PPL, broadcasters head for showdown over music copyright

MUMBAI: The Phonographic Performance Ltd (PPL) is threatening to take broadcasters to court over what they term rampant copyright infringement by television channels and it is certainly not music to anybody's ears.

PPL, the copyright society that administers broadcasting and public performance rights of its member-companies' sound recordings, has alleged that that except for NDTV and Sahara, none of the broadcasters have obtained a licence from it to air copyrighted musical properties.

Talking to, Phonographic Performance Ltd. CEO Vipul Pradhan alleged that broadcasters have been simply ignoring the organisation's repeated requests to obtain licences for using the musical properties owned by PPL's member-companies.

According to Pradhan, if in a TV serial, for example, during a religious scene a holy song is being played from a popular film, then a licence needs to be obtained for doing so.

"Now, the broadcaster who airs the show would argue that the onus of obtaining the copyright for the song played is on the production house. But, according to the law, it is the other way around. A broadcaster should be making sure that the production house has obtained a licence before airing the show," explained Pradhan, adding that PPL is contemplating legal action.

That's not how Sony Entertainment Television sees it though. When asked to respond to PPL's charges, a company spokesperson said, "Producers of our shows have the onus to take responsibility for obtaining all the relevant permissions. We have adequate checks and balance in place to help ensure we always comply with relevant regulations. SET is a law-abiding organisation and always supports the music and entertainment industry."

Pointing out that the onus of acquiring a licence lies on the user, not on the copyright holder, Pradhan said that PPL had been making all possible efforts to open up a constructive dialogue with broadcasters, but in vain for the last 18 months.

He alleged that the broadcasters were "simply refusing" to even have a meeting with representatives of PPL.

"Broadcasters are aware of the copyright rules, but have been carrying on under the impression that the law won't take its course. They have been giving silly excuses too. So fed up are we that we are planning to file cases against the broadcasters," Pradhan hits out against TV channels.

How does the licensing work? There is a show-based licence scheme. This allows an organisation to use musical properties for a particular show. Here, the cost is based on the number of clippings used for a show. According to PPL, per clipping is priced at Rs 25,000. If bulk buying is done, then the rates come down.

Surprisingly, though there is a provision for a 'blanket licence', enabling unlimited usage of clipping(s), PPL couldn't provide the price for such a licence, saying that the figure would change according to an organisation's requirement. "The international norms suggest that, a certain percentage of the organisation's revenue should be paid to the licensing authority as the licence fee for the musical property the organisation uses," is what PPL offered on this matter.

PPL feels that big broadcasters like Star and Sony Entertainment TV, which have an international presence, should be obtaining a blanket licence. PPL trades clippings to news channels at reduced rate as they are non-entertainment in nature and requirements are less.

What is interesting here is that the Indian Performing Right Society Limited (IPRS), which owns the copyrights of literary musical and dramatic works, has joined issue with the broadcasters on similar lines to that adopted by PPL.

It too, has alleged that some media organisations have been irresponsibly using properties copyrighted with them without obtaining proper licence.

"Some broadcasting companies have been behaving as if they have rights to violate the copyright rule," IPRS CEO Rakesh Nigam told Though, the organisation, unlike PPL, does not have any immediate plans to take legal recourse, it would be providing all possible co-operation to PPL on the issue.

"Right now, we are observing the developments. We have a strong case and will wait for a proper time to move the courts," warns Nigam.

What do some other broadcasters have to say about the whole thing, which also had its echo when private FM radio stations were set up?

Essel Group corporate brand development head Ashish Kaul said that nobody has contacted Zee Telefilms till date on the issue of licences to be obtained for musical properties where the copyright lies elsewhere. "We are completely unaware of the whole issue," he added.

When contacted, an executive from the Star India too, said that the company hasn't received any official communication from PPL regarding a case or licences to be obtained for copyright material.

"Without knowing exactly what PPL's allegations are, we can't comment further on this issue. We could take a stance after getting a clear picture of the allegations being made by PPL," the Star executive added.

As the tussle goes on in the industry, PPL's Pradhan said that while action is likely to be initiated against bigger companies, an education campaign would be started for smaller organisations, like cafes, restaurants and hotels, which also violate copyright rules.

Latest Reads
Cosmos-Maya’s next international co-production is a spin-off series of the much talked about 3D Animation feature film Leo da Vinci: Mission Mona Lisa

is another high quality 3D animation international co-production - a spin-off series based on the recently released film Leo da Vinci: Mission Mona Lisa.

Television TV Channels Kids
EPIC TV & Penguin Present The Third Book Of The Devlok With Devdutt Pattanaik Series

Where did the name Radha come from? When did Christianity first come to India? What is the connection between sanskar and dharma? After the enormous success of the first two books in the ‘Devlok with Devdutt Pattanaik’ series, India’s favourite mythologist, Devdutt Pattanaik, is back with a third...

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
Banijay Asia and Salman Khan TV collaborates to create content for digital and tv

World’s largest independent content creation group, Banijay Group recently entered Indian & South East Asian market under the guidance of Deepak Dhar with an aim to produce content across genres. Banijay Asia &SK TV, which was launched few years back, come together to create novel and...

Television TV Channels GECs
DSport reaches 110 mn households in a year

DSport, the sports TV channel by Discovery Communications, has achieved the milestone of reaching 110 million households in India. The channel was launched on 6 February 2017 and achieved the milestone within one year of operations in India and has expanded its distribution across all DTH and...

Television TV Channels Sports
Star Suvarna to telecast 'Kannadada Kotyadhipati 2018' the Kannada version of 'Who wants to be a Millionaire' as part of its revamp

May 21, 2018: The third season of Kannadada Kotyadhipati, the Kannada version of ‘Who wants to be a Millionaire’, which sets the stage for a revamps of Star Suvarna, the Kannada GEC channel of Star Network will premiere in June’18. Since January 2018, the channel has gained viewership share in...

Television TV Channels Regional
Republic Network partners with CAF India to nurture the Culture of Giving amongst Indians as part of its first year celebration.

Republic TV, India’s number 1 English news channel for non-stop 53 weeks is celebrating its milestone first year anniversary in a unique and special way. Republic TV has partnered with Charities Aid Foundation (CAF) India, a not for profit organisation to fuel and accelerate the spirit of giving...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
Star spending up to Rs 2 cr on production per IPL match

MUMBAI: After having bought rights for almost all important sporting properties in India, Star India had the massive task to ensure that it sets a new benchmark for cricket. In February, it won the audio-visual production rights for IPL 2018, making it the first time that a broadcaster is...

Television TV Channels Sports
Watch Rani Mukerji’s ‘Dadasaheb Phalke Excellence Award’ winning performance in ‘Hichki’ only on Sony MAX

After garnering success at the box office and a heart-warming response from the audience, the Rani Mukerji starrer ‘Hichki’ is all set for its Worldwide Television Premiere only on Sony Pictures Networks’ number 1 Hindi movie channel, Sony MAX on Saturday, 26th March at 9pm. Directed by Siddharth...

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
World Television Premiere of Raid on Star Gold

This May, Star Gold to bring the World Television Premiere of Raid. Touted as first Bollywood project to be based on an Income Tax raid, this Ajay Devgn starrer hit will be showcased on 27th May 2018, Sunday at 1 PM on Star Gold.

Television TV Channels Movie Channels

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories