'A slight slip in control can make comedy appear inane' : Manjul Sinha

Manjul Sinha saw his first movie when he was all of two days old. Films have since been an obsession for him. Born into a "filmi family",- they owned a cinema hall in Patna - Sinha always wanted to be a director. So after graduation in English Literature from the prestigious Hindu College, the first thing he did was take a train to Mumbai and start assisting his uncle, filmmaker Shivendra Sinha. He however soon came to the conclusion that training under someone could be no substitute to a specialised course. Hence, after "wasting a year" as he puts it, he joined the Film and Television Institute of India in Pune. He passed out with a first in 1977 and returned to Mumbai to pursue his career.

For the next few years, there was not much heard from Sinha until Yeh Jo Hai Zindagi happened. The dawn of colour TV in India is synonymous with this serial. Such was its popularity that cinema halls would run empty on Friday nights. Seventeen years after YJHZ, Sinha is back with another comedy - Yeh Hai Mumbai Meri Jaan - on Zee TV, which is in its first weeks on air. In between YJHZ and YHMMJ, Sinha has to his credit several ad-films and a series of one-hour stories on Zee - Rishtey.

What drew you to direction?

Well, I was born into a film family. We were into exhibition of films and later ventured into distribution and even production of some Bhojpuri films. So, the interest in the medium was there right from the start. Then, in my formative years at Sainik School, Tilayia, we used to have regular screenings of movies and thankfully the principal there was a person who had a fair knowledge of the medium. He would brief us about the film before each screening and this facilitated an easy understanding and led to greater interest in movies. I think all these factors contributed towards my decision later to become a director.

But did you always want to be a director? After all, children are normally fascinated by the idea of being actors.

Always. This is because I realised that whenever I had to perform on stage, I was uncomfortable. But I was a good visualiser and would manage things quite well without actually coming into the picture. In fact I've recently found an old diary of mine from when I was in Std. 8 where I've written I wanted to be a director.

What are the natural instincts that a director needs to have?

Basically, a director needs to be a good observer, a thinker. He needs to be a leader of men without making it obvious to people working with him. He needs to be a people's man because filmmaking is all about teamwork.

How do you look back to Yeh Jo Hai Zindagi?

When YJHZ happened, TV was just about taking off in India and most people were apprehensive about entering the medium. In fact we ourselves weren't sure about how different the technicalities would be in shooting a serial as opposed to a film. I remember a lot of jokes about Kundan Shah and me were doing the rounds in those days. But yes, there was a freshness involved in the task. The entire crew - actors, writers and cameramen - were extremely committed and determined. They all worked with a lot of passion and the end result is there for everyone to see. In fact later - my assistants, the writer - all have tried to create something similar but the success of YJHZ remains unmatched.

How different is it making a serial now compared to back then with respect to work schedules, the actors, their availability and performances?

Those days can never come back. Then, we used to shoot one episode in approximately three and a half days. I still take two days to shoot one episode though there are directors who even try and complete two episodes a day. Sincerity and dedication is lacking now. Then actors would work on a single project, now they do half a dozen of them simultaneously. They fit in two to three shifts a day and are always in a hurry. When this happens, performances are bound to decline.

You've always been very selective about your work. Don't you feel you got left behind in the rat race?

No, I don't. Money has never been my top priority. In any case, do you think those directors who are supposedly directing three to four serials simultaneously are actually present during the shoot? I don't want to be a 'series' director. I am proud of all my work and am involved with it in every possible way. In fact the only reason I became a producer was because I realised that the product which was the result of my hard labour was not being handled well at the last stage. It was not being marketed the right way or given to the right channel. As a producer I have complete control over my product.

Any specific reason why you've specialised in comedy?

No. I would love to direct a soap. But not everybody can handle comedy well. The channels know it very well and hence after YJHZ everybody wanted me do a comedy. It wasn't a conscious choice.

How difficult or easy is it do direct a comedy compared to a soap?

Comedy is the toughest. The control required is immense and it has to be handled intelligently. A slight slip in control can make comedy appear inane.

Comedy is also tough simply because our culture is not steeped in humour except maybe to an extent Marathi culture. The psyche of Indian viewers is such that they enjoy watching emotional upheavels more than watching comedy. As a result, over here a comedy possibly cannot be a TRP chartbuster. Even the effort required in sustaining the interest of the audience is far more compared to a soap where the makers can get away with occasional low phases.

Do you need minute scripting for a comedy or do you normally improvise on the sets?

We do improvise but no improvisation will work unless there has been minute detailing with regard to the script. Minute scripting is quintessential and without it the director is not able to take the viewers into the zone of "willing suspension in disbelief".

What do you feel of the present trend of the dominance of slapstick?

Well, slapstick is the easier form vis-a vis situational comedy in the same way as overacting is easier compared to method acting. But over the years their success shows that there is definitely an audience for it and so long as there is an audience the channels are more than happy to provide it.

Given a choice between slapstick, situational and satire, which appeals to you the most?

I would always opt for satire. But in India, political satire always runs the risk of running into problems, especially on the national channels. A satire on human conditions is an interesting proposition but again needs to be handled in a very sensitive manner.

Where do you draw your inspiration from? Do the comedians of yesteryears play a part?

The comedians of yesteryears - Charlie Chaplin, Marx brothers - are the biggest heroes cinema has ever seen. Even though I don't necessarily keep them in mind all the time, the fact is that in the subconscious mind their images and actions do exist and play a part when I conceive a scene. Otherwise the inspiration can come from so many sources. I used to keep a diary to note down the funny things that happened during the course of my daily schedule and still refer to it at times.

What distinguishes your genre of comedy from that of others?

My comedy is woven around our lives. It is an extension of life's pathos, an attempt to laugh at ourselves. Even my slapstick has smart punchlines that are laced with pathos and the aim is to make a telling statement in a subtle manner. See, even when Chaplin chewed his shoes in one of his movies, it reflected a grim reality of the times. I seek to create a similar effect through my comedy.

What are the things you would never compromise on as a director?

The script and performances. They are the backbone of any successful project

It is seen that many actors who are good in intense scenes falter doing comedy. How do you extract performances from them?

Well, I believe I am a good teacher. I use a lot of metaphors and similes to get the actor into the right emotions and to feel situations better. My background in English Literature helps me in doing this. Besides, I 'm very patient and always believe that the first shot or the first expression can never be the best or the conclusive one. I don't act out a scene though.

Some actors actually prefer not to have a script for comedy. How do you cope with this?

I would never allow this. An actor who insists on this is not serious about his job.

Do you write all your projects?

I used to. Now I don't get into the technicalities of writing, though I still monitor the writing very closely. I think that is imperative for a project to evolve the way it is conceived.

Any project which you would be averse to directing?

A quiz show. I would rather participate in it.

Who are your favourite actors on Television?

I haven't seen a better actor than Shefali Chayya on TV. I would love to have her on all my Rishtey stories. Shekhar Suman is versatile and I believe much of his potential remains untapped. I would love to work with him.

Shefali Chayya

Which of your works are closest to you?

YJHZ, my ad-films and my stories on Rishtey. In fact I can safely say that my stories on Rishtey is the real me.

Anything you would like to take up in future?

I have a rough idea. I would love to work on a series that will loosely be a sitcom with a soapish theme. I will have satire and at times it will also be very grim and emotional. It is still at the conception stage and I'm yet to work out the minute details.

Satyajit Ray

Who is you favourite director?

Satyajit Ray. All his work was from the heart and he never compromised on his creativity and what he actually wanted to say.

As a filmmaker what does Manjul Sinha stand for? For instance, if Yash Chopra's work can be characterised as passionate depiction of utopian love, what is your style of film-making all about?

It would be difficult for me to classify my work into a particular genre because I've directed diverse plots. But yes, my work is an attempt at reality. Let me put it this way. That even in creating fantasy, I present it as close to reality as I can. So that it may evoke the same emotional response from the audience.

Latest Reads
MTV associates with Brave Combat Federation for 'Brave 20'

MTV, India’s youth brand, is all set to bring the fight series MTV Brave 20 in association with the Brave Combat Federation presented by Mercury Sports Entertainment on 17 February at 9 pm.

Television TV Channels Music and Youth
Q3 2019: BAG Films Television and Radio Dhaamal profits up

The Anurradha Prasad-led BAG Films and Media Ltd (BAG Films) reported 38.1 per cent higher year-on-year (y-o-y) consolidated revenue for the quarter ended 31 December 2018 (Q3- 019, period or quarter, under review) at Rs 48.67 crore as compared to Rs 33.94 crore in the corresponding prior year...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
Comcast, Sony in the running for ZEEL stake?

In the latest financial results, Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd (ZEEL) MD and CEO Punit Goenka mentioned that the company has narrowed down its search for a partner to divest up to 50 per cent stake in the company, an announcement it made in November 2018.

Television TV Channels GECs
9X Jalwa launches Jalwa #10YEARCHALLENGE

MUMBAI: 9X Jalwa, the Bollywood hits music channel by 9X Media, has created Jalwa #10YEARCHALLENGE, a unique property that showcases the songs of Bollywood stars from past to present. Jalwa #10YEARCHALLENGE will feature stars such as Aamir Khan, Aishwariya Rai, Kajol, Akshay Kumar, Salman Khan,...

Television TV Channels Music and Youth
CNN meets the young Lionel Messi fan from Afghanistan who is now a Taliban target

In January 2016, a photo of young Murtaza Ahmadi went viral, thanks to his makeshift version of an Argentine football shirt of his idol Lionel Messi. The photo earned the child two autographed shirts, a signed football and a meeting with the footballer in Qatar 11 months later.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
BARC to share TV viewership data only with subscribers due to TRAI tariff order implementation

Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) India has announced it will only share the weekly TV viewership data with those that have subscribed to its service. The audience measurement firm has taken this decision in light of the TRAI’s new tariff order, which kicked in on February 1.

Television TV Channels Viewership
Republic Bharat has made a smashing entry into the Hindi News genre

The Week 1 performance means that in just 7 days Republic Bharat has made tremendous inroads and on boarded audiences that some established brands have taken many years to reach.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
ISSF signs deal with SPN India for rifle and pistol World Cup broadcast

The International Shooting Sport Federation (ISSF) has signed a deal with Sony Pictures Network India to broadcast the World Cup, according to the Press Trust of India. The sport of shooting will have live television coverage of the World Cup Rifle/Pistol at Dr Karni Singh Range, Tughlakabad from...

Television TV Channels Sports
Broadcasters split over rising production cost of GEC content

The rise in over the top (OTT) platforms has also led broadcasters and production houses to drive up the investment into its TV shows. The same companies are now even producing for both TV and digital.

Television TV Channels GECs

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories