indiantelevision.com presents AdEx India Analysis
 
Indiantelevision.com has been at the forefront of providing original content, news, information and analysis on the business of cable & satellite television to visitors. Our association with AdEx India enables us to continue to serve our core readers - television executives, media planners and buyers, advertisers - with cutting edge insights from India's leading advertising expenditure monitoring firm.
 
 

Indian TV stations follow International norms on ad clutter levels: An AdEx India Analysis

(6 may 2004)

 
 

How much of advertising should there really be on television? Are there any international norms for the same? How do Indian TV stations fare in such a comparison with TV channels abroad? These were some of the questions that we, at ADEX India, tried to answer. In this context, we looked at the year 2003 to evaluate just how critical this issue really is.

Let's first take a look at some international norms, before we evaluate Indian channels.
.The ABA (Australian Broadcasting Authority) reportedly recommends 10 minutes of advertising per hour of children's programming and up to 15 minutes for non-prime time programs.
.The National association of Philippines broadcasters, the KBP, as per its TV code of conduct stipulates a commercial load for television in Metro Manila to 18 minutes per hour, while for provincial TV stations, commercial load permissible is a maximum of 20 minutes per program hour.
.A new regulation introduced in China, from 1 January 2004, sets limits on the total length of ads allowed between 7 pm to 9 pm to a maximum of nine minutes per hour of programming
.In Canada, the Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission (CRTC), recommends eight minutes of advertising per hour during children's programming compared to twelve minutes of advertising per hour during regular programming
.In a couple of other far-eastern economies, the stipulation is eight minutes of advertising time and two minutes of program promo time, that is, a total of 10 minutes of break duration

 

With these kinds of trends emerging across various countries, the average duration/ hour of pure advertising time (not containing any promo durations), in India, should produce a sigh of relief for most broadcasters. That's because, the practices in India are pretty much in line with the international norms. When we look at an all-channels average advertising time, it amounts to only 192 seconds of pure advertising time per hour for the year of 2003. That is a meager three minutes of advertising time per hour of programming... almost one-third the International norms!!!

Even if we divide all channels into DD channels, pay channels and free to air- FTA channels: it is quite clear that the average ad durations per hour for all the three sets are well below the 9 to 10 minute mark set in International markets! Its only one minute 42 seconds for DD stations, three minutes 39 seconds for FTA channels and three minutes 28 seconds for pay channels!

 
 
Even when we split the above averages by prime time versus non-prime, the clutter levels at a broad level seem to be well within the international standards. The maximum value comes up for FTA channels who have six minutes and 54 seconds of average ad duration per hour of prime time programming.
 

 
Moving to average advertising durations for different quarters; it is quite obvious that average duration is highest for the festive fourth quarter.  Advertising durations during the second quarter are also quite high for pay as well as for FTA channels. But for DD channels, they are highest in the third as well as fourth quarters. But again here the results are lower than the highest limit set by various International economies on their TV stations.
 
 
Moving further to average advertising durations across various channel genres; Hindi movie channels (Zee Cinema, Star Gold, Max), general entertainment channels (Star Plus, Zee TV, Sony Entertainment, DD1, DD Metro) and news channels (Aaj Tak, Star News, Zee News, Sahara Samay, BBC, NDTV 24X 7, NDTV India) get the best deal with 321, 302 and 299 secs/hour of pure advertising respectively. 

Music channels (B4U Music, CMM, ETC, MTV, Channel V, Zee Music), kids/infotainment channels (Cartoon Network, Discovery, Animal Planet, National Geographic Channel) and English entertainment channels (Star World, Zee English, AXN) get the second best with 278, 165 and 141 secs respectively.  English movie channels (Star Movies, HBO, Zee MGM) and sports channels (Star Sports, ESPN, Ten Sports, DD Sports) have the least advertising secondages per hour amounting to mere 130 and 107 seconds respectively.

Moving further to average advertising durations across various channel genres; Hindi movie channels (Zee Cinema, Star Gold, Max), general entertainment channels (Star Plus, Zee TV, Sony Entertainment, DD1, DD Metro) and news channels (Aaj Tak, Star News, Zee News, Sahara Samay, BBC, NDTV 24X7, NDTV India) get the best deal with 321, 302 and 299 secs/hour of pure advertising respectively.

 
 
 
Finally while the overall results of this analysis would come as a big relief for TV stations in the country where they can congratulate on being within International norms of ad clutter, there is a note of caution as well... One issue is that if clutter continues to rise, viewership will get dramatically affected! Longer breaks usually mean that audiences will get away to other channels. Same is the case with too many breaks within programs.

The other issue to note here is that the durations considered here have only been pure commercial advertising. Program promos and film trailers have been left out of this analysis.

We shall be coming out with similar such analyses during the coming weeks.  Keep watching this space for more...

 
Analysis from AdEx India (A Division of TAM Media Research pvt ltd)
 
Click here for Adex India Archives
 
Click here for Adex India order Form
 

Email this page Print This Page Home
 

Contact Us | Feedback | About Indiantelevision | Disclaimer
© 2001- 2005 Indian Television Dot Com Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.