HC postpones cable case hearing to 23 April

MUMBAI: It was some kind of an anticlimax considering the number of people who had assembled at the Mumbai High Court today!

A division bench of the Mumbai High Court comprising chief justice CL Thakker and Dr DY Chandrachud will hear cable-related petitions on 23 April 2003. Till then, the previous ruling of 7 March 2003 will be applicable despite the fact that the lawyers of the MSOs (multi-system operators) protested that collections have dropped considerably due to the ruling.


Several cable operators, MSO representatives, media and lawyers were eagerly waiting for the court to take up item number 17 in court no 46 of the Mumbai High Court. Lawyer Chaitanya Dhruve Mehta (of Dhruve Liladhar & Co) representing BJP MP (member of parliament) Kirit Somaiya's group started the proceedings by saying that they needed time as three affected parties had filed their responses just yesterday.

Mehta added that the involved parties needed more clarification on the fact that the government-piloted task force on conditional access is likely to recommend to the government a revised rate of Rs 71.33 (exclusive of taxes) as the price of the basic tier, which has the support of a majority of the panel members. The new figure had been put to vote in a task force meeting yesterday in New Delhi.

While speaking to, Mehta says: "Prasar Bharati, Star India and Mumbai Cable Operators Federation (MCOF) president Nandan Basu filed their replies yesterday. We have sought time to study the responses before filing our replies. Also, we expect that the CAS task force will get a fix on the pricing of the free-to-air channels within a week. It would make sense to postpone the hearing till then."

When questioned about the previous order (dated 7 March), Mehta said that it was victory for the consumers who managed to see the cricket World Cup without any disruptions or blackouts by the cable operators."The FTA price of Rs 71.3 plus taxes will work out below the range of Rs 150 per month per subscriber that Kirit Somaiya has been demanding. We shall strive to ensure that the rights of the consumers are protected!"

Consumer Action Network president lawyer Ahmad M Abdi added: "Yesterday's CAS task force recommendation is a new development and we welcome the price of Rs 71.33 per month per subscriber. We are also happy that the High Court has persisted with its earlier order prohibiting arbitrary disconnection. Ever since the hearing has begun, consumers have benefited a lot."

Maharashtra state government additional solicitor-general SB Jaisinghani, representing Doordarshan raised the point about the cable operators indulging in under-declarations. He also added that the government had already given the cable trade a time period of six months starting January 2003 to pave the way for CAS in July 2003.

On 7 March, the court order had accepted one of the petitioner's Seven Star cable's undertaking that there would be no disconnection or stoppage of broadcasting of programmes except in individual cases of nonpayment of regular charges.

However, the order stated that the above statement doesn't prevent arguments on behalf of the MSOs. At that time, Seven Star officials claimed that the above mentioned statement is binding on all the MSOs (multi-system operators) in Mumbai.

However, the counsels of the other MSOs had argued that the decision is binding only on Seven Star (which gave the undertaking) and not necessarily on the other MSOs. They also claim that the existing agreements between the cable operators and the MSOs are still valid. They also point out that Seven Star had already hiked its rates in late 2002 and the trade/consumers had protested against these rate hikes then. Today, lawyers representing MSOs stated that consumers were refusing to pay the new rates applicable from 1 January 2003 due to improper communication and false perceptions. They sought clarifications from the HC on this issue.

The High Court ruling also directed the cable associations named respondents (Mumbai Cable Operators Federation - MCOF - amongst others) to avoid disconnection's as the counsel for the petitioners had served notices and undertook the process of filing affidavit of services.

The other cable associations in the city who are not affiliated to MCOF say that the HC ruling is not binding on them.

All eyes will be on the final decision of the I&B ministry and the subsequent High Court hearing on 23 April 2003.

Latest Reads
US$ 4.5 bn expected from IPL rights; SC recommends accounts scrutiny

The Supreme Court on Friday froze all financial transactions between the BCCI and state cricket associations by directing the apex body not to disburse any funds till it resolves to abide by the Justice RM Lodha panel recommendations on reforms by 3 December . The top court ordered that none of...

Television TV Channels Sports
TVS Tyres is co-presenter for Asian Champions Trophy 2016

Continuing its strong connect with sports, TVS Tyres has associated with Asian Champions Trophy 2016 by becoming the co-presenter. The Asian Champions Trophy is one of the premier hockey tournaments, a much sought after annual international competition promising some great hockey action. This...

Television TV Channels Sports
Q2-17: Zee Learn declares maiden interim dividend

The board of directors of the Essel group’s education company Zee Learn Limited (ZLL) have declared a first time ever dividend of 5 percent per equity share of Re 1 each for the quarter ended 30 September 2016 (Q2-17, current quarter).

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
Whether BARC action can stop unethical practices?

MUMBAI: Can businesses and industries practise their art of selling fairly although they have 'Fair Practices' training during academic courses, workshops and several ISO and other certifications? There seems to be the fear of the lawman, and not the law in India. If the traffic cop is watching,...

Television TV Channels Viewership
TV Superhighway: beIN, Yaddo, AfricaXP have joined us, says Magine CEO Ambuj Goyal

CANNES; Magine has secured partnerships with four of the industry’s most exciting sports, documentary and entertainment content providers. Partnerships with beIN, the international media group and owner of MIRAMAX; Yaddo, the new documentary streaming service headed up by former head of The BBC’s...

Television TV Channels Factual & Documentary
Colors emerges strong on strength of Naagin I & II

MUMBAI: One of the top rated shows Naagin Season 2 helped Colors reach a top-ranking position.

Television TV Channels GECs
Pakistan Broadcasters Association to oppose PEMRA Indian content ban

MUMBAI: The Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) shocked both Pakistan and Indian broadcasters when it issued an order blanking out  all Indian content from Pakistan’s television channels on 19 October.

Television TV Channels GECs
Sony Pix to telecast 'Jurassic World' on 22 October

Sony Pix will take the viewers on a thrilling, adventurous journey with cloned dinosaurs in their Billion Dollar Premiere property. The channel plans to air Jurassic World on 22 October at 1 pm and 9 pm.

Television TV Channels English Entertainment
Sony AXN scripts deal with Pinewood; buys stake in SVOD service Hopster

Folks at Sony Pictures Television (SPT) are in a celebratory mood. Not only has it signed a six-series deal with Pinewood Television but has also acquired a minority stake in the London-based video subscription service for kids content - Hopster.

Television TV Channels English Entertainment

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories