on the subject. Making headlines during the days of Zero Rating and products of the kind, and coming after nearly three years of setting up of a committee by the TRAI to make recommendations in this regard (January 2015), the document attempts to balance the interest of the general public by including ‘internet access services’ within the regulation of net neutrality and excluding “specialised services” that are “optimised for specific content, protocols or user equipment where optimisation is necessary in order to meet specific quality requirements.’’

Net neutrality, in theory, is a laudable concept. It also finds mention in the UL, VNO and ISP licensing terms notified by the Department of Telecom. The specific mention is absent from the UASL and CMTS licenses. However, this principle can nevertheless be read into the obligation to provide non-discriminatory access even by the telecom service providers. In this background, what is to be considered is whether net neutrality, with its basic principle already enshrined in the law and some contours such as specialised services yet to be clearly defined, is even required to be separately regulated.

First, net neutrality is, as stated in the recommendations, primarily to address and ensure “public internet access”. Importantly, what has not been considered is how much of this “public” of the country actually has access to broadband. The answer would be in the vicinity of 15 per cent. Of this “preferred public population,” many would be multiple connection/access holders and, hence, the effective penetration of broadband would be less than 12 per cent. With this background, the debate, rather than focusing on net neutrality, should focus on access to broadband for all. It is only when such a objective is achieved that the issue of whether or not we have a neutral internet would really need to be studied.

Second, OTT, which is one of the aspects central to the debate on net neutrality, has been currently left out for separate consideration. It is unclear, therefore, as to what position is taken vis-à-vis this very important piece of the net neutrality puzzle.

Third, it is strange that the document should pluck out internet of things, a concept and technology so nascent in India that even its mention in this document makes it conspicuous by its presence. Why is there a need for identification of such detail of a technology still under development, not only in India but in most parts of the world?

Having said the above, all the right words have been used in the recommendations–non-discriminatory access, non-provision of fast lanes, etc. All or most of these recommendations are great in theory. However, and especially with the carving out for specialised services, the workability of these recommendations, if they are to be accepted and converted into regulations, is suspect. We need to have enough cars (population access to broadband) before we can deride the provision of fast lanes.

(Abhishek Malhotra is a partner at Bharucha & Partners)

Latest Reads
TRAI extends submission date for consultation on landing page norms

MUMBAI: The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has extended the date of submission for comments on its consultation paper regarding landing page norms. The new dates for comments and counter comments are 4 May and 11 May respectively. The regulator had issued the consultation paper on 4...

Regulators TRAI
TRAI assures TDSAT on withdrawal of landing page order

NEW DELHI: Broadcast carriage regulator Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) assured the sector disputes tribunal yesterday during a hearing that a November 2017 order pertaining to landing or boot-up page of TV sets will be withdrawn within two weeks and the issue discussed with the...

Regulators TRAI
MIB moves to regulate online media: various organisations join issue

NEW DELHI: Even as a debate on the need to regulate online news media gains momentum, various organisations have moved the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB) hoping to be made a part of the committee that will look into various aspects of proposed regulations—a panel that surprisingly...

Regulators I&B Ministry
TRAI begins discussion on uplinking, downlinking guidelines

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has set the ball rolling for consultation on uplinking and downlinking guidelines with stakeholders. The regulator convened an open-house discussion (OHD) on its consultation paper on ‘issues relating to uplinking and downlinking of television...

Regulators TRAI
Prasar Bharati's policy on DD Free Dish to be out soon

MUMBAI: The suspense surrounding Prasar Bharti's policy on its free direct-to-home (DTH) platform is likely to end soon. The pubcaster has told the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT) that it will come out with a new policy for DD Free Dish in a few weeks. Prasar Bharti made...

Regulators TDSAT
MIB proposes installation of chip in DTH boxes: Report

In order to make the measurement process of viewership better, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB) has proposed of an in-built chip in set-top boxes (STBs). According to a report by The Asian Age, the ministry has sought that all direct-to-home (DTH) operators should install a chip...

Regulators I&B Ministry
TRAI bats for issuing DTH licences for 20 years

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has reiterated its recommendation to the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB) that direct-to-home licences be issued for a period of 20 years and then renewed for 10 years, and a one-time entry fee of Rs 10 crore be charged in the new DTH...

Regulators TRAI
No specific instance of paid news on private TV channels yet: MIB

MUMBAI: The Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB) has not yet had to face the menace of paid news on news channels. In a reply to the Lok Sabha or Lower House of Parliament, junior minister of MIB Rajyavardhan Singh Rathore informed that no specific instance of paid news in electronic...

Regulators I&B Ministry
MIB says ISRO upping capacity to facilitate migration from foreign satellites

NEW DELHI: The Indian government has admitted that inadequate capacity on Indian satellites has compelled domestic direct to home (DTH) operators to use a large number of transponders on foreign satellites and that India’s space agency Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) is gearing up to...

Regulators I&B Ministry

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories