After Davies, BBC D-G Dyke too stands down

MUMBAI: Heads continue to roll at the BBC in the wake of yesterday's damning findings by Lord Hutton in his investigation into the death of weapons expert Dr David Kelly.

Director-general Greg Dyke is the latest casualty in the deepening crisis at the BBC. Dyke's decision to step down owning up moral responsibility for the mess the venerated British institution is in follows BBC chairman Gavyn Davies' resignation on Wednesday, shortly after the law lord's report was published.


Hutton's report, which exonerated the British government almost wholesale of "sexing up" its Iraq weapons dossier with unreliable intelligence while at the same time "tarring and feathering" the UK pubcaster, is widely regarded as being a whitewash to save Tony Blair.

The departure of both the BBC chairman and director-general leaves the corporation rudderless at a time when calls have been growing for the BBC to come under outside regulation.

Greg Dyke: 2nd big BBC fall guy

An emotional Dyke told reporters he hoped their departures meant "a line can be drawn under this whole episode".

The pair quit after the most serious claims in Andrew Gilligan's BBC's reports were branded "unfounded". However, Downing Street made it clear it was still unsatisfied with the resignations and has said it still believes the BBC should apologise for broadcasting a "false allegation".

Hutton in his report criticised as "defective" BBC editorial controls over defence correspondent Andrew Gilligan's broadcasts on the Today programme.

Leaving after four years in his post, Dyke said his position had been compromised by Hutton's criticisms of BBC management. Dyke's decision to go came after BBC governors spent Thursday morning in crisis talks in London.

"My sole aim has been to defend the BBC's editorial independence and act in the public interest," Dyke has been quoted as saying.

He said the resignations of himself and Davies, as well as his apology for the mistakes in Gilligan's broadcasts about the weapons dossier, gave the "opportunity for a new start".

Dyke has said it would be for the governors to decide how to respond to Downing Street's demands for an apology.

The most important thing about the corporation was its audiences, Dyke argued. "The preservation of the BBC per se is irrelevant unless we have the trust of the public out there," he said.

Dyke's deputy, Mark Byford, has been appointed as acting director-general until a successor is chosen.


The future of the BBC head of news Richard Sambrook still hangs in the balance though, with many expecting that his resignation would follow before the day was out.

It was Davies who took the first hit yesterday and in his resignation statement said that as the man at the top he had to take responsibility. But he questioned whether Hutton's "bald conclusions" on the dossier's production could be reconciled with the balance of the inquiry's evidence. And he asked whether enough weight was given to Dr Kelly's taped conversation with Newsnight's Susan Watts.

But Davies added that Dr Kelly was a credible witness whose views the public had a right to know.

Ex-BBC chairman Sir Christopher Bland warned earlier on Thursday against mass resignations and called for a period of reflection at the corporation.

Sir Christopher said it was right to accept Lord Hutton's central criticisms that Gilligan's original story was "unfounded" and that the BBC's governors failed to mount a proper investigation.

But he said: "It is legitimate to question whether Hutton was even-handed in the way he treated on the one hand politicians, civil servants and the security services, and on the other hand the standards of conduct he applied to journalists and broadcasters.

"There is a curious imbalance in that he whitewashed the Government, and maybe he was right to do that, but he tarred and feathered the BBC and there just seems to be a real imbalance in his treatment."


September 2002: Government produces dossier about alleged Iraqi weapons of mass destruction, including claim they could be deployed within 45 minutes

May 2003: BBC Today programme's Andrew Gilligan broadcasts report of claims Downing Street "sexed up" dossier, with 45 mins claim included against intelligence agencies' wishes

10 July 2003: Dr David Kelly named as suspected source of report as government continues to deny the story

17 July 2003: Dr Kelly found dead

August 2003: Hutton begins six weeks of hearings about the circumstances around Dr Kelly's death

In his long-awaited report, Hutton said he believed Dr Kelly had killed himself after being named as the suspected source of the BBC's controversial weapons dossier story.

Dr Kelly's family, meanwhile, urged the government to learn from their tragedy.

Conservative leader Michael Howard said there was a stark contrast between Dr Kelly and "the cabal of ministers and advisers ... who were so obsessed by the war with the BBC that they gave scant attention to his welfare".

Liberal Democrat Charles Kennedy called for an independent inquiry, saying: "The report necessarily leaves unanswered the most fundamental question of all, and that question is, of course, the basis upon which this country went to that war in Iraq. We are still no closer to determining whether this country went to war on a false prospectus."


And that seems to be the view of the general public as well. Much of the British the public thinks the Hutton report was a "whitewash" and that it is unfair the BBC has to shoulder all the blame for the death of David Kelly, a poll by the London Evening Standard done a few hours after the report was released.

The first major survey of the British people's reaction to Lord Hutton's verdict has uncovered widespread scepticism, with 56% of people saying the judge had been unfair to heap most of the blame on the corporation.

Exactly half of those questioned on the Hutton report by pollsters NOP for the Evening Standard said they found its conclusions unconvincing, while 49% said it was a whitewash.

A separate poll carried out by Sky News provided even more dramatic figures, with 67% saying no to the question "Has the Hutton inquiry got to the truth?".

What is the most incredible aspect of this whole affair though, is that Hutton did not deem it fit to have even a half way passing criticism of the actions of the "Blair Rich Project" spinmaster-in-chief Alastair Campbell (the British PM's then press secretary).

To quote a comment by Richard Ackland in "We also know that Alastair Campbell had his hands all over the September 24 document. He oversaw 14 changes to the dossier before the Government presented it as the justification for war. What's a PR man doing in the bowels of this operation if it is not to sex it up a bit?"

Hutton, meanwhile, has announced an "urgent investigation" into the leaking of his findings which appeared in the government cheerleader The Sun newspaper ahead of his statement. Going by the whitewash job his "lordship" did for 10 Downing Street, the government should come out of this one also smelling like roses. That is assuming he will be the one heading the investigation of course.

Latest Reads
Star Movies presents 'Films To See...' every weekday starting 7 Nov

Star Movies Select HD has been staying true to its promise of impeccable curation by showcasing the best. Star Movies sets standards of storytelling high inspiring a lot of others to try and re-invent the art of movie showcasing business.

Television TV Channels English Entertainment
Q2-17: Zee Media operating profit up

BENGALURU: The Essel Group’s news network Zee Media Corporation Limited (ZMCL) reported more than double (2.47 times) year-over-year (y-o-y) operating profit (Simple EBIDTA) for the quarter ended 30 September 2016 (Q2-17, current quarter) . The company reported EBIDTA of Rs 18 crore (14.3 per cent...

Television TV Channels GECs
National Geographic Channel to undergo major rebranding

MUMBAI: Come 14 November and the National Geographic Channel will have a new shortened sobriquet. The word channel will disappear from its name and it will be simply known as National Geographic and a new tagline “Further.” The change is expected to take place simultaneously across all the 445...

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
Maha Cartoon targets 65 per cent rural HSM via DD FreeDish, 2000 LCOs

Who can forget the Charlie Chaplin show which entertained the world audience of all ages. Maha Cartoon, the first free-to-air (FTA) Hindi cartoon channel targeted at the Hindi-speaking markets (HSM), will be launched on India's largest DTH platform DD FreeDish on 1 November. The new Maha Cartoon...

Television TV Channels Kids
Vikram Chandra steps down; KVL Narayan Rao is new NDTV group CEO

The rumours that were making rounds of Vikram Chandra quitting NDTV have now been put to rest.

Television TV Channels People
Naagin helps Colors capture top position this week: BARC

Backed by Naagin Season 2, Colors was almost close to Star Plus to get the number one position, but, this week, Colors went few steps ahead and grabbed the leadership position and replaced Star Plus in week 42. Even in Urban GECs market, Colors toppled Star and took over the number one position.

Television TV Channels Viewership
SPN India to broadcast Barclays ATP World Tour finals

Sony Pictures Networks India (SPN) will exclusively broadcast the upcoming ATP events in the month of November. The ATP 1000 Paris Masters will be aired live on Sony ESPN channels and will be streamed live on SonyLIV app and website. The ATP 1000 Paris Masters in Paris will begin on 31 October.

Television TV Channels Sports
Hunt for Zee Business head continues

MUMBAI: Zee Business, an arm of Zee Media Corporation, has seen several transitions in its management this year. The channel was initially headed by Amish Devgan, who decided to move away after serving for 14 years. It was then led by Zee Media Corporation’s then CEO for content Samir Ahluwalia,who...

Television TV Channels People
'King' content will take over monopolistic media entities, says Arnab Goswami

NEW DELHI: The future of news lies in breaking away from the interdependence of politicians and the media on each other.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories