|
As
the worlds largest television news bazaar with over 40 dedicated
news channels, unrivalled by any other country India offers exciting possibilities
for broadcast journalism. At the same time, just as elsewhere in the world, television
news in India shows a clear trend towards infotainment - soft news, lifestyle
and celebrities - and a decline in journalism for the public interest.
|
Broadcasters
borrow and adapt ideas from entertainment and
adopt an informal style with an emphasis on personalities,
storytelling and spectacle
_____****_____
|
While
news outlets have proliferated globally, the growing
competition for audiences and, crucially, advertising
revenue, has intensified at a time when interest in
news is waning. Audiences for network television peak-time
news bulletins have declined in the US from 85 per cent
in1969 to 29 per cent in 2005 (though in India news
audience has grown).
With
the growing commercialisation of television news, the
need to make it entertaining has therefore become a
priority for broadcasters. They borrow and adapt ideas
from entertainment and adopt an informal style with
an emphasis on personalities, storytelling and spectacle.
This
has been reinforced by the take-over of news networks by huge media corporations
whose primary interest is in the entertainment business: Viacom-Paramount (CBS
News); Disney (ABC News); AOL-Time-Warner (CNN) and News Corporation (Fox News/Sky
News and Star News Asia). This shift in ownership is reflected in the type of
stories - about celebrities from the world of entertainment, for example - that
get prominence on news, thus strengthening corporate synergies.
In
the process, symbiotic relationships between the news and new forms of current
affairs and factual entertainment genres, such as reality TV have developed, blurring
the boundaries between news, documentary and entertainment. Such hybrid programming
feeds into and benefits from the 24/7 news cycle: providing a feast of visually
arresting, emotionally charged infotainment which sustains ratings and keeps production
costs low. The growing global popularity of such infotainment-driven programming
indicates the success of this formula.
Infotainment
- a term that emerged in the late 1980s to become a
buzzword - refers to an explicit genre-mix of information
and entertainment in news and current affairs
programming. This new news cannibalises visual forms
and styles borrowed from TV commercials and a MTV-style
visual aesthetics, including fast-paced action, in a
post-modern studio, computer-animated logos, eye-catching
visuals and rhetorical headlines from an, often glamorous,
anchor person. This style of presentation, with its
origins in the ratings-driven commercial television
news culture of the US, is becoming increasingly global,
as news channels attempt to reach more viewers and keep
their target audiences from switching over.
|
As
Bollywood stars start bidding for cricketers,
the 'Bollywoodisation' of news is likely to continue
_____****_____
|
As
I demonstrate in my new book News as Entertainment:
The Rise of Global Infotainment, such type of journalism
has been very successful: in Italy, infotainment-driven
private television catapulted Silvio Berlusconi from
a businessman to the office of the Prime Minister. A
study of journalism in post-Soviet Russia found that
the media were paying huge attention to the entertainment
genre, while in the Chinese news world, Phoenix
channel regularly runs such soft news programmes as
Easy Time, Easy News.
In
the worlds largest democracy, what I have described
as the three Cs cinema, crime and cricket
encapsulate most of the content on television
news. Here global influences are important: As in many
other countries, the greatest contributor to infotainment
in India has been Rupert Murdoch, whose pan-Asian network
Star, launched in 1991, pioneered satellite television
in Asia, transforming TV news and entertainment. Murdoch
was responsible, among other things, for introducing
the first music channel in India (Channel V); the first
24/7 news network (Star News) and the first adaptation
of an international game show (Who Wants to be a
Millionaire).
Murdoch
was also the first transnational operator to recognise
the selling power of Bollywood, its glamour and glitz.
The obsession of almost all news channels with Bollywood-centred
celebrity culture today dominates coverage. Crime is
big too: as the ratings battle has intensified, news
networks have moved towards reporting sensational stories,
which are becoming progressively gruesome: murder, gore
and rape are recurring themes. The paradox is stark:
although crime coverage has spiralled, especially on
more populist Hindi channels, in the real India the
crime rate has in fact fallen dramatically in the last
decade.
A
third obsession is to be seen in the coverage of cricket:
cricket-related stories appear almost daily on all networks
and not just on sports news. And as Bollywood
stars start bidding for cricketers, the 'Bollywoodisation'
of news is likely to continue.
These
three Cs are indicative of a television news culture that is increasingly becoming
hostage to infotainment. The lack of coverage of rural India, of regular suicides
by peasants (more than 170,000, in the last 15 years, according to government
figures), and the negligible reporting of health and hygiene, educational and
employment equality (India has the worlds largest population of child labour
at the same time as having vast pool of unemployed young people), demonstrates
that such stories do not translate into ratings for urban, Westernized viewers
and are displaced by the diversion of infotainment. The
lack of concern among television news networks for Indias majority population
is ironic in a country that was the first in the world to use satellite television
for educational and developmental purposes, through its 1975 SITE (Satellite Instructional
Television Experiment) programme. The interest in broader questions of global
equality and social justice appear to have been replaced among many journalists
by an admiration for charismatic and smooth-talking CEOs and American or Americanized
celebrities. Should
we worry about this perceived dilution and debasing of news? In the early 1980s,
years before media globalization and rampant commercialization of the airwaves,
Neil Postman, in his influential book Amusing Ourselves to Death, argued that
television militated against deeper knowledge and understanding since it promoted
incoherence and triviality, and spoke in only one persistent voice
the voice of entertainment. A
quarter century later, looking at the Bollywoodization of news in India, Postmans
words ring truer than ever. (Daya
Kishan Thussu is Professor of International Communication at the University of
Westminster in London. His latest book is News as Entertainment: The Rise of Global
Infotainment - the first book-length study of this phenomenon, published by Sage.) |