No rights for third party: HC to BCCI

MUMBAI/NEW DELHI: The Bombay High Court today asked the Indian cricket board to maintain "status quo" and make a firm commitment that it would not award the contract for telecast rights to any third party until it decides on the legal dispute between Zee Telefilms Ltd and ESPN Star Sports.

In its response, the Board for Control of Cricket in India (BCCI) stated it was unable to make such a commitment. It argued that with the Australian cricket team due to land in India on 6 October to play a four test series, and in keeping with International Cricket Council (ICC) rules, the series would perforce have to be telecast. Otherwise there would be a breach of condition of affiliation with the ICC, BCCI's counsel contended, adding that the cricket matches have to be recorded for the benefit of the third umpire as well.

Chief Justice Dalveer Bhandari and Justice Dhananjay Chandrachud had given the direction to BCCI this morning after the board's counsel, in his opening statement, told the court that although Zee had won the bid, the contract had not yet been awarded to it.

It was in view of this statement that the court ordered the BCCI to maintain status quo. Both ESPN-Star Sports and Zee Telefilms urged the court to direct the Indian cricket board to give a firm commitment that it would not give the contract to any third party unless the telecast rights dispute was settled, a report filed by the Press Trust of India says.


The counsel for both parties pointed to reports in the media wherein BCCI supreme (and lately made patron-in-chief) Jagmohan Dalmiya is quoted as having said that in the event of the case dragging on, the board may consider giving the rights to pubcaster Prasar Bharati or make some alternative arrangements for telecast of the Australia series.

The judges said they would hear the arguments of both sides tomorrow on the petition filed by ESS challenging BCCI's decision to award the $ 308 million contract to Zee for telecast rights of cricket matches to be played between October 2004 and September 2008.

As regards the case itself, sources close to the developments say that there would be some 'dramatic revelations' made by Zee when the case comes up for hearing on the morrow.

Zee, yesterday filed an affidavit in the High Court saying that its board of directors was not agreeable to a suggestion put by the division bench for re-bidding.

Contacted by this evening, Dalmiya refused to make any comments on the court observation, but added that the working committee of the BCCI would be meeting tomorrow to take stock of the situation.


Meanwhile, some digging by has revealed interesting facts in the run-up to Zee bagging the rights and subsequently ESS contesting BCCI's decision.

From the documents filed in the court, along with an affidavit, the communication dated 6.9.2004 of PriceWaterhouse Coopers (PwC) was allegedly pursuant to a request made by ESS letter dated 6.9.2004. ESS has stated that it has made inquiries with PwC and were categorically informed that the latter only tabulated the bids received and was not required to examine the fulfillment of requirements of condition No 2 by the tenderers.

Interestingly, clause 3.8(a) of the tender document clearly required that the bids were to be finally examined by PwC as to whether the tenderers fulfill the requirements of condition No. 2 of the tender document and only those tenderers whose bid were found to be in due compliance were to be the "qualified tenderers."

It was also pointed out that both these letters are dated 06.09.2004 and that ESS also filed the writ petition on the same day when these two letters were not a part of the original writ petition.

The letters seem to have been exchanged by ESPN Software India Limited, Building No. 22, Pushp Vihar Community Centre, New Delhi, which seems to be a company having no concern with this cricket tender process or with the writ petition before the court.

A point to be noted is that the petitioner is ESPN Star Sports (not ESPN India) and it has stated in the court that it's a registered general partnership under the laws of the US. The petitioner has also said it has a branch office in Singapore by the name of ESPN Star Sports, which is engaged in production and telecasting of sports channels, ESPN and Star Sports in various South Asian countries, including India.

The petitioner doesn't have any office/operations in India, it has been stated in the court. The present petition is filed through one Vijay Rajput, who has been duly authorised to do all things necessary for the present petition.

Several attempts made by to elicit a response from ESPN Software India on the matter proved futile today.

Another interesting fact that has come to light is that though PwC did not charge any remuneration from the BCCI for opening the sealed cricket tender bids and other professional services rendered, the audit firm, respondent No.4 in the writ petition, is the global chartered accountant firm for Disney, the parent company of ESPN. As per the Disney website, the total fees paid by Disney to PwC for rendering professional services in the last one year was approximately $ 25 million.

Latest Reads
Sunny Leone in Discovery JEET’s show Man Vs Wild

Sunny Leone will be displaying her adventurous side as host of the mega-popular survival series Man Vs. Wild. The iconic series will telecast in Hindi on the soon-to-be-launched GEC Discovery JEET. The new GEC will premiere in the second week of February 2018 and the series will feature the...

Television TV Channels GECs
Times Now appoints Sujeet Mishra as marketing head

Times Network, part of India’s media conglomerate, The Times Group today announced the appointment of Sujeet Mishra as head of marketing, Times Now.

Television TV Channels People
Experience space with BBC's new VR experience

The BBC is giving you a chance fly. Home - A VR Spacewalk is an interactive virtual reality (VR) experience launched today for the HTC Vive and the Oculus Rift, and is available to download for free via the Steam Store and the Oculus Store.

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
Sony BBC Earth presents the Best of 2017

Sony BBC Earth revisits some of its most popular episodes of the best shows in a special programming line-up titled Best of 2017 starting 18 December 2017, every night at 7 pm and 11 pm.

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
Increased revenue from traditional media boosts Shemaroo numbers

Integrated media content house Shemaroo Entertainment Limited (Shemaroo) reported 18.3 percent higher year-on-year (y-o-y) consolidated total revenue for the quarter ended 30 September 2017 (Q2 FY 2017-18, the quarter under review) stood at Rs 1,345.7 million as compared with Rs 1,138.6 million in...

Television Production House Film Production
21st CF spins-off into new live news & sports co Fox

MUMBAI: After the blockbuster acquisition of 21st Century Fox by The Walt Disney Company, the former has announced that it will spinoff into a new brand Fox’ that will seek to replicate its own success in the newly focussed verticals of live news and sports brands. Using fiscal 2017 as a base, the...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
With Star India, Disney emerges as India's largest M&E firm

MUMBAI: Unlike the US, where the merger of The Walt Disney Co and 21st Century Fox’s entertainment assets is between two near equals, the scenario in India is totally different. 21st Century Fox’s India venture Star India is a $1.7 billion dollar media and entertainment behemoth while Disney India...

Television TV Channels People
Disney to buy 21st Century Fox assets for $52.4 billion

The Walt Disney Co has set up a $52.4 billion, all-stock deal to acquire 20th Century Fox and other entertainment and sports assets from Rupert Murdoch’s empire.

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
MOVIES NOW brings #StopDreamingAndStartWinning with 100 Mania Season 5 for its viewers

Movies Now, India’s english movie channel, rings in the festive season with its property ‘100 Mania’, beginning Friday, 15 December at 9pm. In its 5th season, the channel has curated a line-up of some of the biggest Hollywood blockbusters like Furious 7, Jurassic World, Disney’s The Jungle Book,...

Television TV Channels English Entertainment

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories