Ofcom registers plaint against 'Joanna Lumley's India' as 'materially misleading'

MUMBAI: The UK's communications regulator Ofcom recently registered a complaint against "Joanna Lumley's India" to be 'materially misleading'. It has been registered under the "Complaints assessed, not investigated" section of Ofcom. Ofcom has decided not to pursue complaints recorded between 1 and 20 August 2017 because they did not raise issues warranting investigation. "Complaints assessed" fall under the procedures for investigating breaches of content standards for television and radio.

TV show 'Joanna Lumley's India' has been alleged in a section of the UK media for airbrushing history. Lumley had returned to the place of her birth to celebrate India and walk in her ?family?s footsteps?. However, her show alleged overlooked British oppression in the former colony. In the final instalment of Lumley?s three-part travelogue adventure across India, she explored Rajasthan, Delhi and the mountainous North West ending in Kashmir, the place of her birth.

Joanna Lumley?s India, shown on ITV, promise to ?celebrate? modern India and ?walk in my family?s footsteps?. Within minutes of the beginning of the first episode, there was reportedly an omission. Walking through Kolkata, then called Calcutta, Lumley notices the British-inspired architecture. She however fails to mention that the first Anglican cathedral on the subcontinent St John?s Church was built by James Agg, her great-grandfather and the first of her ancestors to arrive in India in 1777. She probably is unaware of the lineage, the Guardian reported.

But. it was not hard to trace it. Or, it could be because of those four chilling words -- British East India Company ? the trading corporation turned ?aggressive colonial power?, as the historian William Dalrymple pointed out, the activities of which brought the word ?loot? (from the Hindustani 'lut') into the English dictionary, and from which Agg may have made his fortune.

The Brit EIC was not just a group of merchants, but a military force that plundered India throughout the 18th and early 19th centuries. In Bengal, the first of the regions to fall to the British Raj, the immediate outcome was full pockets for the Westerners and poverty for the citizens. Indians were stopped from trading, were forced off their land by harsh taxes, and saw their world-renowned textile industry destroyed. 

The poverty of this great city, Lumley says, was down to ?conflict and politics?. Or, did she say: ?conquest and policies? ? such as the 50 per cent tax on income, the extraction of which was routinely helped along by torture. Defaulters could expect to be caged and left in the burning sun. Or, at worst, to quote Edmund Burke?s 1795 testimony in the Parliament about the horrors inflicted upon Bengali women, ?they were dragged out, naked and exposed to the public view, and scourged before all the people ... they put the nipples of the women into the sharp edges of split bamboos and tore them from their bodies,? the Guardian wrote.

As Lumley?s camera crew panned over a child beggar, it began to feel like the presenter was in denial. Take the segment on the Dalits, or ?untouchables?. It is hard to imagine, purrs a moralising Lumley, how ?this modern country? can ?tolerate such discrimination?. Yet, as Shashi Tharoor outlined in his new book "Inglorious Empire," the British helped to entrench caste prejudice, giving a final shape to it as a means of control. "We had castes," Tharoor says, "but we did not have the caste system."

Also Read:

UK's TV & online habits revealed, 40 mn watch episodes back-to-back 

84 U.K. channels required to provide access services in 2018

Fox-Sky deal: UK to assess implications by 29 June

Latest Reads
Bodhi Tree focusing on three verticals to scale up business

Over the top (OTT) services have given a big boost to production houses in the country  Bodhi Tree Multimedia, started by Mautik Tolia and Sukesh Motwani five years ago, only concentrated on general entertainment programs on TV initially. Following the change in the overall entertainment industry,...

Television Production House Fiction
Mumbai Team franchisee owner unable to meet financial obligations towards Zee Maharashtra Kushti Dangal

Mr. Pranav Rajesh Dake, owner of Zee Maharashtra Kushti Dangal’s Mumbai team – Mumbai Astra has regrettably been unable to meet the financial obligations towards Zee Maharashtra Kushti Dangal (ZMKD), its players and technicians.

Television TV Channels Viewership
Zee TV gets ratings boost from Zee Rishtey Awards

Zee TV's recently concluded annual awards property, Zee Rishtey Awards, clocked the highest viewership ratings across award shows that took place in the last two years. As per the recently released BARC HSM weekly data (Urban + Rural) for the week 44 '18, it secured a viewership of 5495 TVTs, which...

Television TV Channels Viewership
No changes in Kannada, Marathi segments in BARC data week 44

In the Bengali space, Colors Bangla and Sony Aath swapped their fourth and fifth positions in BARC data week 44. News18 Bihar Jharkhand emerged as the new player in the market by securing fifth position. No changes were observed in the Kannada and Marathi segments.

Television TV Channels Viewership

Launched on November 19, 2014, EPIC celebrates the completion of four years on air, in which it has set aspirational benchmarks for Indian TV content.

Television TV Channels Music and Youth
Celebrating 100 years of Bengali cinema, Viacom18 and Film Heritage Foundation bring the 4th Film Preservation & Restoration Workshop to Kolkata

In line with the centenary celebration of the Bengali Film Industry, and with a purpose to encourage and give an impetus to film preservation and restoration, the 4th edition of Film Preservation & Restoration Workshop India (FPRWI) 2018 was today inaugurated at Kolkata’s Rabindra Sadan.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
Vimal Elaichi Pan Masala enters top 5 most advertised brands in BARC week 45

The Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) India has released its data for top advertisers and brands between 27 October-02 November 2018. The data is a reflection of top 10 advertiser and brands across genre on Indian television (U+R) : 2+ Individuals. The data demonstrates ads that were...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Zee Anmol back on top of Hindi channels across genres

Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd's (Zeel) free to air (FTA) Hindi GEC Zee Anmol was back to second rank in Broadcast Audience Research Council of India’s (BARC) weekly list of top 10 channels across genres in week 45 of 2018 (Saturday, 3 November 2018 to Friday, 9 November 2018, week under review...

Television TV Channels Viewership
MNX to premiere supernatural fright flick, ‘Wish Upon’

MNX, the preferred movie channel of the millennials, will premiere, American supernatural horror film, ‘Wish Upon’ for the first time on Indian television.

Television TV Channels English Entertainment

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories