The long awaited Communications Convergence Bill 2001, which
has far-reaching implications on how the media industry is to
be run in India, is expected to be tabled in parliament on Tuesday,
industry sources say.
According to them, the final version of the bill, which has
gone through a number of modifications, has incorporated a number
of draconian clauses, putting paid to any hopes industry watchers
had that the government might be willing to ease up on its obsession
with controlling and regulating all things in the media domain.
A new element that has been introduced in the final version
is that within the ambit of the high-powered super regulator
- the Communications Commission of India - there will be two
separate bureaux - a carriage bureau and a content bureau.
According to sources, information and broadcasting minister
Sushma Swaraj had been lobbying to get all content, including
that relating to the Internet, under the ambit of the content
bureau. Swaraj wanted communications regulation to be delinked
from the bill, the sources say. The information technology and
communications ministries strongly opposed this pointing out
that it negated the whole concept of convergence. It was after
this that a compromise formula was adopted where there would
be two bureaux.
There is bound to be a great deal of overlap when it comes to
issues of jurisdiction and it remains to be seen how the two
bureaux are going to operate without constantly stepping on
each other's toes.
There are some points to ponder upon though. The content bureau
will be responsible for all issues that come under that head,
including regulation and laws relating to the Internet. Industry
experts also believe that if such strict regulations were put
in place wherein companies are forced to obtain a licence to
transact electronically, it will have an adverse affect on foreign
investments in India. Their reason: why would anyone go through
such complex processes and red tape when they can easily invest
in countries where no such licences or permits are required.
Even as far as the print media goes, the picture is not a happy
one. Reports say an innocuous sounding clause (Chapter 14, 63)
in the bill permits the central government to detain press messages
and articles of all those journalists who are NOT accredited
with the governments PR set-up, and the Press Information Bureau
(PIB).
The clause empowers anyone - central, state or any authorised
officer - to intercept any e-mail, phone conversation or data
transmission of non-accredited journalists on any communication
network (internet, cellular phones).
Service providers will have to monitor and intercept messages
and failure can lead to a sentence of up to seven years.
The final judgment on the bill will however, have to wait till
its tabling. The bill will be piloted by the communications
ministry. If and when the bill does get passed, India will become
only the second Asian country, after Malaysia, to have a Convergence
Bill.
Click for more Headlines