Zee to move SC on TDAT's TataSky judgment

NEW DELHI: The Zee Group will knock on the doors of the Supreme Court challenging the TDSAT order that has said TataSky is obliged only to take 19 of their channels in bouquets 1 and 2, and has declared Zee a defaulter for not providing signals to TataSky on a non-discriminatory basis.


Asked whether they are moving the Supreme Court, a top Zee official said: "Of course we shall."

"This is a peculiar judgement, because it deals with only the factual positions of the two parties in the dispute in hand, which the judges have clearly said, and therefore, this judgement has not settled the law," the official, requesting anonymity, held.

"Besides, we are not defaulting on anything. The court had issued an interim order earlier, stating that we have to give TataSky our channels at 50 per cent of the cable charges, which we are doing already and have not defied that, so where are we defaulting?" the official queried.

He held also that TataSky is still being given all the 32 channels of Zee‘s five bouquets, and the order has only given the former the right to switch off the channels they do not want.

"Indeed, the quirk is that in their statements, TataSky had finally said they wanted 22 channels, not 19, which was their earlier demand, but the court has settled for 19. So there are a lot of grey areas that need to be settled."

Primarily what needs to be settled is the fact that the order, being centred around ‘facts of the case‘, has not settled the law.

"There are many statements made by our counsel that have not been taken into account," the official said.

Besides, the entire issue hangs on a central confusion: whether the regulator says that there is a "must carry" obligation in place. This is an issue in law, and hence, the Supreme Court would be approached on this issue, Zee officials said.

The case started with TataSky petitioning TDSAT that Zee Turner was forcing it to take all its 32 channels from five of their bouquets, but they needed only 19 which were popular ones, and could not afford to jam their limited transponder space with all 32 channels, most of which (as per their contention) were "junk channels".

The petition had been filed against Zee Turner, Zee Telefilms, Turner International and ASC Enterprises.

TataSky‘s contention was that the regulation stipulates that broadcasters "must provide… on a non-discriminatory basis" all the channels available with them, but the DTH operator could pick and choose the ones it wanted.

Zee had argued, inter alia, that the license conditions for any DTH licensee, which TataSky had to meet with, implied a statutory obligation of "must carry" all the channels of all the broadcasters that they seek to receive signals from.

TataSky later took recourse to an affidavit by the sector regulator, Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (Trai) that the specific clause 7.6 of the regulation did not mean a "must carry" obligation.


But Zee had placed several documents through which it had tried to show that the Trai affidavit was unfounded in facts and Trai‘s own previous orders.

However, the court felt: "We are unable to read a ‘must carry‘ provision in clause 7.6. A plain reading of clause 7.6 suggests that the obligation is cast on a Licensee to provide access to various content providers/channels on a non-discriminatory basis."

This will be one of the serious issues that would come up in the Supreme Court, and any order on this would impact the entire industry.

Latest Reads
HAL Robotics ropes in Navanit Samaiyar as board member and advisor

MUMBAI: HAL Robotics has roped in Navanit Samaiyar as its board member and advisor. Samaiyar has a record of setting up, scaling and transforming businesses across a very wide cross section of industries spanning from IT/ ITeS to steel, telecom, engineering goods, earthmoving machinery, logistics...

Technology Hardware Components
Republic TV launches Android app

MUMBAI: Republic TV is on a roll. From rocking the ratings chart in launch week itself to going international, the channel has added one more accomplishment to its kitty. The Republic TV Android app is now live.

Technology Software Applications
STB cos in India, China enhancing features, providing customised solutions, Technavio enlists top vendors

MUMBAI: The global STB market is characterised by intense competition as the market is saturated in developed countries. The market share of these players is declining because of the entry of new players. The STB companies are enhancing the features of STBs and providing customised solutions to...

Technology Hardware Set-top Boxes
India's PFT Clear Media ERP suite to help US' PBS content delivery

MUMBAI: Prime Focus Technologies (PFT), the technology arm of Prime Focus, announced that its CLEAR™ Media ERP Suite has been selected by Public Broadcasting Service (PBS) to enhance their Network Operations Center (NOC) ecosystem efficiencies and sustainability, with the objective of reducing...

Technology Software Applications
Broadcasters, OTTs to gain as Via adds xHE-AAC at special rate

MUMBAI: Via Licensing Corporation, a intellectual property solutions provider, has announced the upcoming availability of Extended High Efficiency AAC (xHE-AAC) as part of the Advanced Audio Coding (AAC) patent pool. The expanded patent pool licence will be available at no additional cost to...

Technology Software Applications
Tata Comm to deliver Motorsport videos on global devices

MUMBAI: Tata Communications will now deliver video content for viewers' all devices over its global network. The two have partnered to power the growth of the network’s internet television platforms.

Technology Software Applications
How to create live video content sans pros, convert radio broadcast into visual show

MUMBAI: ChyronHego will be showcasing its live production, automation solutions at Broadcast India show in Mumbai in mid-October.

Technology Software Applications
Sony renews IP licence deal with TiVo

MUMBAI: TiVo Corporation, a leader in entertainment technology and audience insights, has announced that Sony Corporation, a leader in consumer electronics, has renewed its multi-year intellectual property (IP) licence agreement. The license to TiVo’s patent portfolios covers all of Sony’s...

Technology Software Applications
Digital TV, growing telecom major drivers of coaxial cable growth in A-Pac: Study

MUMBAI: The global coaxial cables market is mature owing to the use of coaxial cables in industries for a long time and the slow or stagnant product innovation.

Technology Hardware Components

Latest News

Load More

Sign up for our Newsletter

subscribe for latest stories