TDSAT-Ad cap: 2nd amicus curiae done, channels turn now

MUMBAI: The second amicus curiae Aman Ahluwalia continued his arguments today in the TDSAT-ad cap hearing. After giving the legal perspective yesterday, today he focused on the commercial implications of the ad cap regulation.

Ahluwalia said that the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has the power to implement licensing under section 11 (1) (a) of the TRAI Act as well as enforcing it on broadcasters through section 7 (11) of the Cable TV Networks (CTN) Act. There is no need for it to choose the CTN act. The TRAI?s procedure may have been faulty but the bench should not strike down the ad cap regulation on account of this.

The bench wondered that when a licence is issued, the terms and conditions need to be read properly, and if the ad cap regulation issued by TRAI adds anything to section 7 (11) of the CTN act, then should it be accepted. The agreement between the licensor and licensee is only for section 7 (11) and if points like clock hour and reporting to TRAI come into the picture, it is in excess of the section.

The bench said that one cannot change, modulate or supplement the terms of the licence. If TRAI had implemented it under sections 11 and 12 of the TRAI Act that address the issue of licensing and advertisements then such problems wouldn?t have come up.

The amicus curiae read out the final draft report of the convergence bill which gives the definition of ?broadcasting services,? as it doesn?t have an exact one. He said that content, distribution and technical components all come under the TRAI act and content and distribution together mean carriage. By reading out reports such as the Nariman report, he chose to interpret broadcasting services to include content.

Ahluwalia then proceeded to the commercial aspects. He told the bench that after reading the code in the UK, he saw that the ad cap may work for GECs while the news channels that have less viewership will be most affected by it. The only way revenue can be raised is either by digitisation when subscription revenue will go up, or by raising advertising rates. However, if subscription rates are jacked up, viewers may not pay, and resort to cord cutting, resulting in lower viewership, and comitantly lower ad revenues as they depend entirely on viewership.

To support his statement, he also produced financial reports of Zee TV and the Sun Network which showed that their ad revenues were high as compared to news channels. Sponsored shows could be a way out for news channels to generated additional revenues but this could turn out to be dangerous as news could become coloured. And thus he suggested that genres should be dealt with differently.

According to him, English news channels will be the most affected because advertisers will start turning the screws on them as viewership will quite likely drop off the cliff. The scenario could improve when DAS is implemented completely all over the country as by then subscription and ad revenues each will contribute equally to a company's top line.

Reading from an Ofcom (independent regulator and competition authority for the UK communications industries) report, he emphasized that TRAI's ad cap regulation needs to be more precise in terms of the number of ads per half an hour, duration of the promos etc. Till DAS isn?t complete, it should not be implemented as, under Article 19 of the Constitution, broadcasters have the right to disseminate information and viewers have the right to receive plurality of information giving them the power to choose.

If the regulation comes into effect now, many smaller news channels may shut down and the existing ones will generate less revenue and hence news could end up being coloured as only a limited number will be left to provide news.

After Ahluwalia concluded, the News Broadcasters Association (NBA) counsel presented the rejoinder. He argued that TRAI?s analysis of the ad cap violations was incorrect.

His second argument was that TRAI has the power to implement the terms and conditions between the licencee and licensor under section 4 A of the Telegraph Act that talks about teleport licences. It cannot implement it on the basis of the uplinking and downlinking policies.

Teleport licences do not mention the CTN act at all and when TRAI is enforcing it on the basis of licensing then its line of reasoning needs to be read in the context of teleport licensing.

The NBA counsel stated that TRAI cannot act against broadcasters under the uplinking/downlinking policy since it falls under the ambit of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting.

During its arguments, TRAI mentioned that broadcasters had suppressed documents related to licensing. The NBA counsel clarified that the data was about OB vans and teleports, which was available in the public domain.

He added that, according to Ofcom, UK channels were allowed ad commercials of 9-12 minutes averaging and not per clock hour. Also, if TRAI were to enforce the ad cap, it should be under the teleport licence under section 4 A of the Telegraph Act.

The NBA will continue its rejoinder tomorrow as well.

Latest Reads
Concept BIU Acquires the Business of Bluebytes

Concept Business Intelligence Unit (Concept BIU), one of India’s leading media monitoring agencies, has acquired the business of Comniscient Group’s Bluebytes News.

MAM Media and Advertising AD Agencies
Pump it up this holiday season with Athleisure Lifestyle

Family bonding is a complex equation given how different people belonging to the same family can turn out to be- their preferences, their tastes and their opinions.

MAM Marketing MAM
Quess Corp launches its first outdoor campaign, ‘’I AM QUESS’’ to expand brand awareness

Quess Corp, India’s leading business services provider, has launched its first outdoor campaign, ‘’I AM QUESS’’ to expand awareness and communicate with its customers directly.

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns
Brands, agencies to rewire approaches using data: CVL Srinivas, WPP

Data. A four letter word that has even the senior most executives sweating and scratching their heads. While it is a small little word, understanding how to use it, is actually very complicated. That’s why  all we’ve been hearing about in the last year is how can brands and agencies leverage the...

MAM Media and Advertising People
Hershey Kisses will now be Made in India

We’ve all been there where we ask our relatives and friends to bring us imported chocolates and candies from their trip abroad. Hershey’s Kisses have always been one such popular chocolate. The chocolates are distinct because of their unique shape and each one is delicately wrapped to make them...

MAM Marketing Brands
Social Kinnect awarded digital mandate of entire Indiabulls Group

Social Kinnect, an Indian independent digital marketing agency, has been awarded the social media mandate of Indiabulls Group. The agency will be responsible for managing the social media platforms of the entire Indiabulls Group umbrella namely - Indiabulls Housing Finance Limited (IBHFL),...

MAM Media and Advertising Account
Grapes Digital to handle digital mandate for Realme smartphones

Realme, an emerging smartphone brand that specialises in providing high quality smartphones has extended its association with Grapes Digital. In addition to the strategic communications mandate, it has also handed over the digital media mandate to the agency. Grapes will now be responsible for...

MAM Media and Advertising Account
Dentsu Aegis Network removes Kartik Iyer & 3 seniors following sexual harassment allegations

Amidst the ongoing #MeToo movement, where several allegations regarding sexual harassment and sexual assault have come to light, the media and entertainment industry isn’t left behind.

MAM Media and Advertising People
Bathsense launches new campaign with Rajkumar Rao

Bathsense is a creation from Asian Paints, and represents the brand’s first complete bathrooms offering in the bath category. Bathsense is a collection of exemplary bath fittings and sanitaryware products that aims to simplify the user’s bathroom life with a host of truly unique features. Coming...

MAM Media and Advertising Ad Campaigns

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories