Report on Shemaroo

TDSAT & Ad cap: TRAI almost done with its arguments

MUMBAI: The third day of the arguments presented by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) saw several crucial points being touched upon and the TDSAT also noting down points that could be pondered upon for rumination.

The TRAI counsel Rakesh Dwivedi pointed out that if one reads section 7 (11) of the Cable TV Networks (CTN) Act then it must be read with the ad cap regulation because the regulator was using it only to enforce this section.

Section 7 (11) states that the authority has the power to 'seize equipment used for operating the cable television network if it is found to be breaching its other sections'.

According to the TRAI, programmes and advertisements are different and the regulator is trying to prevent intermixing of these two and ensuring an increase in quality of service.

The regulator also gave its version regarding Article 19 (a) of the Constitution saying that airwaves and frequencies are a public property of the government and so there is no fundamental right that can apply to it. Electronic media and press are different and cannot be treated equally. Broadcasters are companies and not citizens so fundamental rights don’t apply to them, Dwivedi argued.

The point about misuse of clock hour was once again raised by Justice Aftab Alam to which the TRAI reverted by saying that the clock hour regulation instituted by the TRAI and the CTN Act are the same thing and they cannot be interpreted in any other way. Broadcasters are thinking of a bankable hour, that can be carried over within 24 hours but the TRAI says that a clock hour is fixed.

The bench questioned the TRAI that if it could have enforced the ad cap law under the CTN Act then it need not have made a separate regulation or a direction or use the TRAI act for it.

To this, counsel said that the CTN Act only applies to cable operators at this stage. And just because they have two powers that are coinciding they cannot take away one power. The point where broadcasters come into the picture of this Act, is for the advertising and programming code, which they have to adhere to by virtue of them having to apply for an uplinking and downlinking licence.

The TRAI counsel also requested that merely because it had framed a regulation or passed a direction the bench may not nullify it because it has passed it under the TRAI act and not the CTN act, although it has powers under both. He also requested that if the bench were to find anything wrong with the ad cap regulation, they may modify it. However, Alam said that it cannot be done since it was a delegated regulation. To this TRAI asked the bench to consider it as a direction and then modify it keeping in mind the best interest of the viewers.

One of the arguments, that the counsel raised, relates to Article 14 of the Indian Constitution that speaks about the fundamental right to equality. He stated that it would be in fair spirit if cable operators and broadcasters are not equated with each other at this juncture. The TRAI counsel presented data which clearly showed that broadcasters were airing TV commercials for an unbearable duration every day in between programmes and hence it had decided to apply the ad cap to them first. The limits on TV commercial time will be imposed on cable operators later by the TRAI, the counsel revealed. And the fact that cable ops will be made to comply later does not mean that broadcasters should be excluded from the ad cap now.

The counsel said he would be addressing the issue of clubbing channel genres together on Monday.

The bench asked the TRAI why it wasn’t willing to wait till digitization was completed to impose the ad cap regulation. The TRAI argued that by September 2014, nearly 50 per cent of the country will be digitized. Hence it was a good enough reason to bring in ad time limits rules now so that TV air time could be slowly modulated over the period. The TRAI counsel agreed the regulation may not be perfect in its current form, but that does not give the TDSAT a reason to strike it down.

Regarding FTA channels, Dwivedi said that the broadcasters had not given the TRAI any financial or commercials analysis of the minute by minute usage of ad time and data to support that ad revenues will indeed fall when the ad cap comes into effect. Hence, the regulator had made a general reccee of the channels and deduced what needed to be done and only then drawn up the ad cap regulation. It also stated that FTA channels don’t have too many ads so TRAI did not know why they were objecting to it.

At the end of the proceedings, an important observation was made by the TDSAT that if the ad cap regulation is struck down, no law can be contended except section 7 (11) of the CTN Act, because broadcasters have accepted this act. Articles 14 and 19 (1) (a) of the Constitution are against the imposition of the ad cap regulation and then the only thing that remains is the interpretation of the 7 (11) section of the CTN Act.

The TRAI will continue with its arguments on Monday and the broadcasters are scheduled to speak after that.

Latest Reads
Panasonic India promotes Dinesh Agarwal as Life Solutions' joint MD

NEW DELHI: Panasonic India has unveiled its new Spatial Solution Division, a move to expand the company's strong presence in the smart home solutions market. The Japanese electronics giant has also promoted Dinesh Agarwal as the new joint managing director of Panasonic Life Solutions.  In this new...

MAM Media and Advertising People
Madison Media wins 23 new businesses in FY 2020-21

Mumbai: Madison Media has created a record by winning 23 new accounts in a financial year, the agency said in a press statement. Amidst the nationwide lockdown and work-from-home, the new business wins amounted to a billing of $211 million as per Convergence New Business Report published in March...

MAM Media and Advertising AD Agencies
Washington Sundar signs on as Anker brand ambassador

MUMBAI: Chinese electronics company Anker has roped in Washington Sundar as its brand ambassador. From now, Sundar will helm all major campaigns for the brand across media platforms. The cricketer is also expected to appear in his first promotional TVC for the brand very soon.  The partnership...

MAM Marketing Brands
Rashmika Mandanna just can’t get enough of the new McSpicy fried chicken

MUMBAI: Your favourite food is sure to be the one thing you just can’t get enough of! With this as the central theme, McDonald’s India (west and south) has launched a campaign with popular film celebrity Rashmika Mandanna to celebrate the deliciousness of McSpicy Fried Chicken. The brand has...

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
Carat India appoints Dipika Bhasin as executive vice president

MUMBAI: Dentsu International’s media agency Carat India has brought on Dipika Bhasin as executive vice president. In her new role, Dipika will lead the agency’s north and east offices, drive growth in these regions, and focus on developing and managing Carat's senior client relationship. She will...

MAM Media and Advertising People
Satish Krishnamurthy is TBWA\India’s new chief strategy officer

MUMBAI: TBWA\India has appointed Satish Krishnamurthy as chief strategy officer, with immediate effect. He takes over from Subramanian Krishnan, who will be transitioning into a part time consulting role with the agency. Before joining TBWA\India, Krishnamurthy was head of strategy at Sideways...

MAM Media and Advertising People
IPL 2021 Brandwagon: Ads that generated buzz

MUMBAI: It's not without reason that cricket is considered a religion in India – nothing can whip up mass fervour like this sport. And what could have proved this better than the opening match of Vivo IPL 2021, which clocked, believe it or not, a colossal 10 billion minutes of viewership on Star...

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
Nestle India posts strong Q1 performance, net profit surges 14.6%

NEW DELHI: FMCG major Nestle India posted a strong performance in the opening quarter of 2021, reporting a 14.6 per cent year-on-year growth in its net profit. Beating estimates, its PAT stood at Rs 602 crore, up from Rs 525 crore in the year-ago period. Total sales increased by 8.9 per cent during...

MAM Marketing MAM
Amit Jain named chairperson of MMA India board of directors

MUMBAI: MMA, formerly known as the Mobile Marketing Association, has appointed L’Oréal India managing director Amit Jain as chairperson of its India board of directors. Jain succeeds Priya Nair, who is the executive director – beauty and personal care at Hindustan Unilever. Nair will move into a...

MAM Media and Advertising People

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories

* indicates required