'Broadcasters could consider different pricing for rural-urban subscribers'


When DEN Networks promoter Sameer Manchanda set up the national MSO in 2007, one of the key professionals on his team, which was led by CEO Anuj Gandhi, was the cable TV veteran S.N. Sharma. The trio quickly ramped up the company and took it to national level status.  Gandhi then moved on in 2010 to join Network18. And, Sharma who was the president (operations), was promoted as the CEO a year or so later.

He continued with the company, expanding it nationally, and seeing it through the first two phases of digitization before departing in 2015 to get on board India’s biggest and most funded  startup  -- the Mukesh Ambani-backed Reliance Jio.  A former McKinsey professional Pradeep Parameswaran was roped in to lead the company in his place.

Sharma, meanwhile, at Jio, worked on planning and building the team for company’s foray into cable TV along with another cable TV veteran K. Jayaraman.

Then, in July 2016, Sharma made a sudden about-turn and decided to return to DEN Networks, a move that raised the eyebrows of many but cheered many in the trade. For he is known for his relationships and his deep understanding of how cable TV should be run in the Indian context.

Sharma was one of the key notes at indiantelevision.com’s Eleventh India Digital Operators Summit 2016 which concluded over the weekend at the Leela Hotel in south Goa. He had a one-on-one conversation with Indiantelevision.com Founder, CEO  & Editor in chief Anil Wanvari. Read on to get some insights into what is going on at DEN and with Sharma. Excerpts from the conversation:

Why did you leave DEN in the first case, join Reliance and then why did you choose to come back?

Having been into the cable industry for over 20 plus years, I thought, let me do something else. And, that’s why I moved to Reliance. Basically, I wanted to roll out fibre to the home (FTTH) over there. It would have been a great experience and learning (I thought). And it was, indeed. I learnt a lot in the short span of one and a half year. It was a wonderful learning that I brought in to my personality.

But then, there was a call from my previous employer DEN, my friend Sameer.  I am one of the co-founders of DEN Network. And, I requested my employers at Reliance if I could leave. And they were kind enough to let me go back. It was more of an emotional decision than a professional one. All my learnings that I have had  at Reliance, I am

sure, will help me learn to drive DEN in a better manner,in a positive direction in time to come.

What are the challenges you are facing?

The challenge as we all know is primarily monetization.  We started seeding boxes in 2010, now it is 2016. DAS came in 2012. And "hote hote" (by and by) it became 2013. Phase I and II happened quickly.

There is a lag in monetization. Of course, we all can understand and you will appreciate that an industry which evolved since 1990, almost 30 year old industry, it  takes time for things to change. And, we took tiny, baby steps to monetize it.  But now, the time has come the boxes seeded in 2010 have almost lived their life and new technology is coming in. So my prime task is to see to it that we augment the process of monetization.

The other challenge that I face immediately which I am working very aggressively on is to reduce the cost. We all know that Phase III digitization got into  a confused state, with boxes having got seeded, and the courts intervening.  Analogue signal has also been taken away from many of us. The MIB says 93 per cent  of digitization has happened. So the monetization process also has to start. But, in the bargain, we have already incurred some expenditure.  And unless I start recovering my revenue, the journey will be difficult.

This time, in a short span of one and a half month, I addressed my cable TV partners, my business partners and my associates in a very transparent manner. We had a discussion – a whole day discussion wherein I shared with them my experiences with the telco. I shared with them the upcoming technology. I told them there is a change. The technology is not going to spare them.  We all used to think that last mile ...last mile. But, my subscriber is not bound by last mile. My biggest threat today is the handset that I carry. The viewing habits are changing. Technology is bringing other alternatives. For the same viewer  who used to be watching their services. It is high time they realized it and accepted this change. And, they all agreed. I was surprised. It was a very open, frank and to-the-point discussion. I told them if we are willing to change, if we are willing to adopt, life will be there for us, otherwise the journey is going to be difficult. Everybody is cooperating. We hope to see a very good upside as far as collections are concerned.

Third is making the LCOs, our partners realize the pains we are going through.  And, make them see the technology.

And fourth is we have started conducting sessions with cable TV operator to sensitise them with the consumers. Like the regulator also said: Don’t force things on the consumer. He is in no mood. So the approach has to be friendlier than earlier. We have to change the face of our representative visiting the home of the subscriber. The

presentation of our package has got lost.  We brought in a digital set-top box, we invested in that. But, we forgot in the process that we had not changed our face to the consumer. The cable TV operators accepted that we need to bring in a lot of ethics and discipline in that part.  You will see our representatives wearing uniforms. Uniform could be ours or the LCO's.  It has to be in a presentable form. Today, if you are visited by a courier boy, the way he  is approaching is different.

I am sure the cable TV operators will comply.

Where are you reducing costs?

Our priority early on was to penetrate the market, you increase your reach and when you penetrate certain areas, those can be reached through fibre or through links from telcos. After some time, you realize that you have spent an X amount in reaching an area and you have seeded 50 boxes. It does not make sense to you. So, you need to make a quick decision. You retract, you save money on that. Or you go to another MSO who is reaching the same area  and he has done it using a different pipe. And, he has 50,000 subscribers. So, I would tell him, why don't we share the pipe. That process (of sharing)  has already started.  Then, we have started sharing the infrastructure also in another manner, in terms of content. If a competitor has a pipe serving more subscribers in the same area than I have less or vice-versa, I am open to sharing the pipe with the competitor. This is helping reduce costs. We have started sharing local content with cable operators. The cable operator has local content with him. So, instead of spending separately on the same content, we have started sharing that content too. Then, there are usual steps -- reduction of manpower, to hire on a temporary basis, and cutting down the day-to-day expenses.

Where are you getting your maximum margins?

You see we have largely been a phase III player.  We have seeded 5.5 million in phase III, and 3-4 million are to go in phase IV. Of the 13 million subscribers, we have seeded 9-9.5 million. My upside will come from revenues of phase III boxes, which were yielding Rs 10-20. We have already crossed a milestone of Rs 40- 45 revenues, By December-end, it will touch  Rs 75 plus -- that is a 45 per cent growth. Phase I is likely to give us 15-20 per cent.

Who is going to get you this money – LCOs or the customer?

You see the mood is set.  In the exercise, baby steps were taken to augment phase I revenues. It took us four years.  Phase III customer is also aware.  All studies and research show us is that the  buyingcapacity is there,  paying capacity is there too. HD is another example.  Around 70 per cent of TVs are HDTVs going into to Phase III

areas. As it is for me to perform and deliver, I need my costs to be under control.  On the whole, we have also become very cost-conscious. We want our pie of the revenue.

The cable sector has been bashed red and blue and cable TV bottomlines are stained with red ink? When will it turn around?

You will see by Q3 end there should be an upside.

You are very strong up north. Are you strengthening that or are you expanding into newer territories?

As of now, my focus is to strengthen where we are. I have 13 million subscribers, I am happy to be limited where we are. As we start seeding boxes, it might go to 15 million as we deliver. I want to have a positive bottomline. I want a fair share of revenue. I want to move towards an era where sharing of revenues has be settled. As of now, there is always a dilemma, am I to stand by the TRAI that cable operators should get 35 per cent of revenue. The fact of the matter is that today we are receiving 35 per cent, and he is getting 65 per cent.

I am very much focused that let’s first  set it right. It will take time and over few months. But, I see that over the next 12 months, this will move towards 50:50. And then, as we move forward, and add more values in the system, I am sure the operator will also get to earn  more through us if he wants to stay with us and be part of the journey.  If he says, he does not want to do broadband with, that’s his choice. If that arises, then we might go direct or we have leave that with him. I am very focused that instead of spreading thinly, focus where you, monetize it well. Settle a good business model. A good business case.  Business will follow.

LCOs’ insecurity is less than earlier. Your comments.

You can’t help it. Even MSOs. Nobody is secure. Times are changing. We have to adapt. You can’t ignore the technolgy. If I don’t change, just because my fellow LCO has not, and even I don’t, that’s a folly. Today, in  a matter of time, we started broadband. We have tested a broadband formula. We have close to 125,00 subscribers. We did this with a focused mind in Delhi and Kanpur. To test how the technology behaved, how the arithmetic works here. Now we find that, with 15-17 per cent of penetration, the project is breaking even. Now, anything added into it, is your upside.  The LCOs who are willing to work with us are very happy as they march around with us. And also, there is a learnin that the normal consumer is consuming 40 GB of internet at a speed of 10 mbps at a price of Rs 800. Broadband consumption is rising fast, 5 GB has gone to 10, and 20 GB has gone to 40 GB. Putting in everything into perspective, the cost is Rs 10 per GB.  Next year, I am sure it will be 100GB. And the speed will touch 50 MBPs. In such a scenario, if  I don’t move, somebody else will move.

You must be happy Goldman Sachs invested but it was a discount to its earlier price, actually a deep discount What’s the way forward on the investment?

It’s a subjective analysis . But, you should say that this proves that there is strength in the business model of DEN.

On broadband there will be an increased investment going in. And besides broadband, we are incorporating OTT and value added services.

So what’s the way forward on the pay TV market, with 31 December coming up?

We are looking at it wholly. The boxes are going at a good speed. We are not really pushing. My focus is on getting Phase I, II III right. Once that business model is set in place, everything will also.  It is a matter of time, the  pull should come from the consumer, from the LCO. If he is willing to work with me. In the earlier case, in Phase I and II, we were subsiding the boxes. Today, it is a pure business case. This my product. You want to do business with me, please do.

How can broadcasters assist the process of digitization till the tariff order comes out?

There was a time when broadcasters used to have dual pricing policy. For rural, it was lower, and for urban, higher.  Now, that we have invested and are investing, all of a sudden  they have foregone  that policy of theirs, which they were following in analogue, and still they are following in some places even today. The moment we seed STBs in phase III, they start charging digital rates. I would urge broadcasters too relook at this.

Latest Reads

Ficci Frames and market concludes on grand note

The FICCI Frames and the newly launched content market as part of FICCI Frames 2018 concluded on a grand note.

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
Screen Density: Lessons from the world & Exploring new business models

n Day 2 of FICCI FRAMES happening in Mumbai, there was a session on Screen Density in India attended by some eminent panelists consisting of Mr. William Feng, VP, Greater China, MPA, Kurt Rieder, Head-Theatrical Asia, 20th Century Fox, Kapil Agarwal, Joint MD, UFO, Kamal Gianchandani, Chief of...

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
Broadcasters see positive future for TV in India

MUMBAI: The threat of OTT and integrated platform ecosystems like Android TV is at the peak. Its increasing penetration across all age groups may be a threat to the broadcasters in the coming time. But, it isn’t the case yet in India with 64 per cent TV home penetration and much room for growth....

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
M&E stakeholders need to collaborate for growth: Sudhanshu Vats

MUMBAI: If the Indian media and entertainment (M&E) sector, poised to be Rs 2 trillion industry by 2020, is to be a force multiplier and up the present growth trajectory, then all the stakeholders, including the government, need to collaborate sinking differences, according to Viacom18 Group...

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
M&E to cross Rs 2 trillion by 2020: FICCI-EY report

FICCI Frames 2018 saw the launch of its annual media and entertainment (M&E) report, this year by Ernst & Young (E&Y) titled ‘Re-imagining India's M&E sector’ which captures key insights from the exciting and fast growing Indian M&E sector.

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
Ficci Frames 2018: Smriti Irani for highlighting M&E's economic importance

MUMBAI: Even as the Indian media and entertainment (M&E) sector is projected to cross $31 billion by 2020, Minister for Information and Broadcasting (MIB) Smriti Irani said yesterday it is imperative that the country as a whole projected the economic value that the industry lends to the country...

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
New initiatives at FICCI Frames 2018

MUMBAI: The 19th edition of FICCI Frames to be inaugurated by the I&B and Textiles minister Smriti Irani on March 4 is all set to be a grand event. There are a lot of interesting sessions lined up with few new initiatives this year. The annual media and entertainment global convention...

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
All India Radio, Radio Mirchi, INOX & State Governments join forces with The Festival of Bharat

The Festival of Bharat, a one-stop experiential window into the best of India, partners with India’s national broadcaster, All India Radio, and India’s favourite Hindi music radio station, Radio Mirchi to promote arguably the largest PPP (privately funded and organised, government backed) cultural...

Specials Event Coverage Occasions
FICCI BAF Awards 2018 entries now open

FICCI Frames–the three-day global convention covering the entire gamut of India’s media and entertainment industry–is close, bringing with it the Best Animated Frames (BAF) Awards, one of the most coveted animation, visual effects and gaming (AVG) awards. The last date to submit entries for the...

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories