Nestled in controversy, brand Maggi in a soup

MUMBAI: Nestled in controversy over the presence of lead beyond permissible limits in its popular noodle brand Maggi, Nestle India has found itself in a soup. As Barkha Dutt tweeted, it could well be ?The Two Minute death of a brand #Maggi.?

What?s more, a domino effect followed immediately with the recent detection of creepy-crawlies in Nestle?s other food product Nan Pro-3.

A brand being embroiled in controversy is not something new with the likes of Cadburys and cola companies having faced similar problems in the not so distant past. About a decade ago, there was uproar over worms being found in Cadbury chocolates. On that note, the company said that most stores in India at that time didn?t have refrigerators and that had affected the product. Similarly cola brands were hit with the pesticide crisis in early 2000, which wiped off their growth for over two years.

In testing times like these for brand Maggi, the big question on everyone?s lips is? could this hullabaloo well sound the death knell for the brand, which has been around in India for decades?

Speaking to about the controversy, Kwan Entertainment & Marketing Solutions COO Indranil Das Blah strongly believed that if Maggi is being held accountable, so should the government, for the simple reason that it has been approved by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), which is a government body.

?I don?t think it?s the death of the brand in India. They?ve been around for about two decades now. A lot of brands have faced similar controversies, be it the cola brands or various food companies. Having said that, it has been approved by the FSSAI, which is why it is available in the market in the first place. Maybe a certain batch had certain excess content of lead and that is something that the judiciary should decide,? Blah said.

Harish Bijoor Consultants CEO Harish Bijoor opined, ?It?s a big shock for Maggi. The trauma is for the consumers as well because they love the brand so much.?

According to Blah, while the controversy will definitely cause immediate damage to the brand, in the long run the brand is strong enough to survive if the allegations are proven false. ?Unless there is firm evidence and a court order is passed, which is not in favour of Maggi, I don?t think it?s the death of the brand,? he added.

Pertinent to note here is that all FMCG products especially food items go through stringent manufacturing processes as well as government approvals. Blah is of the opinion that it never hurts to be extra careful and hence the Maggi fiasco should serve as a wakeup call for other FMCG giants.

While there have been discussions about the nutrition value of Maggi for years now, it hasn?t really hurt the brand and Nestle India has gone about producing it without a hitch riding on its taste quotient.

What?s more, with the involvement of big celebrities like Amitabh Bachchan and Madhuri Dixit as brand endorsers, the matter has been highlighted even more. It is a well-known fact that celebrities are soft targets whenever there is a controversy brewing.

When queried about whether it was fair to drag celebrities into the controversy, renowned photographer and founder of celebrity management firm Bling! Entertainment Solutions, Atul Kasbekar said, ?I believe it's an irrational act to go after the endorsers. While stars and their managers question the brand fits and ask relevant questions at the beginning of any relationship, it's unreasonable to hold an endorser responsible for episodes like this. Already contracts have strong two way indemnity clauses in place; I guess they'd be stronger now and spend more billable legal hours in the process. I cannot imagine that there's a single celeb out there who would've declined a Nestle brand to be honest. I don't imagine that's going to change very much.?

Concurring with Kasbekar, Blah said, ?When a celebrity is endorsing a product, he is lending his name and his image to it. He is not involved in any other activity of the product. All he is doing is attracting eyeballs for the brand. If he were involved in the making of the product, then it would have been justified. But after they endorse a finished product, one can?t hold them responsible. If one batch goes wrong then it is not the celebrity?s responsibility, it is the company?s and the government?s responsibility as they have approved the product. It?s not fair to drag celebrities in this,? he said.

Bijoor is of the opinion that the first thing that Nestle India will do is sort out the issue with the regulators and various states. ?After that they will start addressing the consumer and that is when a lot of credibility building advertising will come from Maggi. Maggi is a highly evolved brand in India. They need to communicate with a different degree of tenacity with the consumers and they will do that,? he voiced.

While celebs have been a part of the controversy, Bijoor thinks that the first thing celebs will do and have done in the past is to indemnify themselves from any collateral damage that the brand faces. ?Without doubt they will be more careful and diligent henceforth,? he added.

Will this one controversy also open doors to other and put other brands under the scanner? To this, Bijoor said, ?This is just one category. If you look at the other categories like tea, frozen food, fresh vegetables, fish, poultry and meat that we eat; you will be shocked to find that the content of chemicals and metals is much higher than permissible limits across the world. So this is a major reaction on Maggi. This paints the entire industry with the same brush.?

Sharing her thoughts on the controversy, PromaxBDA Africa and Asia Pacific country head Rajika Mitra said, ?For the brand Maggi, it has created a huge setback and for Nestle, the brand integrity has been hugely impacted. The brand image of Maggi has witnessed a major dent in its popularity.?

Mitra further added that Nestle would have an uphill task to build customer confidence and re-launch the brand in a completely new avatar, which might take years.

?Celebs have been drawn into this controversy in a big way. Big brands and celebrity associations have always been a popular feature and they do feel responsible for the brands that they accept and endorse. Henceforth, they will be more cautious when accepting such brands in future,? she said.

It may be recalled that as part of its damage control exercise after the worm controversy, Cadburys India came up with new packaging, which would keep the product fresh and intact without refrigeration. However, it is a known fact that chocolates need to be refrigerated, the question is: Why did Cadbury wait for the worm controversy to change its packaging?

While Kasbekar believes that this controversy will be a blip in the progress of this superbrand, the fact remains that the communication path that Nestle India will have to take for brand Maggi following this unprecedented controversial blaze will no doubt have to be powerful enough to dowse the flames.

Latest Reads
‘Beautiful by Nature’: JOYquestions Stereotypes in a Brand New Campaign with Mouni Roy

People are conditioned into following certain pre-defined beauty standards of how a woman should look, behave and carry herself around. Physical appearance has always been the yardstick to measure a woman’s beauty

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
India gets their first-ever international standard Motion Capture Lab

An institution in the entertainment & storytelling sector, Famous Studios once again proves its leadership position.

MAM Marketing MAM
HDFC Life chooses Music to connect with young millennials

HDFC Life Insurance Company, one of India’s largest private life insurers, launched the second edition of its successful campaign #YoungandResponsible on 15 November 2018.

MAM Marketing MAM
Droom ramps up its marketing momentum with the launch of an integrated radio/cinema campaign in major cities across India!

Droom, India’s largest and pioneering online automobile transactional platform, has today announced the rollout of an integrated marketing campaign.

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
Realme introduces its new visual identity system and logo

Realme, the smartphone brand that specializes in providing high quality products for youth, launched its fully upgraded Brand Visual Identity system and Logo to provide a new visual experience and emotional connection with young consumers.

MAM Marketing MAM
Business Entrepreneurialism sees emergence of Social Entrepreneurialism: Ipsos Survey

According to a new survey by Ipsos, a global market research agency, the traditional definition of entrepreneurialism is now undergoing a metamorphosis of sorts and is moving from pure play business entrepreneurialism and is adding a key element of social entrepreneurialism to make a definitive...

MAM Marketing MAM

Ooyala today announced that it has joined the SRT Alliance, a collaboration to continuously develop the SRT (Secure Reliable Transport) protocol and technology stack for low-latency video streaming across any network.

MAM Marketing MAM
Producers Guild of India amends by-laws Makes it mandatory for members to implement 'The Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace' (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act 2013 (PoSH)

Mumbai: Producers Guild of India at its Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) on 14th November, 2018 in Mumbai unanimously passed a resolution to amend its by-laws thereby making  it  mandatory  for  all those  members  who  fall  under  the  purview  of  the  The  Sexual Harassment of Women at...

MAM Marketing MAM
Isobar launches Sri Lanka Operations

Isobar, the digital agency from Dentsu Aegis Network, has expanded its operations to Sri Lanka.

MAM Media and Advertising Digital Agencies

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories