Too much symbiosis makes TV a dull watch
(Posted on 15 June 2005)

Of late there's a lot of cross-pollination going on… Television seems to get progressively more symbiotic, especially on Sony Entertainment.

Rajeshwari, who plays the spirited social activist in Rihhaee, showed up on the rapidly declining Jassi Jaisi Koi Nahin as a fiery protestor charging Armaan (Apurva Agnihotri) with sexual harassment.

Whatever happened to Good Old Jassi, her spectacles and her middle class demeanour? I've never come across a more wayward soap in my life. Everything in Jassi, from the cast of characters to the character of the cast has gone downhill. There was a time when one actually looked forward to seeing Jassi's angelic attempts to find space at a high-class modeling agency. Now, when she's glamorized to look like one of them the shine has gone out of the old wine.

Rihhaee, too, has slumped. From being a hard-hitting look at the crusader's conflicts, it has moved into turgid territory. Last week we even had an item song - if you please! - by one of the Indian Idol finalists Prajakta Shukre. Soon after, a model-friend was bumped off and Shukre began to get threatening calls.

How on earth does this qualify as a women's issue??? Rihhaee is among the better happenings on television in recent times. Let's keep it that way, huh?

I was appalled to see Pooja's elder sister in Sony's Ye Meri Life Hai undergo a 'see' change. The original actress has been replaced without a murmer of explanation. Of course long-running soaps are susceptible to such changes of guard. But shouldn't we be gradually introduced to the radical facial makeover instead of pretending nothing has changed?

****

Advertisement

It's sad to see the truly deserving getting swamped in all sorts of kitschy contradictions. Not too many people watched the gifted documentary filmmaker Minnie Vaid's enigmatic, enchanting, enrapturing excursion into a nature-driven community of Meghalaya. The film entitled Sacred Forests Of Meghalaya was screened on Doordarshan some time ago. Does anyone know? This is a pity, really. Green, the presiding colour in this celebration of nature, isn't translatable on national television.

I wish the satellite channels would create a slot specially for docu-films. Eminently gifted filmmakers like Minnie Vaid would get a chance to have their say.

Say what you will, but non-fiction programming gets a raw deal on the home viewing medium unless it happens to be a celebrity talk-show.

The political prattle on the news channels is getting way out of hand. We had Tonight At 10 on CNBC this week where terrorism was being discussed as an "emotive issue" (whatever that means). But hello? The same discussion was shown twice over a period of half an hour!

We realize intellectual discussions aren't quite the common man's domain. But surely we need to go easy on driving in the point.

The incessant hammering of the Salman Khan tapes got my goat. Surely we need to exercise more self-control in matters that have to do with paparazzi-styled scandals. One Hindi news channel - desperately trying to consolidate its position - sent out SMS messages to all and sundry to 'hear' the Salman tapes on screen.

One thought audio kicks were for radio only. Besides, the voice on the soundtrack was so blurred (or was it slurred?) we couldn't make out what it was saying. So why go into it in the first place?

****

Advertisement

Lately, the talent-scouting shows are becoming the hottest kicks in town. And never mind if most of them follow the bully-the-wannabe role-model from the West. Perhaps realizing how tough the going gets for the contestants, principal Ila Arun in Fame Gurukul sat down a contestant and wept with him as he spoke about his tough fatherless childhood. This get-to-know-the-aspirant approach is commendable, as long as it doesn't become an exercise in self indulgence.

The closing episode of Zee's Closeup Antakshari was quite the most memorable event I've seen on television lately. There were tears galore… by the gallon, in fact. Host Anu Kapoor invited all his co-hostesses from Pallavi Joshi to Richa Sharma to Durga Jasraj to Rajeshwari Sawant to join him on stage to sing farewell songs.

But where-oh-where were Renuka Shahane and Shefali Shah who co-hosted Antakshari many moons ago. Admittedly, they are now mired in motherhood. But surely they could have made an effort to drop the curtain on one of the most momentous musical events on Indian television. And they were part of it.

It would be hard to forget Anu Kapoor and his achievements on Antakshari. More so now, when there's so much that's plainly mediocre.

One soap that conveys some hope is Star One's Siddhanth. This week's guest actor was Arif Zakaria. As a defence lawyer arguing on behalf of a man accused of being rsepomsible for the bad road conditions precipitating a woman's miscarriage, Zakaria was quite watchable.

But of course the counter-opinion in courtroom won. This is one of those rare shows where the the good guy gets to have an upper hand. Otherwise, it's the meanies who are having a ball. Just see the way the popular soaps are going. Meanie No.1 Mandira (Achint Kaur) has practically taken over the show from super-heroine Tulsi in Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi.

Is she neurotic or plain bananas? Who cares? As long as the TRPs sing a heartening tune.

(The views expressed here are those of the author and Indiantelevision.com need not necessarily subscribe to the same)

Click for here more Box Populi