Crossover film makers must retain 'Indianness'


MUMBAI: The panelists at the session on "Films sans frontiers" at Ficci FRAMES 2003 were clear that Indians must make crossover films that had clear, national identity and were rooted in one's own cultural soil without blindly imitating the west. The panelists included speakers: filmmakers Ashutosh Gowariker, Dev Benegal, Ram Madhvani, actor-director Rahul Bose and Robert Jones and moderator Govind Nihalani.


The general consensus was that crossover films can be classified depending on geographical barriers as well as cultural, financial and technological. Crossover doesn't only mean being invited for international film festivals and coming back with a clutch of awards. Crossover films can be rightly described so only when they get distribution in the world market - in the territories of US, Canada and UK which are the big players

With Lagaan getting nominated for last year's Oscar, and Mira Nair's Monsoon Wedding winning the Golden Lion, the question has arisen: are we ready to invade the international market? Are we finally making films that have 'crossed over' or can 'cross over' to the west or the international market?

Nihalani let the field open with Dev Benegal whose two films English August and Split Wide Open had succeeded to make the international market sit up and take notice. Benegal spoke about how it was important to keep the three key ingredients in making a crossover film in mind - story, location and context. He felt that there was no point in being different just for the sake of being different and some differences should be left at just that - differences.

Benegal was of the opinion that the greatest exports of India have neither been IT experts nor any other software technology but our stories and story-telling abilities. He quoted Farrokh Dhondy who feels that "stories are us". He said that our stories have it in them to travel across borders and frontiers. He also reiterated what Shekhar Kapur had

film market is soon going to emerge as the strongest one with the maximum revenue generating capacity. So the next time a Spiderman takes off his mask, he could be an Asian actor! Last but not the least, he said that our stories are the true frontiers and they also are sans frontiers.

Next in line was Ram Madhvani whose debut film Let's Talk created quite a stir recently in the film market with is unique approach. Madhvani's talk also was very unique in the sense that be begun his speech with a smart one-liner, 'Am I making a film for Goregaon (a suburb in Mumbai city) or GOREgaon (as in the village of the fair-skinned)?' He also felt that 'If Shekhar can, then why can't I?'

Madhvani cited examples of how Indian cuisine has traversed the globe with great success and that it could be replicated with our films too. He raised a few questions like if our food has traveled from ethnic cheap to designer chic then why can't our cinema tread the same path? Can we ever be mainstream or just remain art-house cinema? At the end of it though he still felt that sitting in Goregaon one could still make a film that appealed to GOREGAON or the village of the fair-skinned.

Rahul Bose made a passionate speech keeping certain ground realities in mind. He for one described a truly crossover film as one which crosses over into the major markets of the world and by that he meant when a film gets distribution in the US, Canada and UK, would then be it described as 'truly crossover'.

Bose also said that showing at international film festivals and coming back with a clutch of awards is not crossover. He strongly stated that language is no longer a barrier for a film to be accepted. You no longer need to make your film in English to appeal to an international audience.

For the future, he said that today it's early days and we as a film market have some way to go for one Lagaan doesn't make a summer. He said that just because Lagaan was taken into its fold the western audience won't just accept any and every film, especially our by-now-famous song-and-dance routines.

Last that for a film to really crossover, a filmmaker needs a good international sales agent who can pitch your film at the right places at the right time and that's something every Indian filmmaker who wishes to have a greater reach should take note of. And most importantly, at the end of the day, Bose urged all those who aspired to make films to make it just the way you want.

Ashutosh Gowariker who Nihalani described in one word as Lagaan felt that Madonna sporting bindis and henna tattoos, Nicole Kidman gyrating to a 'Chamma chamma' and films like Lagaan and Monsoon Wedding making the international market to sit up and take notice definitely indicate that India is poised for bigger things as far as cinema goes.

Gowariker also though expressed a doubt if our cinema has actually, completely achieved its true potential. He believed that any maker cannot plan a crossover film just like that just like one can't plan a hit film. He said that with the future looking brighter with video on demand, the paper-view mode of exhibition and convergence, Indian cinema would only get better. All said and done, he felt that we have to make films that have a strong cultural identity and only then will they appeal to the rest of the world.

As a distributor and dealer in Indian films, Robert Jones also expressed a need for filmmakers to keep their home address in mind before they ventured out to make crossover films. The success of which will be known only after finding out whether Indian cinema can actually sustain a minimum level of business.

Among other things Jones mentioned that audiences in the west look at other countries for a different experience in narrative style, culture and so on and therefore it was extremely important for filmmakers here to make films with a strong, national flavour. The key lies in not imitating but innovating.

However, the discussion ended on a note that film makers must make a film that they really want to make and not just cater to any one kind of audience' needs.

Latest Reads

2017 was a regulatory roller coaster and the ride continues

NEW DELHI: The year 2017 for the media industry certainly couldn’t be called easy from the point of doing business despite efforts and claims by the federal government that significant progress had been made in the regard.

Specials Year Enders
Guest column: Digital outlook for 2018

MUMBAI: The year 2017 is behind us and, as we peek into 2018, there is so much to look forward to. The digital landscape is so dynamic and ever-evolving that an annual trend-spotting article would be unfair. But still there are key areas where digital is heading and I can safely say that 2018 is...

Specials Year Enders
Content segmentation defines English entertainment, movies in 2017

MUMBAI: It was the year of HD for English entertainment in India. Add to it, the bump up in the number of movie premieres and series that you could now see in better quality. Increased adoption of HD set top boxes encouraged broadcasters to go for HD. Content segmentation has emerged as a big...

Specials Year Enders
DTH's year of consolidation

MUMBAI: It would be safe to say that this was the year of the big DTH challenge. India’s cable TV multi system operators (MSOs) could not go into many phase IV areas and DTH stepped in wherever analogue broadcast signals were switched off following the crossing of the digital addressable system (...

Specials Year Enders
2017 a year of rebranding and extending time slots for Hindi GECs

MUMBAI: The year 2017 was a roller-coaster ride for Hindi general entertainment channels (GEC) in the truest spirit of the term. The tussle for the top slot in the Broadcast Audience Research Council (BARC) ratings has seen pay TV and free-to-air (FTA) channels hold on tight to the rope.

Specials Year Enders
The year of hiccups for marketers

MUMBAI: The year 2017 was when brands were unwillingly thrown into a roller-coaster ride only to emerge dizzy and faint. The highs weren’t enough to ride out the lows.

Specials Year Enders
2017: The year OTTs went regional in India

MUMBAI: Over-the-top (OTT) services were undoubtedly the centre of attraction in 2017. The boom in India’s internet users, mainly aided by the growth of Reliance Jio, ensured that OTT players got the right reception and target audience. Not just  mainstream TV broadcasters but even smaller players...

Specials Year Enders
Making the news: A look at what news broadcasters did in 2017

MUMBAI: News channels were thrown into a storm of activity in 2017 with each player keeping up its oars to wade out of challenges that hit at them like ten-foot waves. With elections and sensational news driving up viewership at various points throughout the year, English news channels had to...

Specials Year Enders
Guest Column: The comeback of full-service agencies in India

By 2020, we will be close to a billion digitised screens. With the advent of cheaper data and smartphones and by virtue of tech giants such as Google, Facebook and Amazon entering the grassroots of India, digitisation has become inevitable. And it’s going to be mobile plus digitised television (...

Specials Year Enders

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories