TV News gathering: Responsibility issues


The horrific communal violence in Gujarat and the images they generated had an overarching influence on the course of the debate during the session "TV News Gathering" held on the concluding day of Frames 2002 .

The core issue was whether the news channels should have been more circumspect in their presentation of the India's worst communal violence in over a decade.

Rajat Sharma, director, Independent News Services (of Aaj Ki Baat fame), chaired the session. Some of the points addressed included the responsibility of the electronic media towards its viewers; should the issues be related to the masses or only to people in the news studio; and can the channels be more responsible to viewers who spend time and money watching the news.

The discussion was opened by Sharma, himself, who began with the example of the 11 September terror attacks on New York's World Trade Centre. Sharma said most viewers switched to foreign channels, and saw vivid images of rescue operations but no bloodshed and pain. In India though, during the Gujarat earthquake, there were no positive images of rescue work in progress.

During the riots, news channels showed Muslim houses attacked and vice-versa. Did this all instigate people? These were some of the points that Sharma addressed.

Uday Shankar, chief executive producer, Aaj Tak, was willing to accept that mistakes had been made. But he said that what are considered mistakes by one channel might not be so with others. While speaking on the responsibility of the channels, and citing the example of the Gujarat riots, he said that while Aaj Tak did not identify any communities, people wanted to know who died and because of whom.

Shankar furthur defended the channels that did identify the communities during the riots. He felt that since everything in India is determined by religion, there is no harm in channels mentioning the same. Since people like to be where news is happening, even though they may not be able to witness it in person, they expect channels to bring it to them. But accuracy in reporting is essential, Shankar said.

Shankar said one man's responsibility is another man's censorship and vice versa. Also, today channels are vying to deliver news first and deliver it effectively. The demand of feeding information 24 hours a day is so huge that it often dictates what news is given. But it is not irresponsible handling.

Raminder Singh, who is with In Cable, said the role of a journalist has changed today. He felt that the danger of overdoing something on TV was far greater than the print media. This is because the print media appeals to one's rationale, and TV generally excites an emotion. Thus the question of responsibility. The responsibility lies with the senior people in TV. He also said that there was no need to show gory pictures constantly on television. Today, since there are so many young reporters, who are also inexperienced, they don't know how to ask a question, and this can be dangerous.

Anuradha Prasad, who started with PTI and now runs BAG films, felt that TV news gathering today is going through a catharsis. With the advent of satellite channels, good things have happened, i.e. they are linked everywhere, there are different perspectives, and there's food for thought, Prasad said. She raised a cautionary note however, while pointing out that the news for the electronic media has also become event related. There are no developmental, rural stories. All the news is market driven, she felt that there should be a proper presentation of news.

The last speaker was Rajiv Shukla, former journalist, now member of parliament. Shukla was of the opinion that communal riots should not be covered as it could lead to violence in other parts of the country. Shukla opined that communal violence on TV should be treated in the same manner as in the print media. At the same time, if the government is not doing anything, that too should be covered, Shukla said. He did admit though that all politicians are uncomfortable with media coverage. Shukla lamented the dearth of developmental coverage. The criminalisation of politicians is covered, but the majority of them who have no criminal record is not covered.

Latest Reads

Casbaa becomes the Asia Video Industry Association

At an Extraordinary General Meeting of members today, Casbaa overwhelmingly approved the adoption of a new constitution and new name.

Specials Event Coverage Occasions
Wizcraft’s 4th broadway styled bollywood musical stage show comes to kingdom of dream

After a glorious run in Mumbai with over 100 shows, Balle Balle - The Biggest and Craziest Indian Wedding Musical theatrical show, is all set to woo audiences in Delhi NCR.

Specials Event Coverage Occasions
ConnecTechAsia Successful in Bridging the Digital Divide for Governments, Cities and Enterprises with Showcase of Latest Tech and Trends

ConnecTechAsia, the inaugural mega technology event comprising BroadcastAsia, CommunicAsia and the new NXTAsia wrapped up last week after an exciting three days of exhibitions and a summit covering the latest innovations in cloud, blockchain, AI, VR/AR, IoT, robotics, 5G, IP broadcasting, OTT and...

Specials Event Coverage Occasions
Lessons Learned With Bitcoin

Blockchain technology is one of the newest buzzwords in business. It is hardly surprising considering that the tech is having such an impact over so many different industries.

Specials Promonet feature
The company is collaborating with Lakme Fashion Week and designer Anita Dongre

World Environment Day - 2018 is going to be special as India is hosting global celebrations of the event today. To commemorate the occasion, Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL) has launched a special T-shirt, branded ?The Earth Tee? and designed by renowned fashion designer Anita Dongre, under its unique...

Specials Event Coverage Occasions
Promaxbda India 2018 announces Puja Vohra and Glenn Urquhart as their masterclass speakers

PromaxBDA India has announced its first 2 Masterclass speakers for the 15th edition of its annual conference and awards property in India, which will take place on 23rd May 2018. Speaking at the Masterclass are truTV?s Puja Vohra and creative mastermind Glenn Urquhart.

Specials Event Coverage Occasions
ABBY Awards 2018 shortlists announced

The coveted ABBY Awards that recognizes and rewards excellence across Advertising, Marketing and Media has now announced that the shortlists for the 2018 edition have started being posted, by category.

Specials Event Coverage Occasions
Ficci Frames and market concludes on grand note

The FICCI Frames and the newly launched content market as part of FICCI Frames 2018 concluded on a grand note.

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames
Screen Density: Lessons from the world & Exploring new business models

n Day 2 of FICCI FRAMES happening in Mumbai, there was a session on Screen Density in India attended by some eminent panelists consisting of Mr. William Feng, VP, Greater China, MPA, Kurt Rieder, Head-Theatrical Asia, 20th Century Fox, Kapil Agarwal, Joint MD, UFO, Kamal Gianchandani, Chief of...

Specials Event Coverage Ficci Frames

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories