TDSAT asks MSM not to disconnect signals to Manthan if dues paid
NEW DELHI: MSM Media Distribution Pvt. Ltd has been directed not to disconnect the signals to Manthan Broadband Services Pvt. Ltd if the latter makes payments under a formula worked out by the Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (TDSAT).
TDSAT asked Manthan to make the payment to the respondent for the outstanding dues as under: 
(a) Rs 1.5 crore by 25 December
(b) Rs 1.5 crore – 15 days thereafter
(c) The balance amount after adjusting TDS amount by 31 January, 2016. 
TDSAT members Kuldip Singh and B B Srivastava in their judgment said in terms of the regulations, three months period after expiry of the existing agreement is permitted to enable the parties to negotiate and arrive at a fresh agreement. During this period, the terms of the old agreement are applicable but when the fresh agreement is signed, the same have to abide by the terms of the new agreement. 
Since the parties have not been able to come to any agreement even after three months, the Tribunal felt that Manthan must clear the outstanding amount of subscription dues as per old agreement if it wishes to continue with the signals of MSM. 
With regard to the credit period, the Tribunal noted that not only is the agreement not in subsistence but dues have also accumulated over a period of time. 
Further, since the subscription fee and placement charges are governed by two separate agreements, which are not even subsisting as on date, the Tribunal said Manthan cannot insist on adjustment of placement fees against the dues of license fee. 
It had been submitted during the hearing that in terms of the notices issued under regulation 6(i) of DAS Regulations 2012, Manthan has to pay MSM for subscription fees as under: 
MSM O/s for Kolkata as per notice dated 29.10.2015 Rs 4,04,53,536/- 
MSM O/s for Ranchi as per notice dated 5.11.2015 Rs 55,60,609/- 
TV Today O/s for Ranchi as per notice dated 5.11.2015 Rs 1,12,395/-
TV Today O/s for Kolkata as per invoice dated 1.10.2015 Rs 8,20,680/-
Manthan counsel Navin Chawla submitted that under the understanding between the parties, his client was getting a credit period of two months for payment of subscription dues. He further submitted that under the invoices issued by Manthan, MSM owes a sum of Rs 4.73 crore as on October 2015 towards placement charges of the channels of the respondent. After netting off the placement charges, Chawla had claimed that it was MSM who had to pay an amount of Rs 1.58 crore to Manthan. 
Chawla referred to minutes of meeting between the parties held on 11 - 13 August in which MSM admitted placement charges of Rs 2.97 crore till July, 2015. However, MSM counsel Ramji Srinivasan submitted that there is no netting off clause in the subscription agreement for adjusting subscription fees against placement charges and in any case the agreement for placement had expired on 31 March, 2015 and therefore, Manthan cannot claim any placement charges in the absence of any such agreement. He further submitted that the minutes of meeting of August was part of a negotiation process and cannot be relied upon in the absence of a concluded agreement. 
The Tribunal noted that the subscription agreement between the parties expired on 31 March, 2015 by efflux of time and no fresh agreement has been signed till date. 

Latest Reads
NBDSA takes cognizance of three debate shows aired by Times Now channel on Teesta Samvad

Mumbai: The News Broadcasting & Digital Standards Authority (NBDSA), has taken cognizance of three debate shows aired by Times Now channel on Teesta Setalvad. This was based on a complaint dated 1 July, 2022 filed by Citizens for Justice and Peace, which mentioned about three debate shows aired...

Regulators I&B Ministry
Govt of India looks into applicability of FDI Policy for OTT Platforms

Mumbai: The Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) provided for FDI up to 26 per cent under the Government approval route for entities involved in uploading/streaming of news and current affairs through digital media in a press note dated 18 September, 2019. DPIIT later...

Regulators People
NBF and NBDA join hands to sit out of DD Free Dish auctions

Mumbai: News Broadcasters Federation (NBF) and the News Broadcasters & Digital Association (NBDA), which represent almost all the national and regional news channels of the country, have decided not to participate in the ongoing DD Free Dish MPEG-2 e-auction. In a letter to I&B Minister...

Regulators People
DD Free Dish auction: Prasar Bharati earns over Rs 190 crore on Day 2

Mumbai: Public broadcaster Prasar Bharati has earned over Rs 191 crore on Day 2 of the fifth annual 67th e-auction for vacant MPEG-2 slots on DD FreeDish. According to the sources, 11 channels secured slots on the second day; six in the Bucket A+ category (Hindi GEC) and five in Bucket A category (...

Regulators I&B Ministry
Technical difficulties push the DD Free Dish MPEG-2 e-auction to today.

Mumbai: Due to technical issues, the DD Free Dish MPEG-2 e-auction has been postponed by one day. The e-auction could not take place on Monday, 13 March due to a technical issue, according to industry sources, but it will begin today, 14 March . The online e-auction was set to begin on March 13,...

Regulators People
Trai extends date for comments and counter-comments on 'Introduction of Digital Connectivity Infrastructure Provider Authorisation under Unified License (UL)'

Mumbai : The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) has extended the deadline for receiving written comments on a consultation paper "'Introduction of Digital Connectivity Infrastructure Provider Authorisation under Unified License (UL)' " issued on  6 April 2023 and 20 April 2023. The...

Regulators TRAI
Vulgar language and content on OTT platforms need to be regulated : Delhi HC

The Delhi High Court stated that appropriate legislation or guidelines to regulate content on social media and OTT platforms are urgently needed in the context of the use of vulgar language in the public domain and on social media platforms, as this content is accessible to children of a vulnerable...

Regulators High Court
Indian telcos may soon be able to build small towers without obtaining permission

Mumbai : Indian telecom companies may soon be able to install tiny towers without obtaining government approval.  According to a news report , there may not be a need for approval for the installation of BTS up to 600W.  The government may soon release new regulations that would make this possible...

Regulators TRAI
Trai to release a new consultation paper on the regulatory framework

Mumbai : Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) has planned to publish a fresh consultation paper on the regulatory framework concerns pertaining to broadcasters.  It will cover the cap on network capacity fees, multi-TV tariffs, and channel pricing. In 4-6 weeks, this work is anticipated to...

Regulators TRAI