Consumer body PIL seeks to plug cable TV rate hike before July 2003

MUMBAI: Consumers are playing safe considering the uncertain circumstances related to the implementation of conditional access system - CAS - in the country. Consumer Action Network, a consumer activist organisation comprising of lawyers, has filed a writ petition by way of Public Interest Litigation in the Bombay High Court today.


CAN is a society registered under the Society Registration Act, 1860 and has its offices in Mumbais Fort area.

The PIL submitted to chief justice CL Thakkar and Dr Dhananjay Chandrachud seeks action from the government - state and Central - forbidding cable trade to increase subscription rates till July 14 July 2003 and also setting up of a regulatory authority empowered to look into the problems of the consumers. The next hearing is slated for Friday 28 February.

CAN has used the constitution of India and the Cable television Networks Regulation amendment bill provisions to strengthen its arguments. The petition also highlights the fact that the inaction on the part of the government has resulted in loss of revenues through tax collections. It has also led to cartelisation of the broadcasters and MSOs.

Meanwhile, CAN officials have decided to start a nationwide agitation and consumer awareness campaign. The following are their demands: freedom of choice for the subscribers; no payments for those channels which consumers dont want to watch; no arbitrary rate hikes till CAS implementation; and a proper regulatory authority with representatives in different parts of the country.

While speaking to, CAN president Ahmad M Abdi states: "Unscrupulous cable operators misguide the ignorant consumers. We have had cases wherein cable operators have threatened to initiate police action against errant consumers. However, the law states that the dispute will be of a commercial nature and police action can take place only if there is violence or some other offence."

CAN representatives contend that cable operators should maintain status quo till the introduction of CAS and adequate guidelines given by the information and broadcasting ministry. They also feel that the cable trade will use this intermediate period to strengthen their bargaining capacity on the eve of introduction of CAS. They also add that they cannot allow the government to sit back and let the cable trade blackmail 200 million TV viewers in the country. They say that there are hints that the monthly cable charges will increase to Rs 350 and Rs 400, up nearly 500 per cent in the last four years.

In the writ petition, CAN mentions that the cable operators are proposing to increase the already high charges by a staggering per cent in the next six months. Even, if the rates were increased by Rs 5, it would cast a burden of Rs 30 billion per annum to the already beleaguered consumers.

"The issue of improper declarations and increase in charges of pay channels by the broadcasters is a dispute between the broadcasters and the cable trade. The poor consumer is suffering in the bargain. We have received numerous complaints related to harassment and arbitrary disconnection. These acts of cable operators are not just unethical and improper but also illegal. Such unconstitutional acts violate the fundamental rights of the consumer as recognised by the Supreme Court in various pronouncements from time to time being part of the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19 1a of the constitution of India," CAN claims.

While CAN officials are demanding a cap on rate hikes, they support CAS saying that it would bring in a lot of clarity. "The consumer must get complete freedom of choice; otherwise the entire purpose of law and technology will be defeated. We have received feedback expressing doubts whether cable trade will provide free-to-air channels to those who are interested in subscribing to the pay channels," adds co-petitioner Kedar Goyal.

This shows that there is a need for a regulatory authority to consider complaints and take timely actions. "Bodies such as Telecom Regulatory Authority of India and Insurance Regulatory Development Authority of India have kept appropriate checks on the new sectors such as telecom and insurance. There are merely six million mobile users in the country as compared to the 200 million cable TV viewers," says Abdi.

Earlier, CAN had initiated action against the telecom authorities demanding number portability. Currently, the cellular subscriber has to surrender his number if he discontinues the services of one particular operator. CAN officials claim that the developed countries have rules which allow a subscriber to continue using the same number despite changing the service operator. CAN officials also state that they will eventually file regarding the adoption of STBs at a later stage because they haven't included the same in this petition.

For the cable trade, it looks as if PILs are simply pouring from all quarters.

Latest Reads
Mumbai Team franchisee owner unable to meet financial obligations towards Zee Maharashtra Kushti Dangal

Mr. Pranav Rajesh Dake, owner of Zee Maharashtra Kushti Dangal’s Mumbai team – Mumbai Astra has regrettably been unable to meet the financial obligations towards Zee Maharashtra Kushti Dangal (ZMKD), its players and technicians.

Television TV Channels Viewership
Zee TV gets ratings boost from Zee Rishtey Awards

Zee TV's recently concluded annual awards property, Zee Rishtey Awards, clocked the highest viewership ratings across award shows that took place in the last two years. As per the recently released BARC HSM weekly data (Urban + Rural) for the week 44 '18, it secured a viewership of 5495 TVTs, which...

Television TV Channels Viewership
No changes in Kannada, Marathi segments in BARC data week 44

In the Bengali space, Colors Bangla and Sony Aath swapped their fourth and fifth positions in BARC data week 44. News18 Bihar Jharkhand emerged as the new player in the market by securing fifth position. No changes were observed in the Kannada and Marathi segments.

Television TV Channels Viewership

Launched on November 19, 2014, EPIC celebrates the completion of four years on air, in which it has set aspirational benchmarks for Indian TV content.

Television TV Channels Music and Youth
Celebrating 100 years of Bengali cinema, Viacom18 and Film Heritage Foundation bring the 4th Film Preservation & Restoration Workshop to Kolkata

In line with the centenary celebration of the Bengali Film Industry, and with a purpose to encourage and give an impetus to film preservation and restoration, the 4th edition of Film Preservation & Restoration Workshop India (FPRWI) 2018 was today inaugurated at Kolkata’s Rabindra Sadan.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
Vimal Elaichi Pan Masala enters top 5 most advertised brands in BARC week 45

The Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) India has released its data for top advertisers and brands between 27 October-02 November 2018. The data is a reflection of top 10 advertiser and brands across genre on Indian television (U+R) : 2+ Individuals. The data demonstrates ads that were...

Television TV Channels Viewership
Zee Anmol back on top of Hindi channels across genres

Zee Entertainment Enterprises Ltd's (Zeel) free to air (FTA) Hindi GEC Zee Anmol was back to second rank in Broadcast Audience Research Council of India’s (BARC) weekly list of top 10 channels across genres in week 45 of 2018 (Saturday, 3 November 2018 to Friday, 9 November 2018, week under review...

Television TV Channels Viewership
MNX to premiere supernatural fright flick, ‘Wish Upon’

MNX, the preferred movie channel of the millennials, will premiere, American supernatural horror film, ‘Wish Upon’ for the first time on Indian television.

Television TV Channels English Entertainment
Hill+Knowlton Strategies India wins communication mandate for Discovery India

After a competitive multi-agency pitch, Hill+Knowlton Strategies, one of India’s premier communications consultancies

Television TV Channels English Entertainment

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories