Zee pitches for allowing adult content on TV


MUMBAI: The Subhash Chandra-promoted Zee Telefilms today made a strong pitch for allowing adult content on television, which should be regulated. Reason: it would help bring about more transparency in the system.

Making a case for the move, Essel Corporate Group vice-president corporate brand development Ashish Kaul said, "This will bring about transparency in the business as, like it or not, adult content is a part of our lives. It is there on the Internet and on MMS on mobile phones. Does this mean that we ban it? Other newer media have far more impact than TV."

Speaking a session on content regulation at the Ficci Frames, Kaul said, "Covers of magazines, sometimes, have provocative pictures. Newspapers too, are no less bold."

Almost 140 million newspapers are sold everyday. Should we stop it?" Extending the argument further kaul explained that the problem lies in the Indian policy-makers obsession for restricting TV content, while not giving much thought to the other media. "In a sense, TV is being made a scapegoat," he added.

Already there are cable operators who after midnight screen adult films. This is due to a huge public demand. Legitimising adult content with regulation will "bring in accountability."

"If a consumer pays for DTH, and he wants adult content why should he be restricted when he has paid for it?" Kaul asked, adding to the debate whether adult content should be allowed on Indian television or the country continues to wear the moral fig leaf closing its eyes to developments happening all over the world.

Universal McCann India president Chintamani Rao said it was undesirable for a proposed Communications Commission of India to be appointed as a super regulator. "It goes against our cultural ethos. Instead we should have a structured and formalised self-regulatory body like ASCI is for advertising, he opined.

Coming down heavily on selective censorship and restrictions being imposed on certain segments of the media, Rao decried the urgency being shown in censoring ads, while nothing is done about Hindi film songs, some of which border on absolute vulgarity.

"It is ridiculous that an ad that shows a man running after eating candy is banned, while vulgar film songs pass muster," Rao said, however, conceding that there were times when broadcasters misbehaved with the rules regarding advertising.

A case in point is liquor advertising. While an understanding was reached that liquor ads would only air between 9 PM and 5:30 am, broadcasters "misbehaved" by showing liquor ads at 6 PM

Information and broadcasting minister joint secretary R Parasuram, also present during the session offered the government perspective saying the ministry is looking into various aspects of content regulation, including setting up a semi-governmental autonomous body for this purpose. Another provision that is being considered is imposing a ban on a channel that shows offensive material. This is being discussed with the law ministry, Parasuram said, indicating a downlink policy is also being discussed in the ministry. "This could have ramifications as far as restricting content is concerned," he added.

Star India VP Karan Kuljeet Singh said that broadcasters have internal control mechanisms for monitoring purposes. Self regulation is important. According to him it is important for broadcasters to design a universal ratings system and for broadcasters to respect viewers' sensibilities. Otherwise, viewers will switch off.

Legal firm TSG Associates' Tamali Sengupta gave delegates an overview of content regulation in different countries. "Most countries have self-regulation, although a fine or a penalty can be imposed," she pointed out.

After the Janet Jackson Super Bowl `wardrobe malfunction' episode in the US, the Federal Communications Commission increased the fine limit to half a million dollars from $32,050. The FCC acts on public complaints. For the Jackson episode, the FCC had received 530,000 complaints from the public.

The main reason for regulation is that broadcasters must meet

Acceptable community standards. However, there are challenges before content regulators globally. One of them being the penalty that must be imposed, Sengupta said.

Should content owners be liable for retransmitted content? Should there be pre-censorship in TV as there is in films? These are some of the issues, according to her, haunting regulators worldwide.

Sengupta added that the US position is that a cable company is not Subject to government interference as the investment is entirely private. For terrestrial TV, however, the government insists on controlling some spectrum. Industry self-regulation has worked in the US.

In the UK, Ofcom is the regulatory body, which has proposed a new draft code for content. Section One states that content that will impair a child's psychological and emotional development can only be screened in the watershed hours of 9 pm-5.30 am. Violence, sex, unjustified nudity are not allowed outside the watershed period.

"As far as India is concerned we need to look at whether content codes are compatible with acceptable community standards", Sengupta concluded.

Latest Reads

2017 for infotainment and lifestyle channels

MUMBAI: The infotainment and lifestyle genres can’t compete with GECs when it comes to ratings but that doesn’t dampen the spirits of channel heads. New shows are constantly launched to engage the tight community of viewers that channels in the category command.

Specials Year Enders
2017 was a regulatory roller coaster and the ride continues

NEW DELHI: The year 2017 for the media industry certainly couldn’t be called easy from the point of doing business despite efforts and claims by the federal government that significant progress had been made in the regard.

Specials Year Enders
Guest column: Digital outlook for 2018

MUMBAI: The year 2017 is behind us and, as we peek into 2018, there is so much to look forward to. The digital landscape is so dynamic and ever-evolving that an annual trend-spotting article would be unfair. But still there are key areas where digital is heading and I can safely say that 2018 is...

Specials Year Enders
Content segmentation defines English entertainment, movies in 2017

MUMBAI: It was the year of HD for English entertainment in India. Add to it, the bump up in the number of movie premieres and series that you could now see in better quality. Increased adoption of HD set top boxes encouraged broadcasters to go for HD. Content segmentation has emerged as a big...

Specials Year Enders
DTH's year of consolidation

MUMBAI: It would be safe to say that this was the year of the big DTH challenge. India’s cable TV multi system operators (MSOs) could not go into many phase IV areas and DTH stepped in wherever analogue broadcast signals were switched off following the crossing of the digital addressable system (...

Specials Year Enders
2017 a year of rebranding and extending time slots for Hindi GECs

MUMBAI: The year 2017 was a roller-coaster ride for Hindi general entertainment channels (GEC) in the truest spirit of the term. The tussle for the top slot in the Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) ratings has seen pay TV and free-to-air (FTA) channels hold on tight to the rope.

Specials Year Enders
The year of hiccups for marketers

MUMBAI: The year 2017 was when brands were unwillingly thrown into a roller-coaster ride only to emerge dizzy and faint. The highs weren’t enough to ride out the lows.

Specials Year Enders
2017: The year OTTs went regional in India

MUMBAI: Over-the-top (OTT) services were undoubtedly the centre of attraction in 2017. The boom in India’s internet users, mainly aided by the growth of Reliance Jio, ensured that OTT players got the right reception and target audience. Not just  mainstream TV broadcasters but even smaller players...

Specials Year Enders
Making the news: A look at what news broadcasters did in 2017

MUMBAI: News channels were thrown into a storm of activity in 2017 with each player keeping up its oars to wade out of challenges that hit at them like ten-foot waves. With elections and sensational news driving up viewership at various points throughout the year, English news channels had to...

Specials Year Enders

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories