Cable TV

SC reserves judgment in Star-Siti HITs case

NEW DELHI: The two-judge bench of Santosh Hegde and B P Singh today reserved a judgment on a special leave petition (SLP) filed by Star last Saturday with the Supreme Court, appealing against an order given by the MRTPC last week.

The MRTPC, petitioned by Siti Cable and ASC Enterprises, had said that till the next date of hearing on 10 September, Star, Sony and ESPN-Star Sports should continue making their signals available to the HITS platform promoted by ASC, which is part of media baron Subhash Chandra's empire.

After a marathon hearing that began before noon and lasted several hours, the judges Hegde and Singh, reserved their judgment, implying that they would write the order at a later date. Both the petitioners and the respondents expect an early direction from the apex court on the case.

However, the apex court did not give any interim relief to the petitioners, which was expected since Siti Cable-ASC Enterprise's HITS platform has already been soft-launched and is providing signals to some subscribers of Star and Sony.

Sony, which had refrained from appealing against the MRTPC order, also joined issues through an SLP yesterday that was clubbed with Star's and heard today. The decision was taken as Sony was already a respondent in the case filed by Siti Cable-ASC Enterprises with the MRTPC.

Former finance minister and lawyer P Chidambaram represented Star, while Sony's lawyer was Ashok Desai. Congress MP and lawyer Kapil Sibal represented Siti Cable-ASC Enterprises.

According to information available with, Star and Sony's argument revolved around the fact that the MRTPC observation on creation of a monopoly is not valid as they don't have any commercial agreement with ASC Enterprises.

Since no contractual agreement exists between ASC Enterprises and the broadcasting companies, the question of providing the channels' signals to the HITS project does not arise, the petitioners contended today at the hearing. Sibal argued that the Siti-ASC combine was executing what had been permitted by the government, and agreements existed between the channels and Siti Cable.

However, Chidambaram said, through HITS-based transmission Siti wanted to wipe out the control of the content provider over the subscriber base and was behaving as if it was the owner of the signals even when it had no agreement with Star for transmission through HITS.

Several references to CAS were also made during the hearing that lasted almost till 4 pm. It was argued that in the wake of CAS being deferred in Delhi and its future uncertain elsewhere, the HITS project has lost its relevance - a line of argument that was hotly contested by Sibal.

Sibal also contended that Star is promoting its cable company Hathaway in cable operations and therefore wanted to create a monopoly situation by denying Siti the signals of major channels. Star holds a 26 per cent stake in Hathway.

Latest Reads
Competition regulator okays Goldman Sachs stake purchase in Den Networks

Investment banking major Goldman Sachs has received the Competition Commission's approval to increase its stake in Den Networks to over 24 per cent by acquiring additional shares through preferential allotment route.

Cable TV Multi System Operators
DAS petitions challenging constitutional provisions listed for 3 November

With the division bench taking cognisance of several cases relating the digital addressable system (DAS) Phase III which challenge constitutional provisions, the Delhi High Court will hear the DAS cases on 3 November, 2016

Cable TV DAS
MSOs finally cross 1000 as pan-India DAS deadline nears

With less than three months to go for the deadline of the final phase which will complete cable digitlization all over the country, the total number of multi-system operators has finally crossed 1000 with 774 getting provisional licences till 30 September 2016.

Cable TV Multi System Operators
Several DAS III petitions may be transferred to Division Bench of Delhi High Court

NEW DELHI: The Digital Addressable System (DAS) Phase III legal wrangle is moving on, albeit slowly and steadily.  Lawyers appearing on behalf of the multi-system cable TV operators (MSO) will inform a single-judge bench of the Delhi High Court about a large volume of cases relating to DAS III...

Cable TV DAS
Going a la carte with Star and Indiacast has helped: Bibhu Prasad Rath

Bhibu Rath heads one of the small regional cable TV players in the TV distribution business: Ortel Communications. The MSO began as a local player in the state of Odisha. But, it has since spread into neighboring states such as Chattishgarh, West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. In fact, it...

Cable TV Multi System Operators
Bihar govt trebles cable TV entertainment tax to Rs 50

Even as the government is working on subsuming entertainment and other incidental taxes into a goods and service tax (GST) which would be around 18 per cent, cable TV subscribers in Bihar are about to be delivered a blow to their wallets.

Cable TV Multi System Operators
DEN seeks Goldman Sachs investment nod from shareholders

MUMBAI: Leading Indian multisystem cable TV operator (MSO) DEN Networks –promoted by Sameer Manchanda- which got its board’s nod to issue another 1.58 crore shares at a price of Rs 90 per share to existing investor Goldman Sachs is now seeking shareholder approval for the same through an...

Cable TV Multi System Operators
NXT Digital-InCable merger gets shareholder nod; D’Silva bemoans lack of ecosystem support

MUMBAI: Hinduja Ventures Ltd’s (HVL’s) proposal to demerge its NXT Digital headend in the sky (HITS) business from its subsidiary Grant Investrade Ltd (GIL) and merge it into its cable TV MSO offshoot Indusind Media & Communications Ltd (IMCL) got the thumbs up from its shareholders at its...

Cable TV Multi System Operators
Comcast to launch wireless service using Verizon

Here is good news for all Comcast subscribers. The US cable giant’s chief executive Brian Roberts has announced the launch of a wireless service by mid-2017. It plans to create a service that would run on its 15 million WiFi hotspots and use Verizon's wireless network through a deal struck in 2011...

Cable TV Multi System Operators

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories