Television

BCCI not a 'State': Supreme Court

http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/smartcrop_800x800/public/images/tv-images/2016/04/19/BCCI_0.jpeg?itok=1D06ghZQ

NEW DELHI: In what can be termed disappointing news for Zee Telefilms, the Supreme Court today ruled that the Indian cricket board was not a 'State as defined under Article 12 of the Indian Constitution and, hence, cannot be sued for alleged violation of fundamental rights.

 

However, the apex court also suggested that some lower court could take up such cases under Article 226. The three-two split SC ruling is important, as the Indian cricket boards case would have major impact on the autonomy of various sports bodies in the country and their subsequent functioning.

Dismissing the case, the court observed, "The petitioner has failed to establish that the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) is a state body."

Zee's shares fell as much as 4 per cent to Rs 148 as the news fanned out to reach the stock markets. At the end of the day, however, the stock recovered to close on the Bombay Stock Exchange at Rs 154.10 (down 0.8 per cent from yesterday's close) as the company maintained that it will continue its legal battle against the BCCI. Zee's shares have fallen nearly 11 per cent this year.

A five-judge Constitution bench, comprising Justices N Santosh Hegde, SN Variava, BP Singh, HK Sema and SB Sinha gave the landmark ruling, while dismissing a writ petition filed by Zee Telefilms Ltd seeking relief against the Board of Control or Cricket in India (BCCI) for alleged arbitrary cancellation of its bid for telecast rights of Indian cricket till 2007.

The ruling was given by 3:2 majority. While Justices Hegde, Singh and Sema held that the BCCI was not a 'State', Justices Variava and Sinha were of the opinion that the cricket board was a 'State' within the meaning of Article 12.

Zee Telefilms contention had been that the BCCI was a 'State' as it was selecting the Indian team and was given de facto recognition by the Indian government to carry out its functions. The petition had requested the apex court to scrutinise the Boards action of canceling the bid for telecast under writ authority.

According to a Press Trust of India report, Justice Hegde, writing the majority judgement, observed that the government of India had not passed any law authorising the cricket board to select the Indian team and the control exercised by it over the regulating body for cricket, at best, could be termed as regulatory, which was not enough to declare BCCI as a 'State'.

Zee remains optimistic

Meanwhile, Zee Telefilms, Indias largest media and entertainment conglomerate, today "hailed" the decision of the Supreme Court stating that BCCI was performing a public duty under Article 226.

Ashish Kaul, spokesperson for the Essel group, the parent entity of Zee Telefilms, said Zee would be approaching a high court very soon, preferably in Delhi, to pursue the matter.

Zee Telefilms had originally won the cricket rights by bidding the highest amount of $ 260 million on 5 September, 2004 amongst other competitors that included ESPN Star Sports ($ 230 million), Indian pubcaster Prasar Bharati ($ 150 million), Sony Entertainment TV India ($ 140 million) and Dubai-based Ten Sports ($ 115 million).

Subsequently, as a drama unfolded revolving around the bidding process and various aspects of it, including technical criteria, Zee committed another Rs 940 million for the development of domestic cricket. ESS too got into the act and upped the ante with a mind-boggling bid figure of $ 308 million, which Zee subsequently matched to be awarded the rights.

Then ESS, apart from legally challenging the award of the telecast rights by BCCI to Zee, later approached the Supreme Court seeking legal redressal against cancellation of the bidding process by the cricket board.

As the Supreme Court dwelt on a clutch of cricket-related cases, including one involving Prasar Bharati and Ten Sports, Zee was hoping to get a stronger decision in its favour. In a rare interview given in recent times, Zee Tele CMD Subhash Chandra had told indiantelevision.com that the company would pursue the matter of cricket with zeal and was

confident of winning the case ultimately.

Zee plans to launch a dedicated sports channel in the second quarter of 2005, and India cricket rights would represent a lucrative property to build on.

What does Article 226 mean?

The high courts have a parallel power under Article 226 to enforce the fundamental rights. Article 226 differs from Article 12 and/or 32 in the sense whereas Article 32 can be invoked only for the enforcement of Fundamental Rights, Article 226 can be invoked not only for the enforcement of Fundamental Rights but for any "other purpose" as well.

This means that the Supreme Courts power under Article 12 and Article 32 is restricted as compared with the power of a High Court under Article 226, for, if an administrative action does not affect a Fundamental Right, then it can be challenged only in the High Court under Article 226, and not in the Supreme Court under Article 32.

Another corollary to this difference is that a PIL (Public Interest Litigation) can be filed in Supreme Court under Article 32 only if a question concerning the enforcement of a fundamental right is involved. Under Article 226, a writ petition can be filed in a high court whether or not a Fundamental Right is involved.

The provision of legal aid is fundamental to promoting access to courts. The Supreme Court of India has taken imaginative measures to promote access to justice when people would otherwise be denied their fundamental rights. It has done this by the twin strategy of loosening the traditional rules of locus standi, and relaxing procedural rules in such cases.

Several sections of the constitution such as Articles 13 (laws inconsistent with or in derogation of the Fundamental Rights (are void)); Article 14 (Equality before law); Article 20 (Protection in respect of conviction for offenses); Article 21 (Protection of life and personal liberty); Article 22 (Protection against arrest and detention in certain cases); Article 38

(State to secure a social order for the promotion of welfare of the people); and Article 39 (certain principles of policy to be followed by the State) have been interpreted in conjunction with Articles 32 and 226 to extend right of access to courts and judicial redress in various matters.

Latest Reads

http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/25/sony.jpg?itok=I2kxp4Dq
Sony Pictures Networks India (SPN) to telecast the India Tour of Ireland 2018 live and exclusive on SONY SIX and SONY TEN 3 channels

Sony Pictures Networks India (SPN) has announced that it has acquired the exclusive media rights to telecast the 2018 India Tour of Ireland that comprises two T20Is to be played on June 27 and June 29, 2018, in Malahide, Ireland.

Television TV Channels Sports
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/25/tlc.jpg?itok=JVqCpOWZ
TLC to show Masterchef Canada season 5

TLC, a part of Discovery, has announced the telecast of the fifth season of the culinary competition series Masterchef Canada from 26 June in India.

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/25/naam.jpg?itok=3O03ZYZ2
&pictures to screen the Indian spy thriller ‘Naam Shabana’ on Saturday, 29th June at 9.30pm

A spinoff of the 2015 box office hit Baby, Naam Shabana follows the life and journey of a spy. Directed by Shivam Nair, the thriller features Taapsee Pannu as Shabana Khan along with Akshay Kumar, Prithviraj Sukumaran, Anupam Kher and Manoj Bajpayee essaying pivotal characters. &pictures, Naye...

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/25/kids.jpg?itok=M51Ves5n
Big Trunk Communications bags digital mandate of Discovery Kids channel in India

Big Trunk Communications, a Mumbai-based full-fledged creative digital agency, has acquired digital duties for Discovery Kids channel in India.The business was won as part of a pitch against leading digital agencies.

Television TV Channels Kids
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/23/zee-tamil-sare-gama.jpg?itok=Vd5vu3RX
Zee Tamil strengthens its weekend programming

MUMBAI: Zee Tamil, the tamil general entertainment channel of ZEEL, recently announced its decision to spruce up its fiction bands for weekends.

Television TV Channels Regional
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/22/Nivedita-Oak.jpg?itok=75PAewjb
Times Television Network elevates Nivedita Oak to DGM

Times Television Network (TTN) has elevated Nivedita Oak to deputy general manager - influence. Earlier, Oak was the regional head for Zoom, FCT and branded content. She has been working with the Times Network for the last 11 years.

Television TV Channels People
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/22/pathan.jpg?itok=tah626ME
History TV18 to release third film in ‘Special Operations India' series

History TV18, a pan-Indian television channel, is to create a documentary on counter-terrorist operation at Pathankot air base named Special Operations India: Pathankot. This one-hour documentary will be aired on June 25 at 9 pm.

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/22/cnbc.jpg?itok=opviMAi9
CNBC-TV18 successfully concludes the 8th edition of the ‘India Healthcare and Wellness Awards 2018’

NBC-TV18, India’s leading English business news channel along with ICICI Lombard hosted the 8th edition of the ‘Indian Healthcare and Wellness Awards 2018’ at The Grand Hyatt, Mumbai.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/drupal7.indiantelevision.co.in/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/22/mn.jpg?itok=QPriVkLO
MN+ to air Indian Television premier of ‘Tulip Fever’

MN+, the Gold Class of Hollywood Movies from the Times Network, brings to the viewers, for the first time on Indian television, the celebrated romantic historical saga– ‘Tulip Fever’. The movie will premiere on Sunday, 24th June at 1 pm and 9pm on MN+.

Television TV Channels English Entertainment

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories