|
Bollywood
is becoming a game for the big boys. New upstarts like Sahara and UTV are pumping
in money behind production and marketing to create mega commercial hits like No
Entry and Rang De Basanti while Anil Ambani's
Adlabs Films is planning to have a high-point presence in all the segments of
film business. The
movie business landscape, in fact, is changing fast. Indiantelevision.com
takes a look at how the industry is shaping up to script a new tale.
MORE BANKS LEND, BUT STILL CAUTIOUS...
IDBI
Bank is the leader in the pack, having late last year decided to double its exposure
limit to Rs 2 billion. No wonder the big daddy of film financing believes it has
found the right formula for lending to the industry. It has sanctioned Rs 1.8
billion while disbursals stand at Rs 850-900 million towards movie projects. Says
IDBI deputy managing director Jitender Balakrishnan, "It has proved to be
a successful product for us, giving us returns which match other industry sectors.
This is why the IDBI board took the decision to increase the upper limit to Rs
2 billion." Other
banks like UTI have entered the fray, but the lending is still extended to select
production houses and the norms are strictly observed. IDBI, for instance, funds
only corporates who have a track record of three years and insists on a 1:1 debt
equity ratio. "We don't deviate from these lending norms. Besides, the size
of the loan can't be less than Rs 40 million and anything above Rs 200 million
will have to be backed by a completion guarantee," says Balakrishnan.
Banks
rely on an advisory committee drawn from the film industry itself to examine the
merit of each project proposal. The approval of the project, however, is done
by an internal team after weighing several considerations including revenue earning
potential of the movie. "It is just over four years since banks have started
film financing. The process is evolving and as the confidence grows, banks will
keep changing the lending norms," says Balakrishnan. Banks
believe there is a need at this stage to stand vigil in a sector that has chronic
ups and downs. They have gone slow on expanding their film finance portfolio.
Though film producers are required to repay the debt before the release of a movie,
holding IPR rights may not be a safety net for loan recoveries. Take Bank of India
which has financed just Rs 250 million for five movies over a four year period.
While two movies under its portfolio have been successful, one has just about
managed to recover costs. "Another project is stuck over disputes
and the movie is yet to be released. We have also financed a fresh project which
is coming up for release. Organised finance is coming, but the pace is very slow.
We have nominated just one branch in Andheri which does film financing. Because
of its risky nature, we have an upper ceiling of Rs 50 million per movie,"
says Bank of India general manager (credit) S Sampath. An
early lender into the film business, Bank of Baroda is extremely cautious about
providing debt to the film sector. "Our experience has not been good so far,"
says a senior official of the bank. That
has not stopped some banks from experimenting in the glamour industry. Export-Import
Bank of India (Exim) has recently agreed to lend $7 million to Crest Animation
Studios in what would be its first funding for an animation film project. Starting
to lend to the film sector since April 2004, the bank has financed Rs 580 million
for nine movies so far. This includes Rs 400 million to noted filmmaker Yash Chopra
for movies like Veer Zaara, Hum Tum, Bunty Aur Babli and Dum. It
has also lent Rs 100 million for Farhan Akhtar's Don and Rs 80 million
for Mangal Pandey - The Rising. "We
feel the entertainment sector will become big business. We decided to start with
the film industry. But we pick and choose projects very carefully. Unlike the
telecom and other sectors, it is far riskier than what we have been used to funding.
We have been lending only to established names," says Exim Bank general manager
Mathew John. Organised
finance is available at much lower interest rates, but is not accessible to fresh
filmmakers. Private financiers charge as high as three per cent on a monthly basis.
"Almost all banks are now open to financing films based on the historical
track record and balance sheet of the producer, in addition to the security of
the film negative. Interest rates range between 9-13 per cent. There are instances
of institutions like Exim Bank offering foreign exchange loans against overseas
rights at cheaper rates," says UTV Software Communications COO Ronald D'Mello.
Exim Bank, which has been funding Hindi movie projects that have a potential
to earn foreign currency revenues in the overseas market, offers floating interest
rates.
So
what do banks need? "This industry will have to corporatise more. Besides,
there has to be a complete cheque mode of payment so that the accounting is transparent.
An established track record is also important," says Sampath. The
lesson in this? If you are making your maiden movie, the chase to the bank for
arranging finance may turn futile. Banks are willing to lend to corporate-driven
organisations, provided the norms are in place. Such companies can leverage on
their equity and internal accruals to raise debt as a mix of funding for movies.
"Of
the 117 Hindi movies produced last year, the fund requirement would have been
around Rs 7 billion. Only 10 per cent of this must have come from organised finance,"
says a trade analyst. What,
though, is not flowing in is equity into film financing from venture capitalists
(VCs) or high net worth individuals. Despite attempts at setting up Film Funds,
no progress has been made. Explains D'Mello, "There are no tax or other regulatory
incentives to attract subscribers to the Fund. Also, there is a high risk perception
of Bollywood movies coupled with non existence of completion bonding which works
well overseas." As
film production becomes more expensive, innovative forms of financing have to
creep in to make it available to a broad section of filmmakers. One way is to
ensure a transparent online accounting system on the exhibition side and make
that cash flow accessible to banks and institutional funding agencies. "By
securitising the cash flows from the theatres into the funding agencies, risks
can be made more acceptable. Multiplexes have a role to play in this and banks
can take a position on the movie's future earning potential," says Mukta
Arts CEO Ravi Gupta.
A
more radical suggestion is to allow the formation of limited liability companies.
"Such companies can be formed for individual projects. Foriegn and high net
worth investors can come in for a movie and after the completion of its commercial
exploitation, the company can be allowed to close down. This is a practice in
the western countries. But the government will have to allow this format in India,"
says Gupta.
INDUSTRY GETS MORE CORPORATISED, BUT DISTRIBUTION STILL THE IRRITANT The
rules of the filmed entertainment business are changing. The production process
is getting more corporatised, multiplexes are bringing in a breath of fresh air
on the exhibition front, and investors are watching with keen interest which way
the fortunes are going to swing. The
production cycle is getting shorter for at least the organised players. Mukta
Arts, for instance, took six months to produce Shaadi Se Pehle. The duration
of completing a movie, though, varies from project-to-project and also depends
on the production house. But, as Gupta says, the average time spent on the floor
has generally shrunk. The
industry, once used to waste and extravagance, is realising the value of streamlining
operations. Focus on good stories, well-oiled machineries, planned executive and
effective marketing campaigns are going to be crucial in driving down costs and
getting mainstream hits. Says D'Mello, "People are not working on broken
schedules. This has brought down time and cost escalations." Fragmenting
and targeting niche audiences is possible today with the number of multiplexes
which have sprung up across the country. Multiplexes are also securing a better
revenue flow across the distribution value chain. Says E-City Ventures CEO Atul
Goel, "The revenue leakage on the distribution front is still an issue. But
there is an improvement because of the multiplexes which have brought about transparency." Digital
delivery of movies will also drive change. But it is still at a nascent stage
and is taking place at the low-cost end. "The industry has around 250 digital
exhibition theatres across the country. We will have to push it up to 2,000 to
3,000 theatres," says Gupta. Mukta Arts has a joint venture with Adlabs for
the digital delivery business. Multiplex
operators are fast ramping up. Says Goel, "There are around 100 multiplexes
in the country. But with the players lining up major expansion plans, this is
expected to grow to 250 multiplexes within two years. We are scaling up from four
properties and 17 screens to a total of 35 multiplexes and 150 screens by early
2008." Adlabs
plans to invest Rs 2 billion over three years towards multiplexes, adding 100
new screens by the end of FY 08 to take the total to 135 screens. Even on the
production side, it aims to produce over 10 films in a year from FY 06 onwards.
"We will have to run faster and higher. We have signed up Ram Gopal Varma,
Ramesh Sippy, Prakash Jha and Vipul Shah," says Adlabs Films chairman and
managing director Manmohan Shetty. Such
ramp ups across the top production houses like Yash Chopra, Mukta Arts and Sahara
will be a challenge and will depend upon how much the market can absorb. Though
multiplexes are growing, it remains to be seen how much additional supply they
can take in. "The exhibition side is getting valued already. On
the production side, as more companies scale up and start demonstrating earnings,
the scepticism will disappear and investors will find it a more acceptable model,"
Says Enam Financial Consultants vice president Salil Pitale.
STRIVING
FOR VERTICAL INTEGRATION MODELS A
more varied business model is taking shape as corporate houses strive for size
and vertical integration. Adlabs, Sahara, UTV and E-City originate from different
backgrounds and are creating empires that will synergise with their other ventures. Ambani
is building an entertainment powerhouse that will sprawl over his telecom venture.
Having paid Rs 3.6 billion for a 51 per cent stake in Adlabs, he quickly raised
$100 million through an offering of foreign currency convertible bonds (FCCBs).
Flushed with funds, Adlabs will scale up movie and radio operations
with a heavy presence in exhibition, production, film processing and distribution
segments. His Reliance Infocomm will link up threatres and deliver content through
its fibre optic backbone. His foray into home video segment will help provide
content for Reliance Infocomm's triple play service which Ambani plans to launch
by the end of this year. The direct-to-home (DTH) service will also gain content
from Adlabs. "In
this type of a model, it is viable to create an integrated platform, scale up
and absorb all the risks from the vagaries of film business. Ambani is best poised
to take the film industry forward, but has to get the content right," says
an analyst. Subroto
Roy, on the other hand, grew up a broadcast business and then spread his fabric
over Bollywood. His Sahara motion pictures division has churned out several hits
and can play a big role in pushing the flagging general entertainment channel
forward. He has also launched a Hindi movie channel and, along with news, is hoping
to have enough firepower to migrate from free-to-air to pay TV business. An
outsider in film production, Roy has turned out to be one of the leading producers
with a pipeline of 40 movies. Sahara's model of tying up with production house
K Sera Sera, which had a long term deal with Ram Gopal Varma, for 10 movies proved
fruitful. The company also worked out multiple-movie deals with Boney Kapoor and
Madhur Bhandarkar. "We are making 20 movies this year. We will be totally
funding these movies. We are also into film distribution business," says
Sahara One Media and Entertainment Ltd CEO Shantonu Aditya. UTV,
which started as primarily a TV content production house, has marched into movies
and broadcast areas to boast of being an integrated media company. The company
has produced seven movies over the last 30 months and more are on various stages
of production now. "We do not consider film business more risky compared
to other media businesses. Selecting the right project after due evaluation and
research, having a slate of film projects of varying content profiles, managing
cost and time schedules well and effective and timely exploitation of revenue
potential are the key to successfully managing the film business," says D'Mello.
UTV was commissioned by Star to produce movies for them. "Broadcasters
of late are looking at acquiring a slate of movies from producers for television
exploitation compared to film acquisition earlier. Apart from assuring future
content, this also helps broadcasters to amortoise the cost over multiple films,"
says D'Mello. Television
content companies like Balaji Telefilms have also made cautious steps into film
production. Their aim: to drive topline growth. Movie companies like K Sera Sera
are also going the reverse way by foraying into TV content business. Pure
film companies are aiming to size up their business. Yash Raj Films has a strong
overseas distribution arm and has set up a hi-tech studio to grab outsourcing
work from Hollywood. Others like PNC have attracted equity financing, but are
trying to grapple with ways to grow the business. Mukta Arts has opened an academy
to train professionals and have a constant supply of talent to feed the industry.
Exhibition
companies are getting into the distribution business. "Exhibition margins
range between 15-20 per cent. It makes business sense for us to be in distribution,
which has margins of 30 per cent, as well. We have entered Gujarat territory as
we have taken 22 theatres on hire there. But one has to progress selectively into
territories," says Goel. Distribution
companies are also finding the climate conducive for movie production. Sony Pictures
Releasing of India, which had obtained FIPB (foreign investment promotion board)
approval for film production, had stayed out of it for years. But recently the
company announced a joint venture with Sanjay Leela Bhansali for production of
Hindi movie Saawariya (Beloved). "We are globally into film production.
We think the time is also right as corporatisation has led to a more organised
production process," says Sony Pictures Releasing of India managing director
Uday Singh.
For
any chance of organised funding to get better, efficiencies have to grow across
the value chain. Aligning with directors for multiple films can draw and lock
in talent while co-productions can raise the production values. On the positive
side, the dependence on domestic theatrical collections has reduced while international
territories are yielding better cash returns. The revenue mix for good
movies is more widely spread today. While domestic box office accounts for 50-55
per cent (earlier 70 per cent) of total revenues, satellite TV rights make up
20 per cent and overseas territories 10-15 per cent. The home video segment is
also growing, accounting for 10 per cent revenues. In the wide basket, it is only
the music rights which have sunk over the years and seen very little rise.
New media exploitation options like mobile and internet also offer promissing
revenue potential for film content. The
best thing to happen is the emergence of a diverse range of players who are aggressively
getting into the film business for strategically different reasons. This is good
for the health of the film industry and will fuel its future growth. |