IAMAI requests TRAI to recognise OTT services as "digital applications"

It thinks the issue of regulatory gap between ISPs and digital application providers is unjustifi


MUMBAI: The Internet and Mobile Association of India (IAMAI) has reiterated that the term over-the-top (OTT) does not justify the innovation in the digital applications at the application layer. In its submission on counter comments to the OTT communication services consultation paper by industry body Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) it has asked the regulator to recognise OTT communication services as ‘digital applications’.

“Using the terminology of OTT paints digital applications as free-riding over telecom networks, as they are accessible to all users with internet service without any arrangements / agreements with TSPs. Using the internet to offer services to consumers does not amount to free-riding, as consumers pay TSPs for the data that they use,” IAMAI said.

The industry body has also added that digital applications provide different services with diverse functionalities that do not merely replicate legacy telecom services. It has also noted that the use of the term “over the top” tries to equate the services while differentiating the mode of their accessibility. According to IAMAI, the services provided by digital service providers in the areas of communication, e-commerce, news, social media etc., do not provide substitutable services.

While submitting comments on the OTT consultation paper, some of the telecom operators and COAI sought to qualify the services provided by some of the digital applications to be similar or substitutes for telecom services. IAMAI is of the view that digital applications are qualitatively very different from telecom services.

“Identifying Rich Interaction Applications (“RIAs”) as comparable to telecom services is highly reductionist and unjustified. Moreover, digital applications are not available to those telecom subscribers who do not have access to the internet. While internet penetration in India is increasing with the rapid adoption of smartphones, this number is still a very small percentage of the Indian population. On the other hand, users can access telecom services without internet access or even smartphones,” it commented.

Some of the stakeholders also spoke about the regulatory gap between ISPs and digital application providers. In response to that, IAMAI has said that the digital applications are duly governed by the IT Act under the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology. It added that any new regulations under a different regulatory authority will only convolute the existing regulatory regime and adversely affect the ease of doing business in the country.

“The argument of “same services same rules” was laid to rest in previous TRAI consultations on the matter. TSPs, with access to scarce national resources like spectrum and having restrictive access over physical infrastructures cannot possibly be compared to services being provided at the application layer, and any discussion of regulatory imbalance between the two would be comparing apples with oranges,” it highlighted.

IAMAI thinks all arguments of service or functional substitution by the telcos ultimately stem from a narrow perception of revenue substitution. In this context, it has highlighted that earlier some telcos acknowledged that the rise of digital applications has actually led to a rise in data revenues for these service providers.

“IAMAI would like to request the authority not to encourage TSPs to cherry-pick digital applications that help raise their revenues while choose to clamp down those they perceive as a threat for their revenues. Regulations should be based on principles and using regulations as restrictive tools for protecting business interests is a myopic outlook that harms the greater interest of the nation at large,” it commented.

Latest Reads

Sachin, Sehwag to open for India again

MUMBAI: Master Blaster Sachin Tendulkar, one of the most fearsome opening batsman of all time Virender Sehwag, the legendary West Indian Brian Lara, lethal Aussie speedster Bret Lee, one of Sri Lanka’s most stylish and dependable batsman of all time Tillakaratne Dilshan and the one and only, who...

iWorld Over The Top Services
Netflix’s mobile-only plan in India exceeds expectations; to help invest more in content

Netflix has bounced back in its Q3 2019 financials by posting revenue of $5.245 billion, which was almost in line with analysts’ prediction of $5.25 billion and was up by 31 per cent y-o-y. While the expected earnings per share were $1.04, Netflix boosted that by delivering $1.47. This is almost...

iWorld Over The Top Services
Ali Hussein promoted to CEO at Eros Now

MUMBAI: Ali Hussein has been elevated to the post of chief executive officer (CEO) at Eros Now, the digital arm of Eros International PLC. Hussein joined the organisation as chief operating officer in 2018. His experience spans over 15 years in the media entertainment and digital space. Ali has...

iWorld Over The Top Services
ZEE5 and Wework host discussion on changing landscape of the digital world

MUMBAI: Addressingthe rapidly evolving digital ecosystem in India, ZEE5 India and WeWork India today co-created an evening of discussions on the Changing Landscape of the Digital World.Tarun Katial, CEO – ZEE5 India, India’s fastest growing ConTech brand, and Ryan Bennett, CWeO of WeWork India,...

iWorld Over The Top Services
ShemarooMe’s platform design gets recognized at ‘India’s Best Design Awards 2019’

MUMBAI: Shemaroo’s video-streaming OTT platform- ShemarooMe's design has bagged India’s Best Design Project 2019 award at the recently concluded ‘India’s Best Design Awards 2019’ organized by Indi Pool for the work done by Fractal Ink Design Studio on its user interface and experience. The award is...

iWorld Over The Top Services
VICE Media Group taps Rohit Tugnait as Commercial Director, India

MUMBAI: VICE Media Group, the world’s largest independent youth media company, is pleased to announce the appointment of senior media executive Rohit Tugnait as Commercial Director for its India territory.  Tugnait will lead the commercial teams based in Mumbai, Bangalore and Delhi and will be...

iWorld Over The Top Services
Microscan launches Internet Service in Aurangabad

MUMBAI: Internet Service Provider Microscan Infocommtech has launched its services in Aurangabad. Microscan has joined hands with Elixir Telelinks to increase its reach and offer premium Internet Services in the city. This partnership plays to both partner’s individual strengths in which the...

iWorld Over The Top Services
ONEOTT Intertainment Limited wins TelecomLead.com Innovation Leaders award 2019

Mumbai: OneOTTIntertainment Limited (OIL), was awarded the 2019 Innovation leaders award by Telecomlead.com. OIL won this prestigious award for adopting innovative steps for expanding broadband connectivity to under connected population in urban locations, like –connectivity of 50 Hotspots in...

iWorld Over The Top Services
Prime Focus Technologies selected as event coverage partner for L’Oréal Professionnel’s Indian Hairdressing Awards 2018-19

MUMBAI: Prime Focus Technologies (PFT) announced that its video agency, PFT Brands was selected by L’Oréal Professionnel as the official event coverage partner for the prestigious Indian Hairdressing Awards (IHA) 2018-19. IHA was launched as a platform to recognize excellence in not only the art,...

iWorld Over The Top Services

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories