Will More News Make Less Cents


When you lose in television news you lose big time! TV news, 24/7, is a huge, hungry, unforgiving animal that will swallow up every paisa you have and still want more.

Amid the euphoria and excitement that's swirling around the industry at the moment, not least from the handful of stars who are seeing their pay packets go through the roof, spare a thought for the accountants. They have a tough year ahead.

The clamour to climb on the TV news bandwagon is being driven by the belief that audiences cannot get enough of watching live drama unfolding before their very eyes. Terrible, but gripping events like 9/11, the Afghan war and the attacks on Parliament and Gujarat's Akshardham have all pulled in the viewers. And viewers, in a very crude sense, mean money.


"Advertisers have woken up to TV news as an untapped and cost effective way to sell your product; certainly compared to the price of sticking your toilet cleaner between two halves of an expensive drama"



Advertisers have woken up to TV news as an untapped and cost effective way to sell your product; certainly compared to the price of sticking your toilet cleaner between two halves of an expensive drama. And so, to come full circle, where the money goes the TV execs follow hence the five new TV operations heading our way next year. The question is how much is too much.

All these TV channels are essentially competing for the same audience i.e the great middle class. The audience is large and it will grow larger but not as quickly as the number of TV channels trying to serve it. Some media analysts suggest that only three of the new channels will survive. But even for those that do, it'll be an expensive and painful experience which may leave even some of the already established Indian channels feeling more than a little bruised.

And what of the other players in the market like BBC World and the other international news channels? CNN already appears to have abandoned its South Asia coverage to fight a rearguard action in the United States with FOX who, for the first time this year, have edged ahead in the ratings war. The sight of CNN's correspondent reporting on the count in Gujarat from a telephone line in Delhi shows that Atlanta has its eyes and its resources elsewhere.

So in India that's meant CNBC has taken over the second slot from CNN. BBC World is still no 1 in India and by far the most watched international news channel taking up 33 of the top fifty slots in a recent survey on audience viewing habits but even so, we've still had to have a re-think, and react not only to the changing conditions in South Asia but from across the world. New markets are constantly opening up to the organisation, like the fact that in the last few years, BBC World has gone from practically zero to now being in 86% of American homes.

So this month the BBC created a new global news division to bring BBC World TV, World Service Radio and the BBC News On-line service under one Boss to fight a united international campaign. My appointment too as the first BBC South Asia Bureau Editor responsible for our entire news operation from Kabul to Colombo (via Delhi!) is an acknowledgment that the organisation cannot manage and adapt to the new environment in South Asia with a long arm from London.

But for the time being, the international channels are the last thing the Indian companies are worrying about. Their big priorities at the moment are how to catch and keep the local talent. TV news is still a young industry here and the pool of reserves are quite small.

So everyone is trying to poach from everyone else, pushing up wages and expectations. And the canny players, like Prannoy Roy know the importance of the talent. He has built up and seems likely to keep, with some hefty pay rises and attractive packages, his very good people. The likes of Rajdeep are tried and trusted by ordinary Indians. No one, least of all Mr Roy, under estimates the importance to the brand of a familiar face. That's why anchors in the US are paid tens of millions of dollars a year to essentially read an auto cue for half an hour a day. But the crunch will come when all the channels suddenly come up against a big costly running story hitting the headlines. Wars and conflicts are expensive.

Both for the participants and the people trying to cover them. If you want to be a big player you have to make a serious financial commitment, if you don't the audience will turn over to those that do. And the first big story in the brave new world of Indian 24 hour news will probably not be in South Asia at all but in Iraq. The programme makers will have to decide whether they want to ride the backs of their international partners (if they have them) or dip deep into their pockets to put the likes of Barkha on a tank in the Iraqi desert to show they really mean business. A serious conflict between Pakistan and India would be even more expensive.

So what will the scene look like two years from now. Journalists are lousy at predictions but that never seems to stop us (the Gujarat poll is proof of that) so here goes. Firstly I'd be surprised, like everyone else, if one or two Chief execs don't end up watching their new cars being towed out the drive as the bills come rolling in and the advertising tapers off. The stars will stay stars though and their salaries will stay with them but the middle rung correspondents and producers, cashing in now on their new found market value, should enjoy it while it lasts. If someone crashes so will their big pay rises.

That at least was what happened in Europe during the swings and roundabouts of the media there. But the industry as a whole will emerge stronger and fitter and a new generation of talent will be created. That, in the long run, can only be good for the Indian viewer.

(The author is BBC South Asia Bureau Editor. His e-mail is paul.danahar@bbc.co.uk)

Latest Reads

Rs 12 billion budgeted for 'Digital India' '17-18

With the Government’s emphasis on cashless and paper-less working, electronic governance gets the highest chunk of Rs 4.0055 billion out of the overall budget of Rs 12.1642 billion set aside for Digital India for 2017-18.

Specials Budget Budget 2017
Ravi Shankar too hopes DTH will support Swayam

Union Minister of Electronics & Information Technology and Law & Justice Ravi Shankar Prasad said, “The budget of Modi government for 2017-18 is historic and unprecedented. This is a budget for bold India, clean India, eager to tap its potential. Based on the pillars of efficiency,...

Specials Budget Budget 2017
Budget '17: SAP enables mid-sized cos to go digital

Aligning to the Union Budget 2017, SAP SE announced the launch of SAP S/4HANA Private Cloud, the next generation business suite tailored for midsize companies, which will be available at a simple and affordable subscription pricing.

Specials Budget Budget 2017
Budget '17: Rural net will facilitate travel bookings

The union budget has broadly focused on themes such as the farming sector, the tourism industry, development of road network, and infrastructure. The high speed internet connectivity in rural areas will now be the biggest advantage to the travellers.

Specials Budget Budget 2017
MIP '17: Nippon TV gears up with two scripted, three non-scripted formats

MUMBAI: Having recently been crowned ratings champion for the third consecutive year in Japan, coupled with the tremendous success of its scripted drama Mother which has received numerous offers from around the world and is a ratings success in Turkey as ANNE, Nippon Television Network Corporation...

Specials Event Coverage Miptv
Budget '17 initiatives will drive overall demand, believe startups

Startups are in a celebratory mode after the presentation of the Union Budget 2017 by the finance minister Arun Jaitley. He announced that small businesses with an annual turnover of Rs 50 crore will now have to pay five per cent less income tax, in order to make micro, small and medium enterprises...

Specials Budget Budget 2017
Top M&E industry honchos see no major benefit from Budget '17

MUMBAI: With the Union Budget’s focus on rural and infrastructure sectors, the media and entertainment (M&E) industry seems to be disappointed as the budget does not offer much. Though the sector is hoping to get some benefit through the digital push mentioned in the budget, expectations were...

Specials Budget Budget 2017
Budget '17: Leading digital players hail sectoral boost

“Digital economy helps in cleaning up the system, has transformational impact, energises private investment through low-cost credit, and benefits the common man,” asserted finance minister Arun Jaitley while announcing the Union Budget 2017 on 1 February. The budget 2017 emphasised a lot on the...

Specials Budget Budget 2017
Budget '17: Prasar Bharati grant-in-aid down, film sector's aid up

NEW DELHI: The grant-in-aid for Prasar Bharati has come down marginally from the revised estimates from Rs 4500 million in 2016-17 to Rs 4300 million for 2017-18. This includes a grants-in-aid to the pubcaster of Rs 3500 million and a separate grant-in-aid to it for the Kisan Channel of Rs 800...

Specials Budget Budget 2017

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories