BJP’s campaign is dull, drab and quite ordinary: Prathap Suthan

MUMBAI: The upcoming election is possibly the only one in a long history of five-year polls, where political parties are unabashedly using media to promote their prime ministerial candidates and agendas.

Thus we have both the main players – the Congress and Bhartiya Janta Party (BJP) – splurging crores of public money on election campaigns in a bid to outdo each other. Indeed, Congress was the first to jump into the fray with the tagline ‘Main nahi, Hum’ which attracted much controversy, what with the BJP claiming the punch line had originally been used by its prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi at a ‘Chintan Shivir’ in Gujarat.

However, the BJP lost no time in launching its own campaign with posters, TVCs, radio spots shouting themselves hoarse – ‘Ab ki Baar, Modi Sarkar’. The underlying message being that the common man’s woes such as inflation, lack of women’s safety etc. would be assuaged if Modi was elected for the country’s top job.

With the political climate hotting-up this election season, both campaigns are attracting their fair share of bouquets and brickbats. But we thought it would be interesting to speak to Prathap Suthan – the man who created BJP’s earlier ‘India Shining’ campaign (2004) – and get his perspective. Excerpts...

What do you have to say about the BJP slogan? Do you see it touching an emotional chord with urban and rural voters?

Barring the fact that it rhymes, I don’t think it's an inspiring slogan. It's a mere auto suggestion as to what the voter should do. It doesn't hold out any promise, mission and vision to people like us. It's dull, drab and quite ordinary.

Do you think the BJP has started too early or too late?

The BJP campaign is at least a month late. Worse still, despite the fact they have started and bits and pieces are making their way onto social media, they have been invisible. Till yesterday, I haven't seen their advertising in print or on TV. Anymore invisibility and they’d be sending out wrong signals to the electorate. But knowing them, and their almost strident confidence, I suspect their cause has been sabotaged by terrible media planning or a media boycott. I can't think of any other reason why their campaign hasn’t broken out in media yet.

Modi stands for development. Do you think the current campaign and slogan brings out this core message?

If the Modi line of thinking has to do with progress and development, the campaign should have been a reflection of that. This is a boring campaign. I see no cues of development and young and contemporary thinking in this. Congress on the other hand, despite whatever else, has better looking advertising by far.

What are your views on the AAP and the way they use publicity in their favour?

I used to like the idea of AAP. But somewhere, they’ve changed into something else that they shouldn’t be.

Considering that they don’t have the kind of media budgets that the main parties have, their public activist avatar keeps them in view. It is clever thinking because media will carry and play the de facto advertising vehicle. However, too of much of everything has a down side. You can't be a serious national party when you pick up street fighting as a brand character. At some level, it will backfire. Leadership, and genuinely inspiring stewardship of the nation is what's missing today, and AAP isn't quite playing that wedge.

One piece of advice you’d like to give to the creative and media agencies that are handling the BJP and Congress accounts?

There is no point advising advertising agencies. I believe all of us are equally qualified and experienced to handle large campaigns. We do that day in day out, and on some very challenging focussed briefs. In this case, the client takes the call and at times, dictates. The fault, if any, doesn't lie with the agencies. It has to squarely lie with the parties.

Lastly, of the two parties, which is the campaign you are betting on and why?

I think the country is loaded in favour of BJP – but they have an uninspiring campaign. One man almost looms over you. Congress, however, seems to have delivered the campaign better. It's younger looking, modern, non-traditional, and in a strange way, more inclusive.

Latest Reads
Gulzar lightens up Luminous's Diwali

MUMBAI: Luminous has launched a unique social campaign that celebrates a part of Diwali that we often forget to talk about. While most Diwali campaigns talk about spending and splurging, others talk about the display of lights and fireworks across the country. This campaign, however, goes away from...

MAM Marketing MAM
Multi-media ad campaign to popularise gold coin

A year after it was first launched, a multimedia advertising campaign is being launched to drive awareness around Diwali on the availability of the Indian gold coin by the Mines and Minerals Trading Corporation along with World Gold Council. Being launched this week, the campaign will cover...

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
Vizeum launches Binary, special advisory unit for media clients

“Media business is, in the short term, headed for a tipping point, driven by the changing consumer-media interface,” emphasises Vizeum India MD Shripad Kulkarni, who strongly believes that media companies need a definitive transformation strategy in place now.

MAM Media and Advertising Media Agencies
Havas Media bags Rs 15-cr Sujata account

MUMBAI: Havas Media Group India has bagged the integrated media duties of Sujata, an Indian Consumer Electronics & Home Appliances brand for Juicer Mixer Grinders. The incumbent on the business was Exposure Media. The account will be handled out of Gurgaon office led by Uday Mohan. The...

MAM Media and Advertising Account
TV festive ad spend to reach Rs 8000 cr; experts divided

MUMBAI: The festive months of October and November are welcome months not just for you and your family, but for most Indian brands as well. After all, they eagerly wait for this early window when consumers loosen up their purse strings and put their Diwali bonuses to good use, aka, shopping.

MAM Marketing MAM
Amagi partners with BARC India to offer monitoring of geo-targeted TV ad-campaigns

Amagi Media Labs has entered into a partnership agreement with India’s apex television viewership monitoring body BARC India to help advertisers monitor geo-targeted ad-campaigns of brands across TV channels.

MAM Media and Advertising AD Agencies
iProspect conceptualises unique digital video for ICICI two-wheeler insurance

iProspect India has conceptualized and executed a unique digital video for ICICI Lombard General Insurance in their latest campaign on two-wheeler insurance.

MAM Media and Advertising AD Agencies
eBay engages consumer with live game on FB

MUMBAI: Festive season is a busy time for Indian brands, especially the e-commerce players given the shopping spree the nation witnessed around the time. Thus it becomes important to brainstorm on new and unique ways to get the consumer’s attention; something different from the unbelievable...

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
Culture Machine & Quaker Oats aim to feed kids

As the festive mood gathers spirit in the country, Culture Machine’s digital channel Being Indian, in collaboration with Quaker Oats, have released a new campaign. Titled "Ek Muthi Sonu ke Naam", the video urges people to pause and spare a thought to the millions of children who go hungry.

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories