Study debunks media monopoly fears in the US

MUMBAI: It is a myth that US media ownership is over concentrated today. Another myth prevalent is that programming choices available to American consumers are shrinking or somehow have been impaired


These findings are contained in a report published by American organisation The New Millennium Research Council (NMRC). The report is titled The Media Monopoly Myth: How New Competition is Expanding Our Sources of Information and Entertainment. The NMRC is composed of a network of policy experts who develop workable, real-world solutions to the issues and challenges confronting policymakers. Its work has focused primarily in the fields of telecommunications and technology.

The report notes that it is regularly contended that “five large corporations” control 80 per cent of the prime time television audience and thus control how and what information people have access to. However the fact of the matter is that the rise of new communications technology, coupled with new producers of information, has continually fragmented the overall mass audience once captured by the old mass media.

In the midst of ongoing court, Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and public debate about media consolidation, the study finds that fears about media control and program choices are not based on fact and also reflect increasingly outdated notions of how consumers use media at a point in time when millions are shifting their attention to the Internet and other digital technologies.

The report notes that the three traditional broadcast networks -- ABC, CBS and NBC -- have seen their prime time ratings slide by about two thirds from the 1970s to date. In the 1970s, on a typical weekday evening, the three networks were watched by about 56 per cent of all households with televisions. By 2003, on a typical evening those networks had on aggregate a 20 per cent rating. They also face competition from newer networks, including Time Warner’s WB and News Corp’s Fox. Those five networks together aggregated to a 26 per cent rating.

Adding together the rating of these five broadcast networks with the cable networks owned by the same corporate family like CNN, HBO and the five major providers of television programming accounted for an average 51 per cent rating in December 2003. This is less than the share that the three networks enjoyed in the 1970s.

In the largest US markets, there typically are 15 or more separate owners of radio stations -- and in most of even the smallest markets in the US have more radio competition than in local TV and newspapers combined. A review of 17 studies finds that chainowned newspapers have greater latitude in determining editorial policy than do editors at familycontrolled newspapers.

The report notes that current measures for media ownership do not take into account the massive shift over the last 10 years in which two-thirds of Americans use the Internet for information gathering purposes, including viewing television and reading newspaper content.



The report notes that television viewers have more choices from more sources than at any time in the history of the medium. There is no support for the contention that media ownership by chains or conglomerates leads to any consistent pattern of lowered standards, content, or performance when compared with media owned by families or small companies.

The report argues that American policy makers have been concentrating on the wrong issues -- the financial size of media companies or the number of eyeballs tuned in to local programming -- rather than whether consumers have a wider range of programming options from which to choose, as is the case today. What is being observed in the US is that the media environment is changing so rapidly that traditional notions of 'media ownership' and 'concentration' have become irrelevant.

Overly restrictive federal ownership guidelines seeking to remedy these misplaced concerns about media ownership and content are now dysfunctional fixes for a phantom problem. The report bas noted that new delivery mechanism provide for greater choice. An example of that is the delivery of video and film via the Internet. This system is on the verge of becoming more mainstream.

As some of the local telephone carriers upgrade their systems with fiber optic cable to the curb or the home, the transmission speed of downloads will be competitive with cable and satellite services. Devices are on the market that allow even today’s broadband users to download movies and video programming for storage on personal video recorders for viewing at their convenience.

Latest Reads
Pro Volleyball League players present Mumbai team jersey to Sunil Gavaskar

Pro Volleyball League stars Mohan Ukkrapandian from Kochi Blue Spikets (L) and Ranjit Singh from Ahmedabad Defenders (R) present the official UMumba jersey to Mumbaikar and cricketing legend, Sunil Gavaskar, who is a panellist on Sony Pictures Networks India’s live studio show, Extraaa Innings.

Television TV Channels Sports
Nikhil Sangha’s Happy Anniversary has a powerful social message for all

While January 24 is observed as the National Girl Child Day across India, Nikhil Sangha’s short film ‘Happy Anniversary’ has a delicate yet poignant message for us all.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
Vestel Releases First CASTVs with Integrated Broadcast Pay TV Services

AMSTERDAM: Home appliance and consumer electronics manufacturer, Vestel has launched the first TVs which allow consumers to access premium pay TV services directly through their TVs without the need for a separate set-top box (STB), CI CAM or any other external device. The 43” UHD CASTV will be...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Disney’s Marvel HQ to offer fresh content

The Walt Disney Company India is making some changes to its newly renamed channel Marvel HQ. To attract viewers, the chanel will undergo a content change. The channel aims to transport viewers into the world of epic storytelling told through inspiring characters and will reach out to kids 9+ (boys...

Television TV Channels Kids
Ad, subscription revenues drive Zeel numbers up for third quarter

The Subhash Chandra led Zee Entertainment Enterprises Limited reported 17.9 percent year-on year (y-o-y) growth in operating revenue at Rs 2,166.77 crore for the quarter ended 31 December 2018 (Q3 2019, quarter or period under review) as compared to the Rs 1,838.07 crore for the corresponding year...

Television TV Channels GECs
DSPORT to telecast marquee european tour events in india

DSPORT, a premium sports channel of Discovery Communications, will broadcast live , Marquee events from the European Tour 2019, Europe’s premiere and one of golf’s strongest professional tours featuring some of the world’s top professional golfers.

Television TV Channels Sports
TV18 boosts Network18 numbers for third quarter

Mukesh Dhirbhai Ambani’s media arm, Network18 reported improved numbers for the quarter ended 31 December 2018 (Q3 2019, quarter under review) as compared to the corresponding year ago quarter Q3 2018).

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
PM Narendra Modi's interview with ANI News garners 5.9 mn impressions

Indian PM Narendra Modi gave an interview to ANI News on 1 January 2019. It raked in 5.9 million impressions in the Hindi news genre, according to BARC India.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
Comedy Central and BSF join forces to ‘Spread The Cheer’ among the Jawans in Jammu

Comedy Central – India’s leading 24-hour English Entertainment channel is committed towards making India smile and spreading cheer in citizens’ lives.

Television TV Channels English Entertainment

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories