Centre backs Zee stand on writ against BCCI

MUMBAI / NEW DELHI: Separate legal moves at different courts in the country today are together posing the most serious threat to the untrammeled authority Jagmohan Dalmiya has enjoyed over the affairs of Indian cricket board these past few years.

Zee Telefilms, embroiled in a cricket telecast rights case in the Supreme Court, today found an ally in the Indian government, which described the Indian cricket board as a 'state' under the terms of Article 12. This move, however, has upset the cricket board.

Arguments continued today in the apex court --- and will do so again tomorrow --- on whether a Zee petition, challenging cancellation of a tendering process by the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI), is maintainable or not and whether the cricket board can be termed a 'state'.

Making his submission before a five-judge constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, additional solicitor general Mohan Parasaran, appearing for the Centre, argued that the board came within the purview of the definition of 'state' under Article 12 of the Constitution.

At the other end of the country, meanwhile, a Chennai court, in an order issued this morning, has restrained till 11 October the BCCI's confirming the appointment of Dalmiya, who is its outgoing president, as patron-in-chief of the world's richest cricket board. Dalmiya was appointed the first ever patron-in-chief of the BCCI at a special meeting on 12 September.


While this was seen as a setback for him, later in the day Dalmiya scored a far bigger victory. Over the Maharashtra political heavyweight and Union agriculture minister Sharad Pawar no less. Elections to decide who would succeed Dalmiya as the cricket board president held in Kolkata ended with a 15:15 tie. Dalmiya who had the casting vote in case of such a tie voted in favour of his nominee, Haryana Cricket Association president Ranbir Singh Mahendra. The elections were held after a seven-hour delay.

Mahendra (or should one say Dalmiya) hardly had time to savour the victory however, when the news came that Pawar would be challenging the way the election was conducted in court. Addressing the media after the elections, Pawar accused Dalmiya of "hijacking" the election process to ensure that Mahendra won.

Coming back to the action in the Supreme Court, the Union Government sprang a surprise on the BCCI when it supported Zee on the issue of maintainability of its petition in the cricket rights case by stating that the Board was a 'state' within the framework of constitutional provisions.

According to agency reports, the Centre's changing stance on whether BCCI is an instrument of the state or a private body for organising and managing the game of cricket irked the latter and this was conveyed to the court by its counsel KK Venugopal.

Venugopal told the court that the government was taking a contradictory stand on the issue. He said while in its affidavit filed before the Delhi high court in a cricket- related case, it had taken the stand that the BCCI was an organ of the state (the time when former cricketer Ajay Jadeja was contesting a ban by BCCI after match-fixing allegations), in an another affidavit filed in the Bombay High Court in the ESPN-Star petition, the Central government had taken the stand that BCCI was a private body.

Additional solicitor general Mohan Parasaran, appearing for the Centre, told the bench, also including Justices SN Variava, BP Singh, HK Sema and SB Sinha, that the government could not be forced to restrict its arguments to a particular level, news agencies reported. He said the government was free to go beyond the contents of its affidavits filed in the high courts of Delhi and Mumbai.

The Central government will file a written submission on the matter tomorrow.

Even as Dalmiya girds for legal battle on three different fronts (Zee's writ, his elevation as cricket board patron-in-chief and the BCCI poll outcome), one thing is certain. The man who seems to thrive on a good scrap is not likely to give an inch and seems clearly set to wage an all or nothing fight to protect what he seems to view as his personal fiefdom - the richest cricket board on the planet.

Latest Reads
Four news genres saw no change in BARC week 2

All the four genres apart from Hindi news urban market saw no change in second week of the year. Aaj Tak continued to groove on the same tracks in the rural, urban and U+R genres as it did the previous year. India TV and News18 India interchanged their positions in the Hindi news urban market.

Television TV Channels Viewership
Sony Entertainment Television leads urban areas in week 2 of BARC

Sony Entertainment Television jumped to second position to fifth position as compared to the previous week in the Hindi (U+R) genre in Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) data for week 2 of 2018. Zee Anmol retained its first position in the rural market. Sony Entertainment Television and...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Aaj Tak becomes the world’s first News Channel to be awarded YouTube’s ‘Diamond Play Button’

India’s No.1 news channel Aaj Tak creates history yet again! The prestigious ‘Diamond Play Button’ bestowed by YouTube, recognises Aaj Tak as the global no.1, the first and the only news channel in the world to have crossed the 10 Million Subscriber mark.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
News18 India launches campaign; asserts channel’s leadership

News18 India, Network18’s general Hindi news channel, recently launched a campaign with a humorous and quirky film to drive home its leadership position in the crucial primetime band in the highly competitive Hindi TV news segment.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
Join Drac’s Pack on their cruise as &flix presents its next #FlixFirstPremiere ‘Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation’

It is seldom that you get to see the hilarious side to a monster trying to get himself a date with the help of a technological app like Siri! Have you ever seen a monster film that is full of fun, frolic, laughter, romance and adventure?

Television TV Channels English Entertainment
9XM On Stage with Salim Sulaiman

To celebrate the Republic Day week, 9XM - India’s most popular Bollywood music destination announces the launch of 9XM On Stage a splendid musical night created in honour of the Indian Armed Forces.

Television TV Channels Music and Youth
Prime Focus joins hands with Pritam and Kwan to create JAM8

Integrated media services company Prime Focus Ltd has announced its collaboration with Jam8, a musical platform founded by Indian music composer/director Pritam, and KWAN, a talent management company to serve as a 360-degree creative solution provider for the M&E industry.

Television Production House Film Production
Star Movies Kids is the new kid on the block

A few years ago Star India decided to hive off some bits of its repertoire and focus exclusively on its main GEC Star Plus and the emerging sports scenario. Surprisingly, the channel is now taking a new turn by targeting the youngest viewers. As per industry sources, the Uday Shankar-led network is...

Television TV Channels Kids
Zapak and Cartoon Network India partner to launch ‘Ben 10 - Alien Run’ mobile game

Anil D. Ambani led Reliance Entertainment’s Zapak, India’s leading Gaming Destination, in association with Cartoon Network India, rings in the New Year with an epic launch for fans and gamers alike, with Ben 10 - Alien Run Mobile Game.

Television TV Channels Kids

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories