He's the man Amitabh Bachchan speaks exclusively to, and the one who has the ear of many veteran television personalities. Subhash K Jha, whose acerbic commentary on Bollywood has enthralled readers for years, will now feature a regular column on indiantelevision.com. Jha will cast his critical eye on the small screen, appreciating the good, criticising the bad and castigating the ugly... Stay tuned for a regular review of programming that peppers the small screen in India:
The art of giving
(Posted on 4 March 2005)

Two additions to non-fiction programming on Indian television haven't made a dent to the dreadfully dull way we look at the home-viewing medium these days.

Sony's Batliwala House No 43 is a takeoff on the British chatcom show The Kumars at No. 42. Unlike the other series this one neither rocks nor rolls. It just growls with a guttural inanity.

First of all, we have Mumbai's theatre actors pitching in to resemble the original cast of kookie British Indians who played the Kumar family. I'm afraid the Batliwalas look like poor copies, in spite of Delnaaz Paul and other comic virtuosos pulling out all steps. The grandma's innocuous lechery for the male guests in the original looks like a case of constipated dementia in the Indian context.

As for the guests, we had the two Indian Idol finalists Amit Sana and Abhijeet Sawant in the first episode. The poor singers tried hard to look bemused and fascinated by the gallery of eccentrics who interviewed them. But the humour never flew above the level of cuckoo-land. Irreverence about singing icons like Lata Mangeshkar is all very fine. But you really can't make a fashion statement out of stupidity. Which is what Batliwala does.

****

The comic talent that goes to waste in Batliwala is put to serviceable satirical use in Sahara One's sitcom Aao Bahen Chugli Karen where a group of women in an apartment block spend all their time cooking up ways of bitching backbiting and hurting one another.

It's fatuously fun to watch competent actresses like Himani Shivpuri, Loveleen Mishra, Sejal Shah and Shruti Ulfat pull out all stops to do what can be loosely termed a burlesque version of Zee's Kittie Party.

Last week's episode where the Bihari protagonist (Loveleen Mishra) tries to get her own back on her neighbour through a cheesy corporator was a samosa-styled spice-and-stuffing appetizer, all done with scant regard for the way women are portrayed in the average serial.

****

Advertisement

Irreverence comes as a breath of fresh air at a time when television is bending backwards to deify the Indian housewife. Tusli and Parvati (who by the way are coming together on Koffee With Karan very soon) continue to be super-icons. Prerna on Kasauti Zindagi Kay ran into her old flame Anurag while holidaying with her husband Mr Bajaj. As luck (and the creatively severely restricted scriptwriter) would have it, both the men landed up in the same hotel room, as Prerna was caught in- between the male gaze and red fluttering curtain (in-sync with her unbelievable false eyelashes).

In fact coincidences have become a way of life on Kasauti. Anurag ran into his estranged daughter Sneha in a peculiar situation. He accused the innocent girl of shoplifting, got her slapped around at the police station and then bit his tongue when he realized his mistake.

Our Anurag is like one of those incredibly daft game-show hosts who insist on cracking sexist/scatological jokes because they know the contestants can't afford to squirm, let alone object. They are supposed to have fun at any cost, you see.

****

Advertisement

Mandira Bedi who loves to play games, be it cricket or any other, now hosts a game show on Sahara every evening. I haven't really been able to figure out what this game show entails, except that strange people from all over the country are supposed to phone in and answer some strange questions.

On Thursday there was a mother and daughter from a far-off place (can't recollect the name but according to the squealing anchor, the milk-cake there is to die for) where asked to name the film for which Bhanu Athaiya got an Oscar.

"Er, what's the prize?" the daughter asked.

"A trip to Manali," chirped Bedi.

"We don't want to go to Manali! Can we have something else?" Asked the anxious contestant.

Manali it was….and the answer? "Mother India!" Came the girl.

I guess one way to avoid a reluctant trip is to give out wrong information.

****

While all the women on TV, from Pooja on Life Ho To Aisi to Mandira Bedi on Sahara's game show adhere to the status quo, I was thrilled to bits to see a thoroughly capricious woman on Karan Johar's show.

Notch up a winner with Sushmita Sen who was quite simply, irresistible on Koffee with Karan. Dressed in a sari she careened from coquettish confidence to fey iconoclasm fascinating both the men on the show. Sanjay Dutt was as usual quiet and thoroughly grateful and embarrassed when a string of stunningly beautiful women from Kareena Kapoor to Mallika Sherawat paraded on the video-monitor to say what they thought of Mr Dutt. (Censored version, I'm sure). We also had the guys saying the same about Ms Sen.

Some of the dialogues on the show were hilarious. Karan to Dutt, "What's your art of living?"

"It's the art of giving," says Sanjay Dutt.

"Could you EXPAND on that?"

This was followed by loud chortles by Sen. …Fun all the way, and quite a between-the-lines experience worthy of being seen twice over to be fully understood.

I must say Ms Sen and Mr Dutt made a terrific couple. Will someone please cast them together pronto?

****

The Filmfare awards on Sony threw forward many memorable moments. Dev Anand was incredulous while announcing the 'Best Villain'.

"Where's your trophy?!" the evergreen Anand wondered, clutching on to his own 'The Golden Glory Viewers' Choice Award' (an honour that he shared with Rekha) when Priyanka Chopra waltzed seductively up to the stage.

Alas Priyanka's trophy was nowhere to be seen. She handled the delay with grace. "Aisa hota hai," she laughed when I spoke to her after the show. "It's all part of such an event. And it's up to the winners to behave like winners in spite of glitches."

Unfortunately the evening's compere Saif Ali Khan (a disaster without his fellow-anchor of two years Shah Rukh Khan) showed no grace when he was called on stage by Dev Saab to collect his trophy for 'Best Actor In A Comic Role' in Hum Tum.

Saif snatched Dev Saab's trophy made his pre-rehearsed speech about family values and filial feelings (a guilt trip, traceable to his recent marital breakup).

Other major goof-ups included the event's new eleventh-hour sponsor asking the winner for art direction (Sabu Cyril) if he paints on canvas or is he associated with cinema. And when Saif asked Mr Swarup to say a few words, the sponsor wondered if he was summoned to speak or give an award.

A lack of co-ordination between the anchors and the celebrities couldn't take away from the nostalgia glamour and star appeal of the evening. Rani Mukherjee (once again, the recipient of two awards for Hum Tum and Yuva), Priyanka Chopra and Sonu Nigam paid elaborate song-and-dance tributes to the stars and music over the decades.

Once again the Bachchans -Amitabh and Abhishek- and Shah Rukh Khan dazzled at the Filmfare awards. Once again they proved they have no peers. When Abhishek won the award for best supporting actor in Yuva it took him quite a while to reach the stage. The volume of congratulations from friends (including Amar Singh and Anil Ambani) and fans proved how popular the junior Bachchan has become in the last one year.

Abhishek dragged his father on stage and gave his award to his father saying, "As I believe there can be no actor better than my father this award belongs to him." The senior Bachchan promptly returned the recognition saying it's a tradition to give the son whatever the father earns in life.

Great showmanship, topped by Shah Rukh Khan's performance of cinematic romance over the years, from Rajesh Khanna singing Roop tera mastana to Sharmila Tagore in Aradhana to , ahem ahem, Shah Rukh singing Ladki badi anjani to Kajol in Kuch Kuch Hota Hai… Shah Rukh enacted all of them with habitual élan. What's more all the original screen queens , from Vyjanthimala and Sharmila Tagore to Zeenat Aman, Jaya Prada and Rekha, to Rani Mukherjee and Preity Zinta joined Shah Rukh for this astonishing piece of on-stage virtuosity….truly the highlight of the evening.

Khan was rewarded with two awards both richly deserved. The best actor award went to Khan for Swades. When he received Filmfare's Power Award Khan said real power was Amitabh Bachchan's performance in Sanjay Leela Bhansali's Black.

(The views expressed here are those of the author and indiantelevision.com need not necessarily subscribe to the same)

picture courtesy: www.rediff.com, www.planetbollywood.com
Mandira's pic by VICKY AHUJA
Email this page |Contact Us | Feedback | About Indiantelevision | Disclaimer

© 2001- 2005 Indian Television Dot Com Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.