FCC nixes Echostar-DirecTV merger

MUMBAI: The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has rejected the proposed $ 18.5 billion merger between the two largest satellite-television companies in the US, EchoStar Communications Corp. and Hughes Electronics Corp, a subsidiary of General Motors.

In 4-0 ruling issued yesterday, the FCC said the two companies, who together make up 90 per cent of the satellite television market in the US, "have not demonstrated that approval of the transaction will serve the public interest, convenience, and necessity."

In an order designating the application for a full evidentiary hearing before an administrative law judge, the FCC ruled that the likelihood of the merger harming competition in the multichannel video program distribution (MVPD) market outweighs any merger-specific public interest benefits. The FCC found that such a loss of competition within the MVPD market is likely to harm consumers by: (1)eliminating an existing viable competitor in every market; (2)creating the potential for higher prices and lower service quality; and (3) negatively impacting future innovation.

The FCC said the combination of EchoStar and DirecTV would eliminate existing facilities-based intramodal competition and replace it with a proposed "national pricing" plan, which would have to be enforced by regulatory authorities. The FCC said the effect would be to replace facilities-based competition with regulation, which is not consistent with either the Communications Act or with long-standing policy, both of which aim at replacing regulation with free market competition.

The 4-0 vote by the FCC marks a significant defeat for EchoStar chairman Charlie Ergen who had campaigned long and hard to push the deal through.

And waiting in the wings to make another possible run at Hughes's DirecTV unit is News Corp boss Rupert Murdoch whose offer was rejected in favor of Ergen's bid. Murdoch has outmanoeuvred Ergen on all fronts, whether it be lobbying on Capitol Hill or working with key groups across the US to ensure the merger was scuttled.

Just how determined Murdoch has been can be gauged from the meticulously planned grass-roots campaign that he stage-managed covering consumer and minority-interest groups, religious broadcasters and rural educators.

The Wall Street Journal reported that in February, Murdoch, accompanied by two News Corp executives, travelled to the National Religious Broadcasters (NRB) convention in Nashville, Tennesee, to meet group leaders.

The WSJ has quoted Glenn Plummer, chairman of the group as saying that Murdoch, a frequent target of religious broadcasters himself, wanted to impress upon the (NRB) that the pending merger between EchoStar and DirecTV was a monopoly and not in their best interest.

The WSJ reported that before the one-hour meeting broke up, one of the NRB leaders suggested a prayer. The dozen people in the room, including Murdoch, gathered their chairs in a circle and held hands. A prayer was said for Murdoch. Three months later the NRB announced that it was opposing the merger between EchoStar and DirecTV.

However, when quizzed by reporters after the News Corps' annual general meeting on Wednesday whether he would launch a second bid for Hughes' DirectTV if the merger was blocked, Murdoch was quoted as saying: "We have not thought about it, we are certainly undecided."

Still, the merger isn't completely dead. The FCC now must send its opinion on the merger to an administrative law judge for review, and EchoStar and Hughes have said they plan to file an amended proposal within a 30-day window.

And interestingly, an indication of the kind of lobbying at work is the reaction of the Consumer Union which has slammed the ruling. The consumer advocate body has supported the merger the deal in the expectation it would rein in rising cable rates. "It's really startling that the FCC wouldn't lift a finger to help cable customers," Gene Kimmelman, the co-director of Consumer Union's Washington office has been quoted as saying.

The FCC will send its findings to an administrative law judge, before whom EchoStar and DirecTV can make their case. The judge's ruling would then be sent back to the commission for a final vote.

Latest Reads
Comedy Central sets pace for ultimate celebration with over 100 hours of non-stop FRIENDS ultra marathon for its 6th birthday

Birthdays and New Years are great occasions to make resolutions for participating in marathons. However, this is one marathon which calls for hanging up your running shoes and grabbing the best spot in front of the telly with a bowl of munchies to keep you going because, for the first time ever in...

Television TV Channels English Entertainment
U Sports launches India's first ever Multi-Platform Multi-Game E-Sports Championship - U Cypher with MTV

The Indian E-Sports scenario is all set for a major revamp as U Sports, one of India’s biggest sports business companies in association with India’s No. 1 Youth Brand, MTV, announces the premiere of their all new month-long championship, U Cypher with MTV. Premiering today, on 19th January, the...

Television TV Channels Sports
TV ownership increased by 14% in 2017: IRS

After a gap of four years, the Indian Readership Survey (IRS), which documents the growth of the media industry, has been released for 2017. The survey methodology was criticised in 2014 and, therefore, was halted for an upgrade. This time, the sample size has been increased by 34 per cent to 3.2...

Television TV Channels Viewership
CNN-News18 launches 'If I Were FM Challenge'

As part of its Budget programming, CNN-News18 is launching the ‘If I were FM Challenge’. The campaign will encourage viewers to contribute their suggestions for the Union Budget. The channel will run an extensive on-air campaign to promote the same.

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
BBC World News to Broadcast 'China's Chat Girls'

Lele Tao is an internet superstar in China’s $3 billion dollar ‘live streaming’ industry. With more than a million fans she can earn thousands of dollars a day singing, dancing, flirting, or often just chatting into her webcam. Fans buy her virtual gifts which she redeems for cash. In return she...

Television TV Channels News Broadcasting
PKL season 6 and 7 dates announced

The second most watched domestic league in India, Vivo Pro Kabaddi League owned by Mashal Sports and Star India announced the dates of sixth and seventh season.

Television TV Channels Sports
Star Bharat leads Hindi GEC (U+R) in week 2 of BARC ratings

MUMBAI: Star Bharat emerged as the leader in the Hindi GEC (U+R) genre dethroning Zee Anmol according to Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) all India data for week 2 of 2018.

Television TV Channels Viewership
BARC week 2: Aaj Tak leads Hindi News in all three markets

MUMBAI: Republic TV continues its leading streak in the second week of the year as well in BARC All India ratings. News Nation stays in the top five chart in week 2 of 2018 in Hindi News Rural market. Aaj Tak tops the chart again in Hindi News Urban market.

Television TV Channels Viewership
Dsport acquires India rights of tri-nation tournament in SL

Discovery’s sports channel Dsport has acquired the exclusive India broadcast rights of Nidahas Trophy 2018, a tri-nation international T20 tournament involving India, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh. The transaction was facilitated by Lagardère Sports, the global marketing consultant of Sri Lanka Cricket...

Television TV Channels Sports

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories