Report on Shemaroo

BARC India's approach post TDSAT's landing page order draws concern from some stakeholders

BARC board has formed a 2-member committee to review its outlier policy

MUMBAI: Questions and controversies around TDSAT’s ruling on landing pages and BARC India’s subsequent flip-flop over implementation of its data validation and outlier policy refuse to die down. In a bid to allay transparency fears of a section within India’s broadcast sector, the BARC board approved a recommendation to set up a two-member committee to review the TV audience measurement body’s outlier policy.

“As you are aware, there has been a lot of confusion around the landing page in the market. Therefore in order to give confidence to the industry and the stakeholders, BARC board approved a recommendation to set a two-member committee. Mr Nakul Chopra and Mr Praveen Tripathi are industry leaders and their appointment only reiterates the BARC board’s reassurance to give confidence to the industry.

“Though we at BARC India, have been requested by many stakeholders to continue with the outlier policy, an independent overview of the process and any recommendation to improve, are always welcome and we look forward to working with this committee. Also, recently Deloitte had done a detailed audit on this process and found it clean” a BARC India spokesperson told

Despite the latest move being a step in the right direction, the naming of the two appointees hasn't really inspired "confidence" among some industry stakeholders. If the objective is to carry out an “independent overview”, those entrusted with the task should ideally be above suspicion of a potential or perceived conflict of interest irrespective of their calibre and competence, is a view expressed by several industry executives. While Chopra is a former BARC chairman, Tripathi as CEO of Magic9 Media and Analytics continues to be associated with BARC as a consultant/vendor. Tripathi's company had earlier helped BARC process data from barometers, identify outliers and project ratings.

While it isn't the board's job to wade through the minutiae of everyday operations, the fact that BARC's data validation and outlier policy mechanism and implementation has assumed game-changing proportions for the ecosystem is an aspect that needs its serious consideration, say some industry watchers.

"In the case of BARC, the problem is compounded as customers are also board members,” pointed out an industry source.

Some broadcasters, however, have raised more fundamental issues, which go beyond the BARC board’s involvement or lack of it in the outlier policy implementation.

“Is BARC circumventing the TDSAT order which allows landing pages as a legal practice?” questioned a senior news broadcasting executive.

The need of the hour, say some, is transparency of BARC’s internal mechanism in weeding out outliers given that there is a degree of subjectivity attached to it.

"As for the landing page, BARC has and does maintain that they cannot identify landing pages. The process can, however, identify reach outliers which could happen for landing pages in big cable networks for smaller viewed channels or when there is a distribution intervention like activation or improvement in availability. The same principle applies to content interventions also. Most analysts who keenly watch these numbers especially for genres like English news and business news do know this since the landing page discussions started some time back. At BARC, our mandate is to measure viewership with transparency and accuracy to provide a credible measurement," the BARC India spokesperson added.

Broadcasters that compete for a small viewership base fight for every eyeball. In an environment such as this, the landing page saga has boxed them into a state of flux when it comes to a post-TDSAT order strategy. The outcome of the two-member committee’s findings is what they keenly await in the hope of some clarity and reassurance. 

Latest Reads
TRP scam: Enforcement Directorate to file chargesheet this month

MUMBAI: The Mumbai police's unearthing of a ‘fake TRP’ (television rating points) scam last year sent shockwaves through India's media industry, with top TV news channels accusing each other of fudging their ratings. The Mumbai police has alleged that a few media houses bribed households where BARC...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Zee's Indian Pro Music League ropes in eight sponsors

MUMBAI: India’s first-ever music league, the Indian Pro Music League (IPML), recently aired on Zee TV and streamed on Zee5, to much fanfare. A clutter-breaking reality format innovation, IPML has received an overwhelming response from leading brands across categories who have come onboard as...

Television TV Channels GECs
No crisis for BARC, our data is proved & authentic: Sunil Lulla

NEW DELHI: As the Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) continues to battle the controversy surrounding its TV viewership ratings, its chief executive officer Sunil Lulla asserted that the issue has become a matter of the past, and the agency’s data remains true, reliable and authentic.

Television TV Channels Viewership
TV viewership up 9% in 2020, ad volumes surge 34% in second half: BARC India

MUMBAI: The television industry witnessed unprecedented highs and lows in 2020, or the year that shall not be named. From record viewership, new category leaders, to diminished ad revenue and stiff competition from upstart OTT players – TV Land saw it all and emerged stronger for it. Now, the...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Sony BBC Earth concludes fourth edition of ‘Feel Alive Hours’

MUMBAI: Yet another season of inspiring young minds has concluded with Sony BBC Earth’s flagship school engagement program, Feel Alive Hours. Over the last three editions, this pioneering initiative travelled to schools across India and rekindled the joy of being closer to nature through positive,...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
9X Media onboards Alok Nair as chief revenue officer

MUMBAI: With Pawan Jailkhani deciding to depart from 9X Media, the company has brought on Alok Nair to take over as chief revenue officer. Nair, who has made the move from his entrepreneurial venture White & Blue Media, will report to 9X Media MD Pradeep Guha. He will work in tandem with 9X...

Television TV Channels Music and Youth
Golden Globes 2021: The Crown reigns, Nomadland is best picture

After a two-month delay, the 78th annual Golden Globes finally took place on Sunday, February 28, giving the industry something to celebrate while also reflecting the reality we inhabit. The awards went bi-coastal this year, most winners accepted their trophies from the safety of home, and the...

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
Julie Pizzi named president, Bunim/Murray Production

Veteran producer and long-time executive Julie Pizzi has been named president, Bunim/Murray productions. The news was announced by Endemol Shine Holdings president and CEO & Banijay chairman of the Americas Cris Abrego.

Television Production House Fiction
Decline in appointment viewing doesn’t mean a show isn’t doing well: Nikul Desai

Nikul Desai is mainly known for directing non-fiction shows like Comedy Circus, Rising Star, and his latest venture, Taare Zameen Par. He began his career under the supervision of his paternal uncle Vipul D Shah, the co-founder of Optimystix Entertainment.

Television Production House Fiction

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories

* indicates required