Cable TV

Cable trade says HC backs their stand on monthly subscriptions

MUMBAI: The legal authorities in Mumbai have their hands full with the various petitions and public interest litigations (PILs) which have been filed by politicians, cable trade and consumer activist groups. Politicians and consumers have moved court to restrain cable operators from arbitrary disconnections and for withholding revenues from government.

However, Mumbai's cable trade has obtained a recent ruling from the Mumbai High Court which counters consumer groups and politicians' threats. The ruling clarifies that the disputes can only be settled in consumer courts or in the form of a commercial dispute in a court. There is no question of any police intervention unless there is a breach of law, say the cable operators.

Two petitions, one from the Consumer Action Network and the other from the Mumbai Cable Operators Federation, came up for hearing before a division bench of the Mumbai High Court comprising chief justice CL Thakkar and Dr Dhananjay Chandrachud on Friday, 28 February.

Consumer Action Network (CAN), a city based consumer group filed a public interest petition in the Mumbai High Court. The PIL challenged the validity of the arbitrary hike in the subscription fees made by the cable operators and has asked for a freeze in the rates charged by them.

Speaking to indiantelevision.com, CAN president Ahmad M Abdi states: "On 28 February, the division bench of the Mumbai High Court merely reiterated the Supreme Court pronouncements from time to time guaranteeing citizens of the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19 1a of the constitution of India. This right is meaningless if the cable operators switch off the connections arbitrarily and hold the city to ransom. Those who pay must get a right to watch and the government can decide what the rates should be!"

On the other hand, the Mumbai Cable Operators Federation (MCOF) filed a civil petition seeking a uniform law and detailed guidelines for all the constituents of the cable trade - broadcasters, MSOs (multi-system operators), cable operators and consumers.

MCOF advocate Ashok Saraogi says: "The petition questions the way in which broadcasters have increased their bouquet prices. It also questions how pay channels continue to obtain advertisements."

On 22 February 2003, the MCOF had obtained an order from Justice SS Parkar and VJ Tahilramani stating that consumers and politicians cannot initiate police action against cable operators for refusing to lower monthly cable rates.

MCOF lawyer Saraogi says: "The court observed that there is no instance of police taking action for disconnecting services due to non-payment of charges. We petitioned that the government should collect the taxes directly from the consumers or give some authoritative powers to the cable operators to empower them to collect entertainment taxes from the consumers."

"On 22 February 2003, the bench had also ruled that the operators were free to disconnect services when the consumers refused to pay the charges. It accepted that there are no clear-cut guidelines on the MRP (market retail price) for cable services. We can afford to show the free-to-air channels at Rs 150 per month," maintains MCOF president Nandan Basu.

MCOF committee member Shafiq Butt adds: "We took a copy of the 22 February 2003 ruling and presented it to Mumbai's police commissioner and other police stations in the areas where we operate."

The MCOF has also taken legal opinion on whether they could be liable for action under the various IPC sections as threatened by BJP member of parliament (MP) Kirit Somaiya who is gunning for the television trade. They have found out that the disputes between the cable trade and consumers can only be settled in consumer courts or as a commercial dispute in a court.

In February 2003, Somaiya had filed a criminal, cognizable, civil complaint against the various constituents of the cable business in Maharashtra - MSOs (multi system operators), independent cable operators and broadcasters.

"The complaints are slated to be filed under various acts including IPC under section 420 (cheating), 406, 441 and 447. The charges include threatening consumers; collecting taxes and not depositing the same with the concerned authorities. This constitutes cheating and exploitation of consumers under the MRTP," Somaiya had said as that point of time.

Somaiya can, however, initiate proceedings against the cable trade for not depositing the service taxes collected from the consumers in the government kitty. 

The MCOF lawyer Saraogi counters this by saying that the liability of paying the taxes rests with the citizens or TV viewers. "Show me one receipt which shows that cable operators have collected taxes from the consumers. Consumers refuse to pay these taxes and cable operators end up collecting their charges - that too with great difficulty," adds Saraogi.

Things will become clear two weeks from now when the government's advocate, including Maharashtra's advocate general Ghulam Vahanvati, responds to the various petitions.

Also read:

Cable ops restrained from enforcing more blackouts 

Consumer body PIL seeks to plug cable TV rate hike before July 2003

BJP MP Kirit Somaiya to file criminal case against TV trade...

Mumbai's small cable ops raise cudgels against MSOs, pay channels 

Latest Reads

http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/08/11/gtpl.jpg?itok=Ab3NPOIV
GTPL Hathway revenue up for Q1

Indian multi-system operator and internet service provider GTPL Hathway Limited (GTPL) reported 15.7 per cent increase in total income for the quarter ended 30 June 2018 (Q1 2019, quarter or period under review) as compared to the corresponding year-ago quarter  (y-o-y) Q1 2018.

Cable TV Local Cable Operators
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/07/04/Jio.jpg?itok=rZUvEat1
Jio & Hathway continue to lead wireless and wired Internet subs growth in 2018

India witnessed 1.74 percent growth in broadband internet customers in the month of April 2018 (Apr-18, month under review) according Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) data for the month ended 30 April 2018. Hence, 71.90 lakh (7.19 million, 0.719 crore) broadband subscribers were added...

Cable TV Local Cable Operators
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/07/03/hathway.jpg?itok=ia1s4x4_
Hathway ropes in Sitendu Nagchaudhuri as new CFO

Leading cable operator Hathway Cable and Datacom Ltd has appointed Sitendu Nagchaudhuri as the new chief financial officer (CFO). The fellow chartered accountant?s experience in the field of corporate finance, commercial and strategy leadership spans over 27 years.

Cable TV Multi System Operators
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/22/mike.jpg?itok=d6c4AxlX
Sony to bring Pictures, TV division under one roof

Sony Pictures TV is set to merge international TV operations to bring its television networks, home entertainment and distribution businesses together. This shuffle may lead to some job cuts, with many senior executives from Sony having already departed.

Cable TV Multi System Operators
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/19/en.jpg?itok=seVAZMpN
DEN Network fixed-line b?band biz plan hinges on partnerships & leveraging present infra

MUMBAI: With telcos handing out data at cheap rates in various package sizes under innovative schemes, mobile data consumption has increased rapidly in India in the last few years, while the growth of fixed-line broadband (FLBB) users has been tepid, if not completely static. MSO DEN Networks now...

Cable TV Multi System Operators
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/15/den.jpg?itok=MgrBAraC
DEN aims to convert 10% of SD subscribers to HD in a year

DEN Networks CEO SN Sharma has set a target of converting 10 per cent of its standard definition (SD) subscribers to high definition (HD) within a year.

Cable TV Multi System Operators
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/15/gtpl.jpg?itok=UXtKUTNt
GTPL Hathway appoints Viren Thakkar as new chief financial officer

GTPL Hathway , one of the major players in the Indian cable TV and broadband industry, has appointed Viren Thakkar as chief financial officer of the company. The appointment ,which will come into effect from 2nd July, was posted on the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) website.

Cable TV People
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/13/hathway.jpg?itok=d7ITpv1s
Hathway plans to seed 2.5 lakh high definition set top boxes in FY19

Going along the lines of FY18, broadband and cable TV service provider Hathway Cable and Datacom is planning a Capex of Rs 310 crore in FY19. In addition to that, it plans to seed 2.5 lakh high definition (HD) set top boxes (STB) in FY19. The company had 2.16 lakh HD subscribers at the end of March...

Cable TV Multi System Operators
http://www.indiantelevision.com/sites/default/files/styles/340x340/public/images/tv-images/2018/06/05/gtpl.jpg?itok=pDk34haZ
Jayanta Pani Resigns as CFO of GTPL Hathway

Jayanta Pani chief financial officer (CFO) of GTPL Hathway has decided to part ways with the company. Pani's last working day at GTPL, where he joined in November 2008, will be 30th June.

Cable TV People

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories