Specials

IDOS 2016: OTT advertising vs TV advertising

https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/smartcrop_800x800/public/images/tv-images/2016/10/03/Untitled-1.jpg?itok=exikbdN9

GOA: Is Online Video (read: OTT) advertising eating into TV’s share? That was the question posed  by the final session of IDOS 2016 held in Goa’s Leela Hotel. The obvious consensus answer from the panelists was a big “no” - and it does not take a genius to reach that conclusion.

On the panel were IPG Media brands CEO Shashi Sinha, Sony Pictures Network India (SPNI) digital head Uday Sodhi, Starcom India Group CEO, Mallikarjun “Malli”  Das and Eros Now business head Zulfiqar 'Zulfi' Khan.

“Digital advertising accounts for about eight to nine per cent of total ad spends,”  said Malli. “Most of this goes towards Google, Facebook. Two to three per cent is going towards digital video, and that too most of it is going towards You Tube.  It’s early days yet for the OTT players to have any revenues of significance.”

“Google has played a pioneering role –  the educational and evangelizing approach that it along with YouTube took visiting advertisers and agencies to explain to them the efficacy of using it  platform,” said Zulfi. “The OTT industry is too nascent and new, and has a lot of work to do.”

Sinha pointed out that the disparity in CPMs between television and online IP video is drastic. “Television is being sold on a cost per rating point (CPRP) basis in India today. In most countries, it is on a CPMs,” he said. “The CPMs even for TV are very low, and for online video, even lower. Airtime on television has become a commodity as there is plenty of inventory, but networks have large enough audiences to present to advertisers.”

public://IMG_5444.jpg

Added Malli: “Television also has a reliable currency – BARC – to measure what’s happening to their spends – the reach, the viewership. Which makes all of us in the media and advertising community secure. We can buy across a network and aggregate audience.”

The panelists agreed even though the OTT players are providing very specific - in fact a surfeit of data, enough confidence has yet to be built in among the advertisers. “There’s fragmentation in the OTT community. There are too many platforms,” said Sinha. “And you can’t aggregate enough audiences of significance to allow us to take CPMs up here.”

Sodhi agreed that OTT video platforms had managed to build an active audience of about 70 million. He said: “China’s tipping point for OTT to significantly impact TV ad spends came when the number of users crossed 200 million.  India has to grow. SonyLiv has around around 10 million. Good and stable bandwidth and right pricing  of data are the issues to be dealt with to expand the OTT user base,” Sodhi said.

Malli believed that the audience of 70 million is large enough. “The Times of India has a seven and a half million readership and there is thousands of crores going into the paper.”

Both Malli and Sinha stated that agencies have started presenting media plans which, include TV plus and online video. “That’s a great improvement over earlier. We are putting in money behind online video. But it’s left to the OTT- owner – the broadcaster – to show it as OTT ad spend or TV ad spend. However, to be fair, the sector will grow when FMCGs start putting in their faith behind digital online video,” revealed Sinha.

Then what is holding the ecosystem back? “Most of the robust OTT platforms are backed by the broadcasters,” revealed Sinha. “The leadership is fearful their targeted revenue objectives from television might get impacted if they start shifting the focus more toward digital video advertising. This leadership has to take a hard call.”

He pointed out that BARC - of which he is a technical committee member - is gearing up to measure online video consumption and become the second country in the world to do so.

“We are ready to launch online video measurement  by March 2017. Relevant data is going to be provided by some of our partners in the ecosystem to allow us to provide effective measurement numbers. However, the signal has to come from the broadcast community,”  he quipped.

Zulfi pointed out that Eros Now has around a  million subscribers – split between India and overseas – paying Rs 49 a month for its Bollywood movie service.

However, his view that today snacking was the primary form of consumption of digital video, was countered by Sodhi, who stated  that the SonyLiv audience was sticking around for  around for 16-22 minutes per session.

They all agreed that there is a bright future for digital video advertising. But, none wanted to hazard a guess as to when will it happen. “I have no clue when will the inflection point come,” Sinha said. “It is now.”

Malli too said that he had no clue about it. “Although the stage is set, I can’t predict when a significant migration to digital will happen -- in one, two or three years from now.”

Sodhi revealed that almost 70 million users are being added to the digital video consumers pie every year. “Within two to two and a half years we will have 200 million users,” he predicted. “And that will be a number no one will want to ignore. The advertising tap will flow and flow then.”

Latest Reads

https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/19/dth.jpg?itok=2ugzTNO1
#Forecast2021: Positivity returns slowly for cable, DTH operators

Waking up to a new pricing regime, followed by an unprecedented pandemic, natural disasters, and tensions with China, 2020 turned out to be a gloomy year for the cable TV distribution industry.

Specials Forecast
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/18/tv.jpg?itok=a8_bbj0B
#Forecast2021: TV advertising may see biggest growth in five years

Indian television made a round trip to hell over the course of 2020, but the new year seems like the beginning of a positive era for the industry, as far as its stature as the primary advertising medium is concerned.

Specials Forecast
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/16/production.jpg?itok=H82e5yTn
#Throwback2020: The year of reinvention in production

MUMBAI: The Covid2019 crisis has engendered a paradigm shift across all walks of life and it is believed that there’s no going back to “normalcy” even after the deadly virus is dealt with. This also holds true for the media and entertainment industry.

Specials Year Enders
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/15/tvv.jpg?itok=692JqTyS
India Khush Hua: Top 5 trends that will define M&E industry in 2021

2020 was when peoples’ worst fears came true. But 2021 is a brand new year full of promise of good things to come, where the media and entertainment industry can reboot, recalibrate and recoup what it lost, voiced the panel comprising leading names from the brand and agency world at...

Specials Forecast
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/15/lap.jpg?itok=XUv9qKww
Forecast 2021: Digital to lead marketing industry’s growth story

2020 started off with industry hopes pinned on a robust double-digit growth. Instead, it left the Indian marketing and advertising industry in shambles. Educated estimates peg the sector to have clocked only a one-two per cent growth over 2019 numbers, with traditional advertising taking the...

Specials Forecast
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/15/tv.jpg?itok=QLpKn9LZ
#Forecast2021: How technology, infrastructure upgrade will shape OTT ecosystem

The over-the-top (OTT) platforms have seen accelerated customer acquisition, especially post-Covid2019. To increase the stickiness of fleeting users, the platforms are adding more and more content to their libraries.

Specials Forecast
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/14/sony.jpg?itok=tW3nGrHc
#Forecast2021: OTT magic will continue to hold sway

Most industries had little cause for cheer last year, but the OTT business wasn’t one of them. Engulfed by an outpouring of love and support, OTTs truly came into their own in 2020. These streaming platforms not only gained paid subscribers in big numbers, but became a staple of the Indian culture...

Specials Forecast
https://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2021/01/12/nina.jpg?itok=r69rvHps
#Throwback2020: For M&E industry, there’s no such thing as closing shop

MUMBAI: It has not been the easiest of years and none of us ever dreamt that the last couple of months would be the way they have been. But I always believe that there is always a silver lining and that there is a lot to learn from what has transpired in the last ten months. Having said that, I...

Specials Year Enders

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories

* indicates required