He's the man Amitabh Bachchan speaks exclusively to, and the one who has the ear of many veteran television personalities. Subhash K Jha, whose acerbic commentary on Bollywood has enthralled readers for years, now features a regular column on indiantelevision.com. Jha casts his critical eye on the small screen, appreciating the good, criticising the bad and castigating the ugly...
Paparazzi journalism
(Posted on 18 December 2004)

Butt seriously! Even while the issue of Kareena Kapoor’s public display of affection raged across the media, Fardeen Khan came on Karan Johar’s show to comment on her “cute heart-shaped butt” for the second time in three weeks.

To hear an actor objectify his colleague in this manner just to raise a few cute moments during a talk show seems like a case of excessive self-projection without regard for the other person’s feelings.

Can we imagine Dilip Kumar talking in public about Madhubala “cute heart-shaped butt.” Or for that matter Shah Rukh Khan commenting on Kajol’s physical assets? The brash brigade threatens to bash every definition of decency to a pulp-age, profession and stature no bar.

****

On Wednesday night on NDTV, I was shocked to hear senior journalist Anil Dharker’s ‘cute’ comments on the Kareena-Shahid controversy. When asked to comment on the ethics of paparazzi journalism, Dharker launched a monologue on what bad kissers Shahid and Kareena are, and that the pair should employ the services of a ‘kissing coach’, etc.

Hello hello??? Isn’t this a bit like taking a discussion on rape into areas of aesthetics? I believe responsible mediapersons who are asked to comment on socio-political issues have no right to be frivolous. The quality is more suited to stand-up comedians. We don’t have too many of those around any more. They are all trying to host talk shows now.

****

The most compassionate mob that I’ve ever seen has to be the one in Star Plus’ new horror serial Kaalchakra. A large group of people with blow-torches in hand descended on the village heveli. They wanted to murder the twin infant daughters because one of them was supposedly evil (a bit like talking about the art of kissing on a discussion on violation of privacy). The baby’s aunt stormed inside, brought out the babies and bellowed, “Kill them if you think they’re the root cause of your problems.”

The blow torches fell out of the mobs’ hands like over-ripe mangoes. Instant reformation. It’s hard to believe Kaalchakra comes from Shakti Samanta who once gave us fabulous feature films like Aradhana and Amar Prem.

****

Television tends to shrink the size of the maker’s creativity. I am still hopeful about the quality of performances being seen in some of the fiction programmes. Mandira Bedi was far more engaging as a woman coming to terms with tragedy in Star One’s telefilm Bali this weekened than she is as a cricket commentator. The hand-held camera movements together with a unhurried evasive pace added to the theme of imminent disintegration.

Advertisement

The other telefilm on Sahara One was Rishta Dilon Ka. It featured Ankur Mohit (who till recently was teacherji on Star’s flop Jeet) as a young man in love with a much older woman (Irawati Harshe). Just one hitch. The lady’s daughter has a serious crush on the man Mom wants to marry.

The presentation never took itself seriously. I came across many portions in the narration that were sunshiny. When the woman wants to sacrifice love and happiness for her daughter the man says, “You’re designing your daughter’s life. Don’t use me as a prop.”

That’s perhaps the best line I’ve heard on television recently. The film faintly recalled Guru Dutt’s Baharen Phir Bhi Aayengi where both the sisters Mala Sinha and Tanuja loved the same man Dharmendra.

These weekend telefilms are giving filmmakers a chance to grow. Not much of that is happening on the large screen.

Advertisement

 

Zee has an ace up its sleeve. They’ve started a Friday-night telecast of Shah Rukh Khan-Preity Zinta-Rani Mukherjee-Priyanka Chopra "Temptations" world concerts from last week. This week I loved all the behind-the-scenes banter among the stars, the rehearsals, arrangements, etc. We also got to see Priyanka singing live on stage.

Coincidentally I also caught her father singing on the same channel in Zee’s Sa Re Ga Ma Pa. The outstanding music contest is now a daily occurrence on Zee. The capsules are so deftly done that we never feel we’re watching old material. Besides, I any day prefer to see old segments of Sa Re GA Ma than new episodes of Sahara’s Parchaiyaan.

This long-winded soap about the Man (Milind Gunaji), wife (Reena Wadhwa) and the psychotic other woman (Achint Kaur) was earlier shown on another channel. Now after the initial episodes the story is being carried forward on Sahara… with the main plot duly diluted by jumbled distractions, like the hero’s pregnant sister who’s rejected by the man she loves.

Now check out the way the above situation was filmed. The man rudely told the girl to get lost since he has nothing to do with her. The tearful girl bravely announced she was pregnant with his child.

“Nope… It’s not my child… don’t want it… leave!” the cad pursed his lips, folded his arms and looked like he wanted to catch the night’s episode of Indian Idols rather than discuss his procreative activities. His mother (herself impatient to see Tulsi and her truant son at loggerheads) seconded her dear son’s motion.

Such scenes are so stale and so badly written you wonder what the writer was doing… besides watching third-rate big-screen potboilers.

Shouldn’t Indian television show a growth beyond the clichés of Hindi cinema?

****

Both Esha Deol and Kareena Kapoor confirmed on Koffee With Karan that they were buddies of Zayed Khan and Fardeen Khan, respectively. No affair. Esha also implored Zayed to be his natural self and not put on an accent.

Zayed still spoke in an indecipherable accent and misused words, like “retrospect” when he meant “respect”

Dude with an attitude… and a vocabulary problem.

(The views expressed here are those of the author and indiantelevision.com need not necessarily subscribe to the same)

Email this page |Contact Us | Feedback | About Indiantelevision | Disclaimer

© 2001- 2005 Indian Television Dot Com Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.