Dyke hits out at Hutton, says report full of errors

MUMBAI: Any hopes that 10 Downing Street may have harboured that Gerg Dyke, dubbed "Tony's Crony" when he took the reins at the BBC four years ago, would quietly ride away into the sunset look certain to be dashed.

A day after he quit as BBC director-general, Dyke, who'd said his resignation should draw the line under the Kelly affair as far as the rest of the BBC top management were concerned, fired his first salvo.

Speaking on BBC radio and GMTV television, Dyke said he did not accept all of Lord Brian Hutton's report into the death of weapons expert David Kelly, saying it was lacking in balance and tainted with errors.

"I would be very interested to see what other law lords looking at Hutton thought of it. There are points of law in there in which he is quite clearly wrong," Dyke said.

Dyke said he agreed with the departing BBC chairman, Gavyn Davies, that one could not "choose the referee" and had to accept his decision, but quipped: "The government did choose the referee."

Dyke also blasted prime minister Tony Blair's former spokesperson and chief spinmaster Alastair Campbell, calling him "remarkably ungracious" for the tenor of his comments in a series of interviews that he gave yesterday. A clearly gloating Campbell stated he had always told the truth and that he had been vindicated by Hutton.

Vindicated by Hutton maybe, but certainly but not so by the British public. A YouGov poll in the Daily Telegraph found that 56 per cent of Britons believed Hutton's report was a "whitewash", and that 67 per cent trusted BBC journalists compared with 31 per cent who trusted Blair's government.

The public response to the whole sorry affair as well as the outpouring of spontaneous support that came from across the rank and file of the BBC might well explain the combative stance that Dyke has taken the "morning after typhoon Hutton" left the Beeb desperately trying to find its bearings again. Dyke's resignation triggered walkouts and demonstrations by hundreds of BBC staff around Britain.

A comment made last night by John Tusa, the former head of BBC World Service, and reported in The Guardian is relevant in this context. Tusa has been quoted as saying he believed the government's satisfaction with resignations at the top of the BBC could backfire.

Tusa noted that Dyke had offered an apology on Wednesday when the Hutton report came out, but that he had backtracked on Thursday, questioning the governors' decision to offer an unreserved apology for the way the corporation handled the Kelly affair.

"If I were the government, I would say this is an argument which is not going to go away, because the two most dangerous men involved are out there and they have got an argument to make," Tusa was quoted by The Guardian as telling BBC2's Newsnight.

Latest Reads
Cartoon Network Enterprises’ new Back to School collection

To kickstart their new school semester, kids can now flaunt and stock up the coolest & cutest school essentials! Cartoon Network Enterprises (CNE), the global licensing and merchandising division of Turner India, brings to kids a brand new Back-to-School collection at offline and online retail...

Television TV Channels Kids
Summer of fun and excitement with india’s no 1 kids entertainment destination - Nickelodeon

India’s leading kids’ entertainment franchise Nickelodeon has kids beat the summer heat with a host of exciting and fantastic entertainment spread of new movies and new episodes starring favorite Nicktoons. Adding to the excitement are interesting and once in a life time opportunities for kids to...

Television TV Channels Kids
Zee Anmol retains leadership in GEC (U+R) in week 20

Star Plus and Star Utsav swapped their sixth and seventh positions in Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) data of week 20 of 2018 in the Hindi GEC (U+R) market, whereas in rural markets no changes were observed as compared to the previous week. Sony Sab and Star Bharat exchanged their...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Karnataka election helps news channels increase ratings

The general news channels witnessed a spike in the ratings because of the Karnataka elections. Aaj Tak led the chart in all three Hindi news markets, as per Broadcast Audience Research Council’s (BARC) week 20 ratings for 2018. English news genre doubled its ratings in week 20 and Republic TV...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Applause Entertainment and Sudhir Mishra hold Ronit Roy, Tisca Chopra and Parvin Dabas, ‘Hostage’

Applause Entertainment, the content studio from the Aditya Birla Group brings its audiences a premium drama series that will be a bolt from the blue. ‘Hostages’ is a potent conspiracy thriller fueled by several twists, strong performances and sharp direction. ‘Hostages’ brings together a stellar...

Television TV Channels GECs
ITV Network readies Punjabi music channel

MUMBAI: All the Punjabi music lovers have a new destination to groove to the bhangra. ITV Network is launching a new music channel P Tunes. A source close to the development confirmed the news and revealed that the channel will be launched next month. “There will be two channels, HD which will be...

Television TV Channels Music and Youth
Eros International profit margins up in FY 2018

BENGALURU: The Sunil Lulla-led Indian film and media company Eros International Media Ltd (Eros) saw EBITDA for the quarter ended 31 March 2018 (FY 2018, year, fiscal under review) of Rs 328.21 crore and a margin of 34.2 per cent of operating revenue, about 985 basis points more than the margin of...

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
Zee Cinema to air the World TV Premiere of the family entertainer Pad Man on Saturday, 26th May at 8PM

The people who are crazy enough to think they can change the world are the ones who do. A movie that dared to break stereotypes and talk about a tabooed topic, Pad Man was instrumental in creating a platform to discuss female hygiene in the country. Helmed by the celebrated director R Balki, Pad...

Television TV Channels Movie Channels
TV Today board recommends 45% dividend; numbers up

The board of directors of TV Today Network Ltd (TVTN) has recommended a dividend of Rs 2.25 (45 per cent) per equity share of face value of Rs 5 each for the financial year ended 31 March 2018 (FY 2018, year, fiscal under review). The company has reported 10.7 per cent growth in consolidated total...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories