Television

COMMENT: KNIVES, ARNAB, & THE OLD GUARD OF ENGLISH NEWS

https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/smartcrop_800x800/public/images/tv-images/2018/09/04/knivesarnab_0.jpg?itok=3sAkIHvy

MUMBAI: The knives are out. The blades are being flashed around. And those involved in the street fight are drawing blood and bleeding as well. Only difference is that the street fighters are not the ruffian kind, rather they are gents who you watch on the TV screen or dressed up to the T in well pressed suits in boardrooms.

What has got these reasonably well-behaved folks from the English news channel space all het up?

Well, a possible shakeup in the pecking order courtesy a newcomer who likes a round - some say bouts - of fisticuffs – both on air and in the marketplace. Team Republic TV led by editor-owner Arnab Goswami is clear that it wants to own the English new genre – or create a new one combining both Hindi and English – by hook or by crook. After all, all’s fair in love and business isn’t it?

So far he and his CEO Vikas Khanchandani have used tricks which older players have resorted to in the past – multiple LCN distribution on cable TV networks and allegedly pinching content which was recorded when he was in another channel’s employment.

The courts will decide whether Arnab and team are thieves or not; we are not insinuating anything. The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India will clean up the multiple LCN mess by coming down hard on the errant distribution platform owners who have fallen prey to the smell of money – lots of it.

But the affair Republic TV has thrown up a lot of deeper issues which could be thought about.

When all members of a gymkhana or club have agreed upon a code of conduct, and a new entrant does not adhere to it, then should he not be told to fall in line when the infringement is brought to the establishment’s chairperson’s notice? Could the chairperson give the older members a patient hearing and heed what they have to say?

Older players are an aggrieved lot. Yes, they admit that they have been bad boys in the past. But then they have mended their way, signed a truce and decided to follow the straight and narrow path. Should their old behavior be brought up to excuse that of the new entrant?

And when they decide to protest by not coming to the club, should they be further threatened that they will be banned for longer if they do continue with their picketing?

Of course the chairperson is BARC; the policeman/security is TRAI and the members are the NBA. No second guesses for who the new entrant is – Republic TV.

Would BARC have responded the same way had it been the general entertainment channels which would have raised a hue and cry? Remember what happened to TAM!) After all the entertainment broadcasters contribute about four to five times more to BARC’s purse then do the news channels.

Could broadcasting licence issuance by the ministry of information and broadcasting be linked to well-behaved and well-accepted distribution practices? If some one does not adhere to them, could the licence be suspended?

Should news channels be measured alongside entertainment channels? This modus operandi has forced them to resort to entertainment or outshout-and-out-abuse-your-guest kind of programming (read entertainment again) which seems to appeal to TV soap viewers wanting to have big names of society and public life being squashed like flies on TV. Some have called this the dumbing down or bimbo-isation of news television.

Is there a need for a new viewership currency or data points - which are more specific to the news genre - other than what BARC churns out? Could media agencies and brands resort to qualitative checks of content before signing cheques for ads on TV news channels? The most watched read/watched genre of content on the internet begins with a P. Do all major advertisers place their consumer messaging in that environment?

Could distribution platforms have stricter penalties if they fall for green dollars, violating codes set up by regulators? The DTH guys would not dare to go for multiple LCN placement because what they do immediately comes to the public’s and regulator’s eyes – they are accountable for their quality of service. Fear of punishment can be a big deterrent.

From an editorial perspective, questions are being asked as to how far will Arnab go? And then will the other channels show restraint or will they beat the same path? So far, it appears that some of them played follow-the- newcomer on the multiple LCN issue. Of course, they all did a volte face when the policeman/security guard waved around his night stick.

Whatever be the case, it is quite sure that the NBA English news members will kiss and make up with BARC, the TRAI and each other. Sooner then later. (BARC and NBA are scheduled to meet today to pencil out points that will help them resolve the crisis.)

Who knows Arnab may also find some sense in the NBA and its code of conduct and eat his own words and also house his channel under its protective roof? There was a time when another bespectacled news journalist was labelled the villain of TV news; today he is part of the establishment.

After all, they all need each other. This is despite some media blogs and websites which have sketched the industry’s execs as shaking hands while holding a dagger behind each others' backs.

Industry old timers are betting that ratings released after week 22 will give a true reflection of what’s going on with English news TV viewership. The three to four weeks’ data prior to that is simply something to be kept aside as an aberration as it will continue to show Republic TV as the numero uno. After that it could well go into a free fall and the older players will continue with their leadership position, is their prediction.

Republic TV executives are clucking that this is wishful thinking. Indian viewers have been waiting for the Arnab school of journalism like the Jews did for manna from heaven in the good old Bible, is what they have voiced. And that their channel will continue to top the charts for the foreseeable future.

Only time will tell which prediction turns out be true.

Until then, we will keep channel surfing with hope in our hearts that we will get to watch some real news.

Latest Reads

https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/03/zee.jpg?itok=oLeRaAYB
Zee South Cluster donates Rs 1.35 crore to daily-wage workers

MUMBAI: Zee South Cluster, part of the Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd, has cumulatively donated Rs 1.35 crore to support more than 1,000 pandemic-hit daily-wage workers in the television industry across Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Karnataka and Kerala. The aid has been directly sent...

Television TV Channels Regional
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/03/go.jpg?itok=5a5TqwGa
Malaysia-based Astro woos Tamil diaspora with more HD content

Malaysia-based Astro has added more Tamil HD content on the platform including Zee Tamil HD, Star Vijay HD, Colors Tamil HD. The Chakravarthy Pack will be offering premium content to over 300,000 Tamil households in Malaysia.

Television TV Channels Regional
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/03/delhi.jpg?itok=fyK7-BTY
TV Today Network cites tepid growth, less revenue for discontinuing Delhi Aaj Tak

Recently, TV Today Network announced that the transmission of its Hindi news channel Delhi Aaj Tak (DAT) will be discontinued from the midnight of 30 June 2020. Speculations on the reasons for the closure were rife.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/03/red.jpg?itok=HlbErxHr
Industry needs to handhold to come out of this crisis

The film and television producers are gearing up to restart shooting in the wake of guidelines issued by the Maharashtra government and the easing of lockdown restrictions. Film and TV post-production activities in Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka and Telangana have also resumed, albeit with...

Television Production House Fiction
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/02/ashok.jpg?itok=8SblLKPX
Film, TV directors' association requests Maharashtra govt for changes in shooting guidelines

MUMBAI: The Indian Film & Television Directors’ Association (IFTDA) has sent a letter to the Maharashtra government seeking the removal of certain clauses in the guidelines for resuming shooting of films, OTT shows, and television serials as they are difficult to be adhered to. Chief minister...

Television Production House Film Production
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/02/jagdish.jpg?itok=Q19phizl
  •  
The Zoom Studios announces Intertainer 2020, India’s ultimate digital hunt for the best entertainer on internet’

As India continues to practice social distancing and safety measures amidst the COVID-19 pandemic, the digital world has paved itself to be an enabler to continue with our social lives, connecting with the outside world and also serving a creative platform for many budding talents.

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/02/news18.jpg?itok=JOVij5lL
News18 India lines-up exclusive interview with Defence Minister on 2nd June @4PM

New Delhi: As the Modi government completes the first year of its second-term, Defence Minister Rajnath Singh will speak about the major decisions taken by the government in the last one year in an exclusive interview with News18 India.At a time when India is battling to contain the spread of COVID...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/02/asianet.jpg?itok=ednuCJtZ
Asianet starts airing popular serials

Prominent GEC in Kerala Asianet is back with some exciting entertainment for the audience. TV shoots which were stalled due to the Covid2019 outbreak have resumed following the guidelines issued by the government.

Television TV Channels Regional
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2020/06/02/studio.jpg?itok=PaZu6owM
Distressed studios ready to give concessions to producers

Huge financial losses, unbearable maintenance costs, the fear of impending rain ruining the sets... Studio owners in the country have been living with all these woes and challenges ever since the lockdown was imposed to curb the spread of Covid2019.

Television Production House Fiction

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories

* indicates required