Television

Comment: Does Star stand to gain or lose by sharing IPL with DD?

https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/smartcrop_800x800/public/images/tv-images/2017/12/05/Vivo_ipl.jpg?itok=DlRb9aCf

MUMBAI: On a balmy September afternoon, while some reps from bidding companies blew smoke in the air (and the tensions, too, probably) at a five-star hotel in South Mumbai’s Colaba, some senior executives of Star India were lounging in a room in the same hotel-not as anxious as some of the smokers outside, a person familiar with the settings chirped. Soon, the Indian cricket board, BCCI, announced that Star had won the broadcast rights to the money-spinning IPl cricket tournament for five years for Rs 16,3475 million (Rs 16347.5 crore) or approximately $ 2.55 billion.  

Cut to a fortnight or so earlier to New Delhi where the August summer was refusing to relent and the temperature fluctuated in a room in Supreme Court where the learned judges observed that India’s pubcaster Prasar Bharati cannot freely re-transmit TV signals of sports or cricketing events to other distribution platforms where the rights were held by a private broadcaster or a TV channel and was being shared with Doordarshan under a legislation of the country.

In both the cases cited above the common factor was Star India (a subsidiary of Rupert Murdoch-controlled News Corp/21st Century Fox), probably the biggest broadcasting company in India in terms of revenues.

Champagne should have been popped on both the occasions. Probably it was, but privately. And, the public reactions were cautious. Even in his interview to indiantelevision.com mid-September, Star India chairman and CEO Uday Shankar was cautiously optimistic about IPL win and India’s regulations relating to the media sector.

Almost 70 days after winning the IPL rights --- somewhere in between hectic consultations would have happened between Star India top leadership and company’s promoters --- reports surfaced in media that Star India probably would have to share the IPL telecasts with pubcaster DD that will air the cricket matches on its terrestrial network and FTA DTH platform, DD FreeDish.

What’s the gist of these reports in the media? IPL cricket matches would be telecast live on Star Sports channels and also a DD channel that would be available terrestrially and on DD FreeDish. This would be made possible --- as and when the government formally issues a directive as both the law  and information & broadcasting ministries were being consulted --- under a regulation called the Sports Broadcasting Signals (Mandatory Sharing with Prasar Bharati) Act, 2007. Some tweaks would have to be made and IPL categorized as a tournament of national importance at par with other sporting events like Olympics, Commonwealth Games and Wimbledon for the sharing to be mandated.

Indiantelevision.com must admit, though, till the time of writing this piece everything’s in the realm of conjectures and possibilities. While Star and BCCI did not comment on emails on the issue sent to them by us, even the government sources quoted in the media as having articulated on the possible development were unnamed.

It makes one thing clear: that nothing is clear as of now or set in stone. It’s also possible that as a trade-off for the Supreme Court directive barring  free re-transmission of shared TV signals of sporting events where rights were held by a private broadcaster, Star India could be mulling sharing IPL matches with DD --- and also part of the advertising revenue.

According to Financial Express newspaper, which quoted industry estimates, Sony Pictures Networks India (SPN), the official broadcaster (till 2017) of the T20 tournament since its inception, had crossed the Rs. 1,300 crore (Rs. 13,000 million)-mark in terms of ad revenue. The newspaper also stated that IPL’s season 10 garnered 1.25 billion impressions as per BARC data, gaining 24 per cent more viewership (compared to last year) on Sony channels.

Writing a guest column in indiantelevision.com after Star won the IPL bid in September, senior business journalist and author of two books on IPL, Alam Srinivas, observed: “In 2009, when the IPL rights were renegotiated, Sony agreed to pay Rs 82,000 million for a nine-year period or Rs 9,111 million a year. At a simple inflation rate of 10 per cent, the figure will escalate to Rs 17,311 million over nine seasons. At a compounded rate of 10 per cent, the figure will be Rs 21,483 million. Star agreed to pay Rs 32,695 million per year, or a sizeable over 50 per cent higher than the 10 per cent compounded figure. This indicates that the IPL’s valuation has shot up, or at least the stakeholders think so.”

Given this scenario, the following questions arise:

Question No. 1: Is IPL that crucial (versus Test cricket, for example) to be designated as a sports of national importance to be shared with the pubcaster?

Question No. 2: If that’s made possible, how will the technicalities of different TV feeds play out?

Question No. 3: Will Star gain or lose financially having dished out $ 2.5 billion for a five -year rights?

Question 4: Will sharing of the IPl matches with DD impede or affect Star’s usual high-octane marketing campaigns aimed at monetization of high-value events and will it set a precedent?

The answers are not easy to frame as possible explanations are not forthcoming in the absence of any formal and official confirmations or denials.

If we have to answer Q. 1, then prima facie, the answer would be ‘no’. IPL is a domestic cricket tournament having played out for 10 years with DD showing (officially) minimum interest. That IPL’s popularity has increased shouldn’t be reason for it to be shared with pubcaster, especially when the pubcaster has mostly shied away from airing Test cricket, which is a five-day affair over seven hours daily, and even when India featured in such matches.

But then in an age of social media, when many games are played on the basis of perceptions, giving a huge swathe of Indian population easy and practically free access to IPL matches on DD could also mean scoring points with a big voting bank. After all, TV services or even entertainment are not categorized under essential services (like some utility services) that need not be subsidized by the government or access made free. Still in India, politics and sports have had a history of an intricate and, at times, incestuous interplay.

Question 2 and 4 are easier to attempt. Simply because if Q1 and Q3 are sorted out --- amicably --- then these issues don’t matter much. TV feeds have been shared with DD and AIR by private broadcasters in the past on few occasions. What would be important is that DD adheres to the Supreme Court verdict and ensures that its free signals are not illegally carried by any unauthorized distribution platform(s) in the case of IPL matches.

 This brings us to Q.3 on which hinges Star’s fortunes despite being mandated by a regulation that can smack of strong-arm tactics by the government.

However, it has to be admitted, again, that DD’s reach is tantalizing --- at least theoretically. The FreeDish FTA DTH platform has an estimated 22 million subscribers, mostly in non-urban areas, while DD channels on the terrestrial network supposedly cover over 80 per cent of the approximate 1.26 billion Indian population.

Given these numbers --- clamour amongst private TV channels to be on the FTA DTH platform could be an indication --- sharing of IPL matches with the pubcaster may not be such a big loss for Star.

In an imagined world, Star could agree to share the IPl matches, forced under a regulation, but insist that it would retain the rights for marketing and ad sales of the matches  shown on DD channel too, sharing 25 per cent of the ad revenue--- again as per stated law.

This move could help Star not only increase the reach of IPL matches by at least 25 per cent, but also do some imaginative and aggressive ad sales with sponsors on digital and linear TV spaces. A marketing guru did admit in private that most FMCGs and big global spenders are now more looking at non-urban markets, which DD’s platform guarantees.

In conclusion, we might say there are too many straws in the wind presently. A word of caution: this can set a precedent that may not always be healthy for the rightful rights owners. But then, as the boss, the government is always right, as the folklore goes.

ALSO READ:  

Guest Column: Star India's IPL deal raises three crucial questions

Star bids highest for BCCI's IPL media & digital rights and is the winner

IPL has come to the rightful home of cricket in India: Star's Uday Shankar

Star's Uday Shankar on distribution challenges, IPL, FTA vs. pay TV, innovations, Made in India content…and much more

With IPL rights, Uday Shankar gambles audaciously, must plan pragmatically

Latest Reads

https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/02/zulfia.jpg?itok=pkwaDSMw
ABP News Network appoints Zulfia Waris as business head of ANN Content Studio

MUMBAI: ABP News Network has appointed Zulfia Waris as the business head of ABP News Network Content Studio. Waris will be responsible for the organisation’s new subsidiary, ANN Content Studio, to produce path-breaking content for all platforms.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/02/barc.jpg?itok=YSgL1D2M
TV consumption up by 37% in week 12 due to COVID-19 lockdown: BARC India & Nielsen

MUMBAI: As India went into a lockdown mode due to COVID-19, people have upped their TV viewing time, as per the latest information from Broadcast Audience Research Council of India (BARC) and Nielsen. Total TV consumption in week 12 grew by 37 per cent compared to the previous week.

Television TV Channels Viewership
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/02/Wimbledon-2020.jpg?itok=JBi30X6q
Wimbledon 2020 becomes latest sporting event to be cancelled due to Covid-19

For the first time since World War II (1945), the Wimbledon Championships 2020 has been cancelled by a year amid rising concern of the novel Covid-19 pandemic, confirms All England Club Lawn Tennis Club (AELTC) in its official press statement.

Television TV Channels Sports
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/01/nbsa.jpg?itok=Aws1be0k
NBSA advises news channels to use social media content after thorough verification

MUMBAI: The News Broadcasting Standards Authority (NBSA) has advised member broadcasters of the News Broadcasters Association (NBA) to verify any content used from social media platforms in their news programmes at the highest editorial levels before being telecast in the wake of the recent supreme...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/01/nba_0.jpg?itok=3ubPyfky
NBA players go head-to-head in first-ever ‘NBA 2K players tournament’

MUMBAI: National Basketball Association (NBA), and National Basketball Players Association (NBPA) announced the “NBA 2K Players Tournament,” an NBA 2K20 gameplay tournament between 16 current NBA players from 3 April on ESPN and ESPN2. NBA players, including top seeds Kevin Durant of the Brooklyn...

Television TV Channels Sports
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/01/wwe.jpg?itok=zXqG2rOC
Sony Pictures Networks India extents broadcast partnership with WWE by 5 yrs

MUMBAI: Sony Pictures Networks India (SPN) and World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) have announced a five-year extension agreement to broadcast weekly wrestling matches, buttressing the fact that wrestling is one of the most-watched non-cricket sports in India. An official press release said: “With...

Television TV Channels Sports
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/01/aajtak.jpg?itok=Rh7umaPt
Aajtak.in is the No. 1 Hindi News Destination across Desktop, Mobile, APP, Video & Social

New Delhi: Aajtak.in has again established its dominance in Hindi news space across digital platforms (Desktop, mWeb, App & Social). The latest Comscore data (February 2020) is a clear reminder of the trust of the Indian consumers on the Sabse Tez news brand. Here’s how Aajtak.in reinforced its...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/01/ramayan.jpg?itok=-aNukYGv
&TV to re-air ‘Ramayan’ this Ram Navami

MUMBAI:In the spirit of Ram Navami, a festival that signifies the birthday of Lord Rama, &TV is all set to present (Shri Ram Charit Manas Adharit) ‘Ramayan’ on television. The show features popular actors like Gagan Malik, Neha Sargam, Shikha Swaroop, Rucha Gujarathi, Sachin Tyagi, Divyanka...

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/04/01/kids.jpg?itok=P6GMcwxw
Nickelodeon franchise witnesses 20 per cent growth in weekly viewing minutes

MUMBAI: In this period of lockdown, the kids’ category has seen a surge in viewership including the growth of the Nickelodeon franchise ratings, which have in fact fuelled the growth of the entire kid’s category. The kids’ genre has seen a 33 per cent growth by moving up to nine per cent share in...

Television TV Channels Kids

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories

* indicates required