|
MUMBAI: The story of We Are Family is adapted from the Hollywood film,
Step Mom. One wonders why borrow from there since the theme is a part of Indian
folklore as well as tradition!
 |
Producers:
Hiroo Yash Johar and Karan Johar Director: Siddharth Malhotra
Music: Shankar Ehasaan Loy Cast: Kajol, Kareena Kapoor, Arjun Rampal |
It
is a tradition which has been used in film stories in both cases such as, when
a married woman with a husband and kids is dying it is usually her sister who
takes her place. Same is the case when such married women cant beget an
offspring. The tradition works other way round too, in case of a male demise as
has been depicted in films like Ek Chadar Maili Si (Hindi) or Diyar
Vatu (Gujarati) to name two. So what is different about We Are
Family? We Are Family feign to be contemporary. In that the Indian
family lives in a foreign land (for no apparent reason). The couple (Kajol and
Arjun Rampal) with three kids is divorced but both care very much for the kids.
This situation makes it convenient for the man to fall for another woman (Kareena
Kapoor) and, since he cares a lot for his kids, also attempts to make his kids
accept the new woman in his life. Arjuns efforts to make his kids accept
Kareena fail as the children revolt. The
rest of the story is as predictable too. The divorced wife, Kajol, is diagnosed
with Cervical Cancer and given three months to live. So now it is her wanting
Kareena to enter her family and her children to accept her before her time runs
out! With
the story being so predictable, screenplay follows suit. There are no twists and
turns, no surprises, nothing that would make an Indian movie lover stir! While
the first half is boring, the second half adds some interest but not enough to
stop the tedium setting in. The narrative is as interesting as a school kids
zoo visit report! The
story requires mainly Kajol to perform, rest needed to just be their real selves.
Sadly, Kajol is one-dimensional here. Her chirpy, charming self is not a part
of the story; her hyper, insecure sad self runs through the film, which may be
good enough for critics but not her fans. What
is more, she looks jaded. Kareena Kapoor is okay. Arjun Rampal is a miscast; his
performance is fair. Kids are cute, endearing, defiant, pests in turns, as has
been seen in a hundred films. The music is noisy and wonders how many would identify
with the Elvis Presleys Jail House Rock! The film comes up with just one
funny dialogue when the father-son talks. The photography is good. We
Are Family has a sob story counting on Kajol to carry it off. She can't, it
is just not there in the script! Prospects look below par. |