Trai'ng hard but falling way too short

Some like it; some don't. But there's no denying that the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai)-mandated pay channel prices in CAS areas (Rs 5 for all pay channels) is going to stir up much more than just a storm in the proverbial cup.

It's like those weekly village markets that are quite popular in India where the refrain is har maal paanch rupaiya mein (every product priced uniformly at Rs 5). The actual price may differ a bit, but the concept adopted by Trai is the same. Reason: low and uniform prices attract buyers.

Faster the adoption of a technology like CAS, sooner more transparency will come into the Indian broadcast and cable industry, which has been plagued by massive under-declaration by cable ops


A low price entry point for a new technology --- about which myths abound still for the general public --- is certainly a good way of incentivising its quick adoption. And, faster the adoption of a technology like CAS, sooner more transparency will come into the Indian broadcast and cable industry, which has been plagued by massive under-declaration by cable operations and other such ills in the absence of any regulation.

But in attempting to keep cable TV as a mass service ---- which it is, anyway --- and having the prices of all pay channels uniform, Trai has forgotten one important aspect of regulatory process: the cost factor while deciding tariff for a service.

The real boom in the Indian cellular phone market came when players clipped price lines and made the whole process of acquiring a mobile phone connection so cheap and attractive that even a domestic hand found it hard to resist. Who can forget a certain Indian telecom player's offer of a mobile phone connection with unlimited talk time for a certain period of time and the handset thrown in for Rs 500 under the Monsoon Hungama or monsoon bonanza scheme some time ago?

Trai, which also oversees the telecom sector, may actually take pride in claiming that it facilitated massive growth in cellular phones in the country. The numbers say it all. There are more cellular phone connections in the country compared to fixed line connections. But broadcast industry cannot crow like its telecom counterpart.

Though cable TV service, unlike some others like transport (especially capital intensive railway transport), cannot be categorized as a natural monopoly, the cost of putting together that service cannot be overlooked.

In forcing an entertainment broadcaster to sell its product at a ridiculously low cost, Trai is trying to say Indian consumers don't appreciate high quality production values.


Not as capital intensive as power or transport sectors, cable TV nevertheless does need investments to be made by all stakeholders of the value chain. By presuming that all types of content can be acquired comparatively cheap and revenue generated through volume sales (after all, India now boasts of 68 million C&S homes with all TV homes standing at 110 million), the regulator has highlighted its partial ignorance of how the broadcast business is conducted.

Imagine the plight of Nimbus, for example, which has bought Indian cricket rights for over $ 600 million hoping that the content would help it to price its proposed channel at a premium. But now it would have no option but to price a pay channel at Rs 5 and look at rejigging the whole business model.

There is no denying that the programming costs in the sports, movies and entertainment segments are higher than news or infotainment channels segment. In forcing an entertainment broadcaster to sell its product at a ridiculously low cost --- when compared to the input costs of aggregating content --- Trai, probably, is trying to say that Indian consumers don't appreciate high quality production values and can be served shoddy work. Class comes with a price tag and the price decided by the regulator is unlikely to encourage quality.

Could Trai have gone in for differential pricing for some genres of channels? Yes, of course it could have, and displayed a visionary flair in the process.

But as long as regulators like Trai remain hostage to a government's whims and fancies, it would always open itself to the criticism of pandering to politicians' wishes, which are mostly based on populism.

Still, there is no gainsaying that the last word on this tale is a long way away from being written. And, if the way the currents are flowing are anything to go by, it could well be on this critical point that Trai's efforts to usher in the CAS era could fall flat!

Latest Reads
Top Innovative Video Marketing Trends for 2020

With the COVID-19 pandemic occupying most of 2020, many businesses have had to suffer its dire consequences. Companies have had to shut down, people have lost their jobs, and the economies of countries have gone down by leaps and bounds. With the economy slowly coming back on track, businesses are...

Resources Education
How Remote Medical Care During The COVID-19 Crisis Is a Boon to the society

The world we live in now bears no resemblance to the one we used to live in a few months ago. The COVID-19 crisis has impacted every aspect of our life over the past couple of months. Earlier, going to the hospital to consult our doctor used to be a part of our routine. Now, however, the very...

Resources Education
8 Movies to Write an Analysis Paper on

Not all the movies and serial movies you watch are suitable for an analysis paper. Unfortunately, professors are often a little old-fashioned, and you should choose a movie remembering that. We have collected eight very different movies that you can find suitable for this assignment. If you need to...

Resources Education
India’s Digital Revolution and the State of Online Gaming

Indian online gaming has come of age, and its popularity across the age spectrum means this is no longer viewed as childish play. Influenced by the rapid development of technology, the availability of online games, and a higher gross per capita, a gaming class has been firmly established in India.

Resources Education

The days are gone when you needed to mop your home floor by kneeling with one hand holding a bucket of water and the other hand holding a mop. Also, such tedious mopping task would lead to problems of knee and back pain. So, what to do? Due to such a problem, you cannot stop mopping! Keeping our...

Resources Education
How to Host a Holi Card Party That Your Friends Will Love?

Host a Holi Party with spectacular card games with a desi touch for your family! Read this article for tips and tricks on how to throw your best party yet! Holi is a festival where people forget bitter past and come together to celebrate and love each other. It is a festival of positive vibes,...

Resources Education
E3 2020 Cancelled: Organizers Looking at Alternative Options to Continue Event

Electronic Entertainment Expo or E3 2020, the biggest gaming event of the world has been cancelled, to the disappointment of gaming fans and supporters. However, it has a good reason following the coronavirus outbreak. Canceling the event will ensure the safety of every one given that COVID-19 is...

Resources Education
How the 2019 Coronavirus has Affected the Sports Industry

The coronavirus is now declared as a pandemic by the World Health Organization. Currently, there are now over 140,000 cases related to this. The virus has also caused over 5,000 fatalities. It has already spread to over 100 countries.

Resources Education
Teen Patti Is More Popular Amongst Indians Than Ever

Teen Patti is a very popular game in India and some parts of SouthEast Asia. It is a game of cards which is mostly offered by casinos and bars, and played between 3 and 6 people at a time, using 52 cards. Teen Patti game online is also widespread in India, and it is getting popular by the day. Why...

Resources Education

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories

* indicates required