|
The
Union Cabinet decision this morning to open up print media
to foreign investment has been rah-rahed by industry as
a whole. Some professionals Indian television.com spoke
to were euphoric, while others said they had expected it
to happen. "It's extremely positive," said Mid-Day Multimedia
managing director Tariq Ansari.
"The momentum to allow FDI in print media was too strong,"
said Indian Express Newspapers (Mumbai) CEO & editor-in-chief
Shekhar Gupta. "It was expected. I am not surprised by the
decision," said The Pioneer editor & managing director Chandan
Mitra.
According to sources in The Times of India, its management
had done a volte face on its position on FDI in print media.
Sources say that Bennet Coleman & Co vice-chairman Samir
Jain was in the Mumbai offices and an edit was expected
to be out for tomorrow's edition of the paper welcoming
the decision.
This morning, the English language daily paper had an editorial
entitled "Meddling with the Media" which stated that "both
prime minister Vajpayee and information and broadcasting
minister Sushma Swaraj (who) had promised that the government
would go by the recommendations of the Committee. It is
not clear why they are moving now, and that too surreptitiously,
to thwart its verdict. In adopting this stand, the Vajpayee
government is treading a perilous path of ignoring the principle
of consultation with not just cabinet and parliamentary
committee, but the opposition as well, on matters of national
importance. It is also setting the stage for undermining
the country's security. Indians have long complained that
the western media consistently skewed reporting on terrorism
and its Pakistani connection till the attack on the World
Trade Center. Ironically, this is a lesson that should have
been best understood by a government that claims it has
been hurt by the depiction of its prime minister by an American
news weekly."
The Shobhna Bharatiya headed Hindustan Times has also been
critical of the Union Cabinet decision calling it controversial
saying that "the government decision comes in face of outright
rejection of FDI in print media by a Parliamentary Standing
Committee and stiff opposition from several political parties,
including some ruling NDA constituents."
The Indian Newspaper Society president Pratap Pawar reportedly
has decried the FDI policy saying that it will "sound the
death knell for small and medium newspapers besides badly
affecting the country's large newspapers."
The chairman of the Mathrubumi group of newspapers and vice-president
of the Indian Newspaper Society M P Veerendra Kumar has
also trashed the decision, and has been quoted as saying
"foreign investors will not care what we hold dear. They
will be driven only by commercial considerations. We must
oppose it."
However, financial daily Business Standard editor T N Ninan
has being quoted as saying that that London-based pink paper
Financial Times is extremely eager to pick up an equity
stake in Business Standard Ltd.
On the political front, the Bharatiya Janata Party refused
to comment on the issue, while the Congress (I) and the
Left parties opposed the government's decision. The Congress
(I) spokesperson said the party's position on the 1955 Cabinet
resolution has not changed and that it would take an appropriate
position on it when it comes up before parliament.
The Communist Party of India Marxist said that the government
was playing a dangerous game by handing over the print media
to imperialist forces which have been carrying out a malicious
propoganda. Its spokesperson, Harkishen Singh Surjeet, has
been quoted as saying that it will be harmful for democracy
and would benefit foreign companies and other countries.
The stockmarkets, however, saw a lot of positivity in the
government's decision and pushed up the prices of media
shares such as Navneet Publications (up 11 per cent), Sahara
Media, Mid-Day Multimedia and Tata Infomedia. This despite
the dampening news of industrialist and Reliance Group founder
Dhirubhai Ambani's ill health and hospitalisation.
Click here for more headlines
|